Assessment of the osteogenic effect after maxillary sinus floor elevation and simultaneous implantation with or without bone grafts by analyzing trabecular bone parameters: a retrospective study

Mohan Wang, Beibei Li, Hailiang Feng, Qingsong Ye, Yahui Sun, Xinxiu Duan, Jiacai HeJournal of Applied Oral Science 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates whether bone grafts are necessary for successful maxillary sinus floor elevation (MSFE) and simultaneous dental implantation. Using advanced CT analysis, they found that while bone grafts aid in implant encapsulation, they actually hinder the formation of high-quality bone. The absence of grafts, conversely, leads to better bone quality, albeit with less bone mass.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Restoring dental implants in the posterior maxilla is often challenging due to insufficient bone volume and density, frequently caused by sinus pneumatization. Maxillary sinus floor elevation (MSFE) is a common solution, but there's ongoing debate about the necessity of using bone grafts during this procedure. While bone grafts can provide space for bone growth and improve implant stability, some research suggests they might negatively impact the quality of newly formed bone. Existing clinical assessments of MSFE primarily focus on implant survival and marginal bone loss, with fewer studies delving into the actual quality of the regenerated bone. This paper aims to fill that gap by quantitatively analyzing the microstructure of newly formed bone after MSFE, with or without bone grafts, in a human population.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective cohort study involving 100 patients who underwent MSFE and simultaneous dental implantation. Patients were divided into two groups: 50 who received bone grafts (deproteinized bovine bone matrix) and 50 who did not.

The key methodological innovation lies in their use of cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT) combined with specialized software called CTAn (CTAnalyzer). While CBCT is a standard imaging technique, CTAn is a micro-CT analysis software that can differentiate between newly formed bone and non-degraded bone grafts based on grayscale values. This allows for a quantitative analysis of trabecular bone parameters, offering a non-invasive way to assess bone microstructure.

Specific trabecular bone parameters analyzed included:

  • Bone Volume/Total Volume (BV/TV): The proportion of bone within a given volume.
  • Bone Surface/Total Volume (BS/TV): The amount of bone surface relative to the total volume.
  • Trabecular Number (Tb. N): The average number of trabeculae per unit length.
  • Trabecular Thickness (Tb. Th): The average thickness of the trabeculae.
  • Trabecular Separation (Tb. Sp): The average distance between trabeculae.

These parameters were measured in specific regions of interest around the implant root using CTAn software.

Datasets

The study utilized CBCT scans from 100 patients collected at the Stomatological Hospital of Anhui Medical University between January 2021 and August 2022. These scans served as the primary dataset for quantitative analysis. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bone Grafts Hinder Quality: The most striking finding is that while bone grafts facilitate better implant encapsulation, they significantly impede the formation of high-quality bone. This is evidenced by lower BV/TV, BS/TV, Tb. N, and Tb. Th in the graft group.
  • No Grafts, Better Quality: Conversely, the absence of bone grafts led to superior bone quality, characterized by a higher proportion of bone volume, denser trabecular structure, and thicker trabeculae.
  • Trade-off Between Quality and Quantity: The non-graft group achieved better bone quality but with less bone mass (lower BV/TV). The graft group, while having poorer bone quality, showed greater gained bone height (GBH), suggesting that grafts contribute to overall bone volume, even if it's of lower quality.
  • CTAn as a Powerful Tool: The study highlights CTAn software as a valuable, non-invasive tool for quantitatively assessing bone microstructure after MSFE in humans, offering a more objective evaluation than previous methods.

Key Results

  • Trabecular Bone Parameters: The non-graft group showed significantly higher BV/TV (62.46% vs. 35.47%), BS/TV (3.69 vs. 2.92 mm²/mm³), Tb. N (0.85 vs. 0.56 mm⁻¹), and Tb. Th (0.74 vs. 0.62 mm) compared to the graft group (all p<0.001). The non-graft group also had lower Tb. Sp (0.63 vs. 0.70 mm, p<0.01).
  • Complications: The graft group experienced a higher incidence of perforation (16% vs. 4%, p=0.046) and bleeding (22% vs. 6%, p<0.05) compared to the non-graft group. Infectious complications did not differ significantly.
  • Bone Height: The graft group showed significantly greater postoperative bone height (PBH) (11.97 mm vs. 7.78 mm), gained bone height (GBH) (8.10 mm vs. 1.94 mm), and apical bone height (ABH) (2.36 mm vs. -1.70 mm) compared to the non-graft group (all p<0.001).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Short Follow-up Periods: The follow-up periods were relatively short and varied among patients.
  • Need for Long-Term Data: They emphasize the need for longer-term follow-up to fully understand the impact of MSFE with bone grafts on osteogenic effects and implant survival rates.

Future research directions include:

  • Optimizing Bone Grafts: Continued development of innovative bone grafts and regenerative medicine approaches to achieve better bone quality and quantity in the maxillary sinus.
  • Long-Term Implant Outcomes: Investigating the long-term survival rates and success of implants placed with and without bone grafts.
  • Further Validation of CTAn: Continued exploration of CTAn's utility for jawbone analysis.

Summary updated

Abstract

MSFE with and without bone grafts can significantly improve bone formation. In MSFE, the use of bone grafts hinders the formation of good quality bone, whereas the absence of bone grafts can generate good bone quality and limited bone mass.
BibTeX
@article{wang2024assessment,
  author = {Mohan Wang and Beibei Li and Hailiang Feng and Qingsong Ye and Yahui Sun and Xinxiu Duan and Jiacai He},
  title = {{Assessment of the osteogenic effect after maxillary sinus floor elevation and simultaneous implantation with or without bone grafts by analyzing trabecular bone parameters: a retrospective study}},
  journal = {Journal of Applied Oral Science},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1590/1678-7757-2023-0406},
}
Figure