Assessment of ownership of smart devices and the acceptability of digital health data sharing

Md. Mobashir Hasan Shandhi, Karnika Singh, Natasha Janson, Perisa Ashar, Geetika Singh, Baiying Lu, D. Sunshine Hillygus, Jennifer Maddocks, Jessilyn P. DunnNpj Digit. Medicine 2024 · OpenReview

Abstract

Smart portable devices—smartphones and smartwatches—are rapidly being adopted by the general population, offering opportunities to use physiological and behavioral data for research and clinical monitoring. However, reliance on "Bring Your Own Device" (BYOD) models may introduce biases. This study characterizes smart device ownership, usage, and data-sharing willingness among 1,368 patients from a southeastern US academic health system. While smartphone ownership was nearly universal (98%), wearable ownership (59%) varied significantly by demographic factors. Fifty percent of owners were willing to share data for research, with acceptability varying by data type and demographic group. These findings highlight the need for equitable study designs in digital health.

Introduction

The "Bring Your Own Device" (BYOD) model is transforming digital health research by enabling the collection of real-world data (RWD) in naturalistic settings. This approach is cost-effective and provides a more naturalistic view of health than laboratory settings. However, a significant challenge remains: if researchers rely exclusively on devices participants already own, they risk excluding underrepresented populations. This exclusion can lead to biased algorithms and inequitable healthcare technologies. This study investigates the demographics of device ownership and the willingness of patients to share their data to inform more inclusive research designs.

Methods

Researchers conducted an electronic survey of the Duke Health Listens (DHL) patient advisory group in January 2022. Out of 3,021 members, 1,368 (45%) responded. The survey instrument covered device ownership (e.g., iPhone vs. Android), usage frequency, reasons for non-ownership, and willingness to share data for research. Statistical analyses, including Chi-square tests and Benjamini-Hochberg corrections, were used to identify demographic associations. Findings were compared against national benchmarks from the Pew Research Center and the Health Information National Trends Survey (HINTS).

Smartphone ownership was nearly ubiquitous at 98%, with a preference for iPhones (66.6%) over Android devices (33.2%). In contrast, wearable ownership stood at 59%, dominated by Apple Watch (44%) and Fitbit (42%).

Ownership patterns revealed significant demographic divides. Generation Z (ages 18–25), individuals with higher education, and full-time employees were the most likely to own wearables. Conversely, wearable ownership dropped sharply with age, falling to 39% for those 77 and older.

Demographic breakdown of smartphone and wearable ownership across gender, age, race, education, and employment status.

Insights: Barriers and Data Sharing Acceptability

The study identified a "Usage Paradox": while women were significantly more likely to own a wearable than men (62% vs. 53%), men reported higher regular usage on both weekdays and weekends.

Barriers to ownership were highly demographic-specific. Cost was the primary deterrent for women (31% overall), whereas a "lack of interest in tracking" was more common among White, Asian, and Hispanic participants compared to Black participants. Privacy concerns also showed racial disparities, being significantly more important to White respondents (15%) than Black respondents (4%).

Primary reasons cited by respondents for not owning a wearable device, with cost and lack of interest being the leading factors.

Willingness to share data was not uniform. While 50% of owners were definitively willing to share data for research, another 32% would "consider" it. Comfort levels varied by data type: participants were most willing to share fitness data (69%) but more hesitant to share self-reported measures like mood or food logs (50%).

Limitations and Future Directions

The study's primary limitation is its focus on a single academic health system's patient advisory group, which may be more tech-literate than the general population. Additionally, the lack of specific income data limits the analysis of economic barriers.

Future research must address the evolving legal landscape regarding data privacy, particularly for sensitive health data. The research team also plans to compare self-reported usage data with actual device logs to improve the accuracy of survey-based digital health research. These efforts are crucial for developing equitable digital health technologies that serve diverse populations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Smart portable devices- smartphones and smartwatches- are rapidly being adopted by the general population, which has brought forward an opportunity to use the large volumes of physiological, behavioral, and activity data continuously being collected by these devices in naturalistic settings to perform research, monitor health, and track disease. While these data can serve to revolutionize health monitoring in research and clinical care, minimal research has been conducted to understand what motivates people to use these devices and their interest and comfort in sharing the data. In this study, we aimed to characterize the ownership and usage of smart devices among patients from an expansive academic health system in the southeastern US and understand their willingness to share data collected by the smart devices. We conducted an electronic survey of participants from an online patient advisory group around smart device ownership, usage, and data sharing. Out of the 3021 members of the online patient advisory group, 1368 (45%) responded to the survey, with 871 female (64%), 826 and 390 White (60%) and Black (29%) participants, respectively, and a slight majority (52%) age 58 and older. Most of the respondents (98%) owned a smartphone and the majority (59%) owned a wearable. In this population, people who identify as female, Hispanic, and Generation Z (age 18–25), and those completing higher education and having full-time employment, were most likely to own a wearable device compared to their demographic counterparts. 50% of smart device owners were willing to share and 32% would consider sharing their smart device data for research purposes. The type of activity data they are willing to share varies by gender, age, education, and employment. Findings from this study can be used to design both equitable and cost-effective digital health studies, leveraging personally-owned smartphones and wearables in representative populations, ultimately enabling the development of equitable digital health technologies.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shandhi2024assessment,
  author = {Md. Mobashir Hasan Shandhi and Karnika Singh and Natasha Janson and Perisa Ashar and Geetika Singh and Baiying Lu and D. Sunshine Hillygus and Jennifer Maddocks and Jessilyn P. Dunn},
  title = {{Assessment of ownership of smart devices and the acceptability of digital health data sharing}},
  booktitle = {Npj Digit. Medicine},
  year = {2024},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=Xdpt2Bd8nM},
}

Loading related content...

Figure