Association between Sleep Duration and Physical Fitness in Children Aged 3–6 Years: A Cross-Sectional Study from China

Xin Xiong, Yinchen Cui, Weinan Zhang, Chenlin Zhao, Jiahui Wu, Haifeng Li, Zhiping Zhen, Jian SunInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This cross-sectional study of over 21,000 Chinese children aged 3-6 years reveals a significant inverted U-shaped relationship between sleep duration and physical fitness (PF). Both insufficient and excessive sleep are associated with lower PF, highlighting the importance of optimizing sleep schedules for healthy childhood development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Early childhood is a critical period for establishing healthy habits and physical development. While physical fitness (PF) in young children is generally improving, specific components like strength and flexibility are declining, raising public health concerns. Simultaneously, sleep disorders and abnormal sleep patterns are increasingly prevalent in early childhood, recognized as a global health issue. However, the precise relationship between sleep duration and the multifaceted aspects of PF in this age group remains underexplored. This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating how varying sleep durations impact overall PF and its specific components in Chinese children aged 3-6.

Methods

The study employed a cross-sectional design, utilizing data from the National Physical Fitness Measurement Standards Manual (NPFMSM) for preschool children in China. The researchers analyzed sleep duration data collected via questionnaires administered to parents and kindergarten teachers, and physical fitness data from standardized tests.

Key analytical techniques included:

  • Restricted Cubic Spline Model: Used to explore the dose-effect relationship between sleep duration and PF, specifically to identify non-linear associations like the inverted U-shape.
  • Binary Logistic Regression Analysis: Employed to assess the association between abnormal sleep duration (defined as insufficient or excessive) and the risk of having low levels of overall PF, body morphology (BM), and motor ability (MA), while controlling for confounding variables.
  • Partial Correlation Analysis: Utilized to examine the correlations between sleep duration and individual PF components (e.g., height, weight, jumping ability, speed) across different sleep categories (normal, insufficient, excessive).

Datasets

The study utilized a large dataset of 21,857 children aged 3-6 years from Guangdong Province, China, collected between 2018 and 2019. This data was derived from the National Physical Fitness Measurement Standards Manual (NPFMSM), a national initiative to systematically assess and monitor the physical fitness of Chinese children. The dataset included demographic information (age, gender, residence), sleep duration, and various physical fitness indicators.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Sweet Spot" for Sleep: The most striking finding is the inverted U-shaped association between sleep duration and PF. This suggests there's an optimal range of sleep for peak physical performance, and deviating from this range, either too little or too much, is detrimental.
  • Abnormal Sleep is a Risk Factor: Regardless of whether it's sleep deprivation or excessive sleep, both are linked to an increased risk of having lower physical fitness. This underscores that sleep quantity, not just quality, is crucial.
  • Components Matter: The study didn't just look at overall PF; it delved into body morphology (BM) and motor ability (MA). Both were negatively impacted by abnormal sleep, with BM showing a slightly higher risk increase.
  • Rural vs. Urban Sleep Patterns: Rural children in the study reported better sleep quality and a lower prevalence of sleep deprivation compared to their urban counterparts, suggesting potential environmental or lifestyle differences influencing sleep.
  • Aging and Sleep Decline: Sleep duration tends to decrease with age in children, and the rate of sleep deprivation increases, highlighting a potential challenge as children grow.

Key Results

  • Overall PF: The study found a high pass rate for PF (93.6%), with girls generally outperforming boys.
  • Abnormal Sleep Prevalence: 19.7% of children exhibited abnormal sleep duration (18.4% sleep deprivation, 1.3% excessive sleepiness).
  • Inverted U-Shape: The restricted cubic spline model showed a statistically significant inverted U-shaped association between PF and sleep duration (X² = 28.13, p < 0.0001).
  • Logistic Regression: After controlling for confounders, children with abnormal sleep duration had a 1.077 times higher risk of low PF, 1.077 times higher risk of low BM, and 1.035 times higher risk of low MA compared to those with normal sleep duration.
  • Partial Correlations: In the normal sleep group, sleep duration showed significant negative correlations with height, weight, standing long jump, and tennis throwing, but a positive correlation with the 10m shuttle run test. This indicates that within the normal range, longer sleep might slightly decrease some abilities while enhancing speed.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Cross-Sectional Design: This study cannot establish causality between sleep duration and PF. It only shows associations.
  • Subjective Sleep Data: Sleep duration was reported by parents and teachers, which may introduce measurement errors and bias compared to objective measures like actigraphy.
  • Focus on Duration: The study primarily focused on sleep duration and did not deeply explore other critical aspects like sleep quality, sleep disorders, or sleep hygiene practices, which could also influence PF.

Future work suggested by the authors includes:

  • Causal Inference: Conducting longitudinal studies to establish causal relationships.
  • Objective Measures: Incorporating objective sleep measurement tools.
  • Broader Sleep Factors: Investigating the impact of sleep quality, disorders, and behavioral patterns on PF.
  • Optimizing Sleep: Further research to determine the optimal sleep duration for different PF components and overall development.

Summary updated

Abstract

Aim: To explore associations between sleep duration and physical fitness (PF) of children aged 3−6 years. Methods: This study investigated the sleep duration and PF data of children aged 3−6 years by stratified random sampling. The restricted cubic spline model and binary logistic regression analysis were mainly used for the empirical analysis of the correlation effect between sleep duration and PF. The final data had a total of 21,857 children, of which 11,245 (51.45%) were boys and 10,612 (48.55%) were girls. Results: The PF level of the children in this study showed a relatively positive level (pass rate = 93.6%), and 19.7% of them had abnormal sleep duration; the results of the restricted cubic spline showed an inverted U-shaped association between the level of PF and the risk of abnormal sleep duration (X2 = 28.13, p < 0.0001). The results of logistic regression analysis showed that children with abnormal sleep duration were more likely to have a low PF, body morphology and motor ability levels at an OR (95% CI) of 1.077 (1.023−1.133), 1.077 (1.016−1.142) and 1.035 (1.08−1.062), respectively. The results of the bias correlation analysis showed varying degrees of correlation between sleep duration and various components of children’s PF. Conclusion: Insufficient or excessive amounts of sleep were significantly associated with PF in children, with abnormal sleep duration leading to reduced levels of PF and its components.
BibTeX
@article{xiong2022association,
  author = {Xin Xiong and Yinchen Cui and Weinan Zhang and Chenlin Zhao and Jiahui Wu and Haifeng Li and Zhiping Zhen and Jian Sun},
  title = {{Association between Sleep Duration and Physical Fitness in Children Aged 3–6 Years: A Cross-Sectional Study from China}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph19116902},
}
Figure