Assessment of Urban Flood Vulnerability Using the Integrated Framework and Process Analysis: A Case from Nanjing, China

Peng Wang, Yifan Zhu, Ping YuInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study presents an integrated framework for assessing urban flood vulnerability (UFV) in Nanjing, China, by combining multiple indicators and analyzing their spatial-temporal dynamics and interrelationships. The findings highlight that vegetation coverage, precipitation, population density, and road density are key drivers of UFV, and reveal complex pathways through which these factors influence vulnerability across different districts.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Urban flooding is a growing global concern, exacerbated by climate change and rapid urbanization. While assessing urban flood vulnerability (UFV) is crucial for effective risk management, existing studies often face limitations. These include a lack of integration of diverse indicators, insufficient exploration of spatial and temporal trends, and a limited understanding of the underlying mechanisms driving vulnerability. Specifically, many assessments focus on vulnerability scores without delving into how different factors interact and influence each other, hindering the development of targeted mitigation strategies. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a comprehensive UFV assessment framework that not only quantifies vulnerability but also elucidates the complex relationships between contributing factors.

Methods

The study employs an integrated approach to assess UFV, combining geographic information system (GIS) and remote sensing techniques with a novel process analysis method.

  • Integrated Framework: A composite index was developed using 18 indicators across six categories: physical, economic, community, nature, population, and political.
  • Indicator Extraction: GIS and ENVI (Environment for Visualizing Images) were used to extract indicators with geographic attributes, such as impermeable surface area and fractional vegetation cover.
  • Standardization and Weighting: Indicators were standardized using the Min-Max method. Objective weighting was achieved using the entropy method, which is considered more credible and accurate than subjective methods.
  • Vulnerability Scoring: A final UFV score was calculated based on the weighted indicators.
  • Process Analysis: This novel aspect of the study involved analyzing the "drive mechanism pathways" between indicators. This was achieved through mediation effect testing, which examines how the effect of one variable on another is realized through an intermediary variable. This allowed for the identification of indirect relationships and the complex interplay of factors contributing to UFV.

Datasets

The study utilized data for the Xuanwu-Qinhuai-Jianye-Gulou-Yuhua (XQJGY) region in Nanjing, China, from 2012 to 2018. Specific data sources included:

  • Statistical Yearbooks: 2012-2018 statistical yearbooks of Nanjing and its districts (Xuanwu, Jianye, Yuhua, Gulou, Qinhuai), as well as historical almanacs. These provided data for economic, population, and political indicators.
  • Remote Sensing Data: MODIS land cover data and U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) network data were used for extracting physical indicators like impermeable surface area and vegetation coverage.
  • Geographic Information System (GIS): GIS was used extensively for spatial analysis, mapping, and integrating various datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Interconnectedness of Factors: The most significant insight is the revelation of complex, indirect pathways through which various indicators influence UFV. It's not just about individual indicator values, but how they interact.
  • Vegetation as a Double-Edged Sword: While vegetation coverage is generally seen as beneficial for flood mitigation, this study suggests it can also indirectly increase UFV by promoting population density. This highlights the need for nuanced planning.
  • Urbanization's Impact: The study underscores how rapid urbanization, leading to increased impermeable surfaces and altered land use, significantly contributes to flood vulnerability.
  • District-Specific Vulnerabilities: The analysis reveals that the drivers and pathways of UFV differ across the five districts, emphasizing the need for tailored mitigation strategies rather than a one-size-fits-all approach.

Key Results

  • Temporal Trends: UFV generally showed a decreasing trend in Xuanwu, Qinhuai, and Gulou from 2012-2018. Jianye and Yuhua experienced an increase in UFV from 2012-2015, followed by a decrease.
  • Top Contributing Indicators: Vegetation coverage, precipitation during the flood season, population density, and road density were consistently identified as the top contributors to UFV across the districts.
  • Impermeable Surface Area: This indicator was a dominant factor in UFV for Xuanwu (16.33% contribution) and Qinhuai (13.06% contribution).
  • Mediation Effects:
    • In Xuanwu, "vegetation coverage → population density → flood vulnerability" was a significant mediating pathway.
  • In Qinhuai, "fixed investment → population density → flood vulnerability" was significant.
  • In Yuhua, "per capita GDP → road density → flood vulnerability" showed a mediating effect, while "per capita GDP → flood vulnerability" had a direct effect.
  • In Jianye, "per capita GDP → population density → flood vulnerability" was significant, as was the direct effect of "per capita GDP → flood vulnerability."
    • In Gulou, "fixed investment → per capita GDP → flood vulnerability" was significant, as was the direct effect of "fixed investment → flood vulnerability."

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Granularity: While the study uses detailed data, the resolution of some remote sensing data might limit the precision of fine-grained urban features.
  • Model Complexity: The process analysis, while insightful, involves complex statistical modeling. Further validation and exploration of alternative modeling approaches could be beneficial.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring the interaction mechanisms of cities within the XQJGY region in more detail. They also recommend further research into the cascading effects and interplay between different types of flooding (e.g., fluvial vs. pluvial) and the use of flood simulation and modeling to test the influence of vulnerability indicators. The integration of blue-green infrastructure (BGI) as a mitigation strategy is also highlighted as a crucial area for future consideration.

Summary updated

Abstract

Flooding is a serious challenge that increasingly affects residents as well as policymakers. Many studies have noted that decreasing the urban flood vulnerability (UFV) is an indispensable strategy for reducing flood risks; however, some studies have several pertinent assessment limitations. The objective of this study is to assess the UFV of the Xuanwu-Qinhuai-Jianye-Gulou-Yuhua (XQJGY) region from 2012 to 2018 by integrating various indicators into a composite index. This study uses the environment for visualizing images (ENVI) and the geographic information system (GIS) to extract indicators that have geographic attributes for the assessment of UFV and the process analysis method is then used to explore the relationship between these indicators. The results indicated that: (1) The UFV of Xuanwu, Qinhuai, and Gulou decreased from 2012 to 2018 and the UFV of Jianye and Gulou increased from 2012 to 2015 and decreased from 2015 to 2018. (2) The vegetation coverage, precipitation during the flood season, population density, and highway density significantly contributed to the UFV. (3) There also exist transformation pathways between the indicators that led to vulnerability in five districts. This study provides a theoretical basis for the government to manage floods.
BibTeX
@article{wang2022assessment,
  author = {Peng Wang and Yifan Zhu and Ping Yu},
  title = {{Assessment of Urban Flood Vulnerability Using the Integrated Framework and Process Analysis: A Case from Nanjing, China}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph192416595},
}
Figure