Assessment of Water Eutrophication at Bao’an Lake in the Middle Reaches of the Yangtze River Based on Multiple Methods

Mingkai Leng, Lian Feng, Xiaodong Wu, Xuguang Ge, Xiaowen Lin, Shixing Song, Rui Xu, Zhenhua SunInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study assesses the eutrophication status of Bao'an Lake in China using three distinct methods: the comprehensive trophic level index (TLI), CDOM absorption coefficients, and phytoplankton analysis. The findings reveal that Bao'an Lake is consistently in a eutrophic state, with significant seasonal and spatial variations, and identify key nutrient and organic matter indicators as primary drivers.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Lakes worldwide are facing increasing threats from pollution, leading to deteriorating water quality and widespread eutrophication. Eutrophication, characterized by excessive nutrient enrichment, can trigger harmful algal blooms, reduce dissolved oxygen, and disrupt aquatic ecosystems. While numerous methods exist for assessing eutrophication, a comprehensive understanding of a specific lake's condition, especially for less-studied shallow lakes like Bao'an Lake in the Yangtze River basin, is crucial for effective restoration. This paper addresses the need for a multi-faceted assessment of Bao'an Lake's eutrophication, considering its ecological and economic importance, and aims to provide a robust scientific basis for its ecological restoration.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-method approach to assess Bao'an Lake's eutrophication:

  • Comprehensive Trophic Level Index (TLI): This standard method integrates multiple water quality parameters (chlorophyll-a, total phosphorus, total nitrogen, Secchi depth, and permanganate index) into a single index to represent the overall trophic state. The TLI was calculated using established formulas, with chlorophyll-a serving as the benchmark parameter.
  • Chromophoric Dissolved Organic Matter (CDOM) Absorption Coefficient: CDOM absorbs UV and visible light, and its absorption coefficient at specific wavelengths (particularly 254 nm) is a proxy for the amount of dissolved organic matter, which is often linked to eutrophication. The study measured CDOM absorption spectra and calculated the absorption coefficient, using a specific method to correct for scattering.
  • Phytoplankton Water Quality Biological Method: This approach leverages the fact that different phytoplankton communities and densities are indicative of varying water quality and nutrient levels. The study analyzed phytoplankton cell density, Shannon-Wiener diversity index (H'), Margalef abundance index (D'), and Pielou evenness index (J') to assess eutrophication.

These methods were applied to monthly monitoring data collected from January 2018 to December 2020.

Datasets

The study utilized monthly water quality monitoring data collected from six sampling sites in Bao'an Lake, Hubei Province, China, spanning from January 2018 to December 2020. The data included measurements for:

  • Dissolved Oxygen (DO)
  • pH
  • Secchi Depth (SD)
  • Total Nitrogen (TN)
  • Total Phosphorus (TP)
  • Ammonia Nitrogen (NH3-N)
  • Chemical Oxygen Demand (Permanganate Index, CODMn)
  • Chlorophyll-a (Chl-a)
  • Chromophoric Dissolved Organic Matter (CDOM) absorption coefficient at 254 nm
  • Phytoplankton cell density and diversity indices (Shannon-Wiener, Margalef, Pielou)

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the study focused on analyzing existing data using established methodologies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Multi-method validation is key: Different assessment methods yielded slightly varied results, highlighting the importance of using multiple approaches for a robust understanding of lake health. No single method tells the whole story.
  • Seasonal dynamics are pronounced: Bao'an Lake's eutrophication is not static. It's significantly worse in warmer months (summer and autumn) and improves in cooler months (winter and spring). This seasonality is linked to the life cycle of the dominant aquatic plant.
  • Aquatic plants are double-edged swords: Potamogeton crispus, the dominant submerged plant, seems to improve water quality when actively growing in spring. However, its decomposition in summer and autumn releases nutrients, exacerbating eutrophication.
  • Land use matters: Intensive fishponds and agricultural land surrounding the lake are identified as major contributors to nutrient loading and eutrophication, underscoring the need for watershed management.

Key Results

  • Consistent Eutrophication: Across all three assessment methods, Bao'an Lake was found to be in a eutrophic state throughout the 2018-2020 period, with water quality generally ranging from Class III to V.
  • TLI Trends: The comprehensive trophic level index (TLI) showed interannual variations between 51.68 and 57.98, indicating a trend of increasing then decreasing eutrophication over the study period. The highest TLI values were consistently observed in autumn.
  • CDOM Spatial Patterns: CDOM absorption coefficients indicated higher eutrophication in the southern parts of the lake compared to the north.
  • Phytoplankton Insights: While algae cell density suggested moderate to high eutrophication, phytoplankton diversity indices pointed towards a medium eutrophication level. This discrepancy highlights the complexity of biological assessments.
  • Dominant Factors: CODMn, TP, TN, and Chl-a were identified as the primary factors influencing Bao'an Lake's eutrophication. A strong correlation was found between Chl-a and TP (p < 0.01).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Methodological Discrepancies: The paper acknowledges that different assessment methods produced slightly different results, suggesting the need for further research to reconcile these discrepancies and develop a unified assessment framework.
  • Seasonal Plant Decomposition: The study highlights the negative impact of Potamogeton crispus decomposition on water quality. Future work could explore strategies to manage or mitigate this effect, perhaps through controlled harvesting or alternative aquatic vegetation management.
  • Land Use Impact: The significant role of intensive fishponds and agriculture in driving eutrophication calls for targeted watershed management interventions. Future research could focus on quantifying the specific contributions of different land-use types and developing effective mitigation strategies.
  • Spatial Variability: While spatial patterns were observed, further investigation into the drivers of these variations, particularly the high eutrophication in the south, could inform localized restoration efforts.

Summary updated

Abstract

Based on the monthly monitoring of Bao'an Lake in Hubei Province from 2018 to 2020, the eutrophication level of Bao'an Lake in the middle reaches of the Yangtze River is investigated using the comprehensive trophic level index (TLI), chromophoric dissolved organic matter (CDOM) absorption coefficient, and the phytoplankton water quality biological method. The influencing factors are then identified. The results demonstrate that the overall water quality of Bao'an Lake remained at levels III-V during 2018-2020. Due to different eutrophication assessment methods, the results are different, but all show that Bao'an Lake is in a eutrophication state as a whole. The eutrophication level of Bao'an Lake is observed to vary with time, exhibiting an increasing then decreasing trend between 2018-2020, while levels are high in summer and autumn, and low in winter and spring. Moreover, the eutrophication level of Bao'an Lake presents an obviously varying spatial distribution. <i>Potamogeton crispus</i> is the dominant species of the Bao'an Lake, the water quality is good in spring when <i>Potamogeton crispus</i> vigorously grows, but poor in summer and autumn. The permanganate index (COD<sub>Mn</sub>) and total phosphorous (TP), total nitrogen (TN), and chlorophyll a (Chl-a) contents are identified as the main influencing factors of the eutrophication level of Bao'an Lake, with a significant relationship observed between Chl-a and TP (<i>p</i> < 0.01). The above results provide a solid theoretical basis for the ecological restoration of Bao'an Lake.
BibTeX
@article{leng2023assessment,
  author = {Mingkai Leng and Lian Feng and Xiaodong Wu and Xuguang Ge and Xiaowen Lin and Shixing Song and Rui Xu and Zhenhua Sun},
  title = {{Assessment of Water Eutrophication at Bao’an Lake in the Middle Reaches of the Yangtze River Based on Multiple Methods}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph20054615},
}
Figure