Association between Pregestational Vaginal Dysbiosis and Incident Hypertensive Disorders of Pregnancy Risk: a Nested Case-Control Study

Xiao Li, Zhaomei Tian, Ran Cui, Jiale Lv, Xin Yang, Lang Qin, Zheng Liu, Changlong Zhang, Congcong Jin, Yanqi Xu, Zi‐Jiang Chen, Han Zhao, Shigang ZhaomSphere 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that pre-pregnancy vaginal dysbiosis, specifically a lower abundance of Lactobacillus crispatus, is associated with an increased risk of developing hypertensive disorders of pregnancy (HDP). These findings suggest that characterizing the vaginal microbiome before pregnancy could help identify at-risk individuals and inform novel preventative strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Hypertensive disorders of pregnancy (HDP), including preeclampsia, are significant contributors to maternal and neonatal morbidity and mortality. While several risk factors are known, the precise etiology remains unclear, and effective individualized prediction and prevention methods are lacking. Emerging research points to the role of the microbiome in various pregnancy complications, but the specific link between the pregestational vaginal microbiome and HDP has not been thoroughly investigated. This study aims to fill this gap by prospectively examining the association between the vaginal microbial community before pregnancy and the subsequent development of HDP.

Methods

The researchers conducted a nested case-control study using a cohort of women undergoing assisted reproductive technology (ART). They collected vaginal swabs from 75 women who later developed HDP (cases) and 150 matched controls (NP group) before pregnancy. Bacterial identification was performed using 16S rRNA amplicon sequencing. Beyond analyzing the composition and diversity of the vaginal microbiome, the study employed advanced techniques:

  • Principal Coordinate Analysis (PCoA): To visualize and compare the overall microbial community structure between the HDP and NP groups.
  • Network Analysis (Cooccurrence Networks): To investigate the complex interactions and relationships between different bacterial taxa within the vaginal ecosystem, identifying "driver" taxa that might be responsible for shifts in the microbiome.
  • Functional Prediction (PICRUST): To infer the potential metabolic and functional capabilities of the microbial communities in each group.

Datasets

The study utilized vaginal swab samples from a cohort of 5,849 normotensive women undergoing IVF/ICSI at the Center for Reproductive Medicine, Shandong University. From this cohort, 75 women diagnosed with HDP and 150 matched controls were selected for the nested case-control analysis. The sequencing data generated from these samples forms the primary dataset for the study.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Pregestational Microbiome as a Predictor: The most significant insight is that the vaginal microbiome before pregnancy is not just a passive bystander but appears to be an active contributor to HDP risk. This shifts the focus to early, pre-conception interventions.
  • The Lactobacillus crispatus Protective Effect: The strong association between a L. crispatus-dominated vaginal community and a reduced risk of HDP is a crucial finding. This suggests that maintaining a healthy, Lactobacillus-rich vaginal environment might be a key protective mechanism.
  • Dysbiosis as a Risk Factor: Conversely, a shift away from L. crispatus and an increase in potentially pathogenic bacteria like Gardnerella vaginalis are linked to a higher HDP risk. This highlights the concept of vaginal dysbiosis as a potential etiological factor.
  • Beyond Abundance: Microbial Interactions Matter: The network analysis reveals that it's not just the presence or absence of specific bacteria, but also how they interact with each other, that is altered in women who develop HDP. This suggests a more complex ecosystem-level disruption.
  • Functional Differences: The predicted functional pathways highlight that the HDP group's microbiome may be geared towards bacterial virulence and inflammation, while the NP group's microbiome is associated with beneficial metabolic processes.

Key Results

  • Microbial Composition Differences: The vaginal microbial composition significantly differed between the HDP and NP groups (PERMANOVA, P = 0.037).
  • L. crispatus and G. vaginalis: Abundance of Lactobacillus crispatus was significantly lower (q = 0.046), and Gardnerella vaginalis was significantly higher (q = 0.046) in the HDP group compared to the NP group.
  • L. crispatus CST Protective Effect: Women with an L. crispatus-dominated vaginal community state type (CST) had a significantly decreased risk for HDP (odds ratio = 0.436; 95% CI, 0.229 to 0.831).
  • Network Rewiring: 61 unique edges were found in the NP group's cooccurrence network, and 57 in the HDP group, indicating significant differences in bacterial interactions. Several taxa, including G. vaginalis, L. iners, and bacterial vaginosis-associated bacteria, were identified as "drivers" of this network rewiring.
  • Functional Enrichment: The HDP group showed enrichment in pathways related to bacterial toxins and transporters, while the NP group was enriched in pathways for amino acid, cofactor, and vitamin metabolism.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sample Size: While the study is nested within a large cohort, the final case group consisted of only 75 women due to the relatively low incidence of HDP and exclusion criteria.
  • Population Specificity: The study participants were infertile women of Chinese Han ethnicity undergoing ART. Generalizing these findings to other populations or women with spontaneous pregnancies requires caution.
  • Causality: While the study demonstrates a strong association, it cannot definitively establish causality.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Larger, Multi-center Studies: To confirm these findings in more diverse populations.
  • Longitudinal Studies: To track microbiome changes throughout pregnancy.
  • Animal Models: To further elucidate the mechanisms by which vaginal dysbiosis contributes to HDP.
  • Intervention Studies: Exploring the efficacy of pregestational probiotic interventions targeting the vaginal microbiome for HDP prevention.

Summary updated

Abstract

A balanced vaginal microbiome dominated by <i>Lactobacillus</i> can help promote women's reproductive health, with Lactobacillus crispatus showing the most beneficial effect. However, the potential role of vaginal microbiomes in hypertensive disorders of pregnancy (HDP) development is not thoroughly explored. In this nested case-control study based on an assisted reproductive technology follow-up cohort, we prospectively assessed the association between pregestational vaginal microbiomes with HDP by collecting vaginal swabs from 75 HDP cases (HDP group) and 150 controls (NP group) and using 16S amplicon sequencing for bacterial identification. The vaginal microbial composition of the HDP group significantly differed from that of the NP group. The abundance of L. crispatus was significantly lower, and the abundances of Gardnerella vaginalis was significantly higher, in the HDP group than in the NP group. Of note, L. crispatus-dominated vaginal community state type was associated with a decreased risk for HDP (odds ratio = 0.436; 95% confidence interval, 0.229 to 0.831) compared with others. Additionally, network analysis revealed different bacterial interactions with 61 and 57 exclusive edges in the NP and HDP groups, respectively. Compared with the HDP group, the NP group showed a higher weighted degree and closeness centrality. Several taxa, including <i>G. vaginalis</i>, <i>L. iners</i>, and bacterial vaginosis-associated bacteria (<i>Prevotella</i>, <i>Megasphaera</i>, <i>Finegoldia</i>, and <i>Porphyromonas</i>), were identified as "drivers" for network rewiring. Notable alterations of predicted pathways involved in amino acid, cofactor, and vitamin metabolism; membrane transport; and bacterial toxins were observed in the HDP group. <b>IMPORTANCE</b> The etiology of HDP remains unclear to date. Effective methods for the individualized prediction and prevention are lacking. Pregestational vaginal dysbiosis precedes the diagnosis of HDP, providing a novel perspective on the etiology of HDP. Early pregnancy is the critical period of placental development, and abnormal placentation initiates HDP development. Thus, disease prevention should be considered before pregnancy. Vaginal microbiome characterization and probiotic interventions before pregnancy are preferred because of their safety and potential for early prevention. This study is the first to prospectively assess associations between pregestational vaginal microbiome and HDP. L. crispatus-dominated vaginal community state type is linked to a reduced risk for HDP. These findings suggest that vaginal microbiome characterization may help identify individuals at high risk for HDP and offer potential targets for the development of novel pregestational intervention methods.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2023association,
  author = {Xiao Li and Zhaomei Tian and Ran Cui and Jiale Lv and Xin Yang and Lang Qin and Zheng Liu and Changlong Zhang and Congcong Jin and Yanqi Xu and Zi‐Jiang Chen and Han Zhao and Shigang Zhao},
  title = {{Association between Pregestational Vaginal Dysbiosis and Incident Hypertensive Disorders of Pregnancy Risk: a Nested Case-Control Study}},
  booktitle = {mSphere},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1128/msphere.00096-23},
}
Figure