Abstract
Angiogenesis is a highly ordered physiological process critical for tissue engineering to ensure construct survival post-transplantation. This study introduces a novel 3D in vitro dynamic model to evaluate pro-angiogenic agents under physiologically relevant conditions. We compared the angiogenic potential of 2-deoxy-D-ribose (2dDR) with vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF). Results from conventional 2D assays and the new 3D model demonstrate that 2dDR significantly promotes endothelial cell proliferation, migration, and infiltration, especially when combined with dynamic fluid flow, making it a cost-effective alternative to traditional growth factors.
Introduction
The rapid neovascularization of tissue-engineered constructs remains the "holy grail" of the field. While pro-angiogenic agents offer a solution, current testing models are often insufficient. Standard 2D in vitro assays are fast but lack structural complexity and mechanical stimuli like shear stress. Conversely, in vivo animal models are realistic but ethically complex, expensive, and time-consuming. This research addresses this gap by developing a 3D bilayer tubular model that simulates both the architecture of a blood vessel and the dynamic mechanical environment of blood flow.
Materials and Methods
The study utilized a custom-fabricated bilayer tubular scaffold to mimic the vascular environment and a 3D-printed bioreactor for dynamic testing.
Scaffold Fabrication
The scaffold consists of two distinct layers designed to simulate the vessel wall:
- Inner Layer: PHBV nanofibers produced via rotational electrospinning to mimic the basement membrane, providing a tight surface for Human Aortic Endothelial Cell (HAEC) attachment.
- Outer Layer: A highly porous PCL PolyHIPE (polymerized high internal phase emulsion) tube. Its large, interconnected pores allow cells to migrate outward from the inner layer, simulating tissue infiltration.
The layers were joined using a "shrink-fit" technique: the PolyHIPE tube was swollen in ethanol, the inner PHBV tube was inserted, and the assembly was transferred to water, causing the outer tube to shrink and create a tight mechanical bond.
Dynamic Bioreactor System
A custom 3D-printed bioreactor was developed to house the bilayer tubes. The system was connected to a pump to provide controlled shear stress (1, 2, or 10 dyn/cm²), simulating physiological flow conditions. The chambers are highly accessible, costing approximately $15 each to produce.
Results and Discussion
2D Comparative Assays
Initial testing using standard 2D assays confirmed that 2dDR is a potent angiogenic agent. At an optimal concentration of 100 µM, 2dDR doubled cell numbers by day 7 and increased capillary-like tube formation by 1.8-fold, achieving approximately 95% of the potency of the gold-standard VEGF (80 ng/mL). However, high concentrations (10 mM) were found to be cytotoxic, causing cell detachment.
3D Dynamic Model Performance
The 3D model revealed a significant synergistic effect between chemical stimulation (2dDR) and mechanical stimuli (flow):
- Cell Infiltration: Under static conditions, 2dDR-treated cells migrated ~182 µm into the porous outer scaffold. Under a low flow rate of 2 dyn/cm², this infiltration distance increased dramatically to ~780 µm.
- Cell Density: The combination of 2dDR and optimal flow resulted in a 3.8-fold increase in cell density compared to static controls.
- Flow Sensitivity: Flow rates of 10 dyn/cm² were found to be too high, preventing stable monolayer formation by washing away cells.
Mechanistic Insights
Unlike exogenous VEGF, which acts as a direct ligand, 2dDR appears to work by inducing controlled oxidative stress. This triggers the cells to secrete their own endogenous growth factors, such as VEGF and IL-8, promoting a more natural angiogenic response.
Conclusion and Future Directions
The novel 3D dynamic model provides a cost-effective and physiologically relevant platform for testing pro-angiogenic agents. While the current study focused on a single cell type over 7 days, future iterations incorporating co-cultures and longer durations will further enhance its predictive value for in vivo success.
Summary updated