Assessment of Organic Matter Influence on the Ecological Integrity of Poyang Lake Using O/E Model and Chemical–Biological Indices over the Past Two Decades

Jindong Wang, Wenjie Huang, Chenglian Feng, Hongyang WangToxics 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study presents a novel combined approach using the O/E (Observation/Expectation) model and a chemical-biological composite index to assess the ecological integrity of China's largest freshwater lake, Poyang Lake, over two decades (1998-2022). The findings reveal a generally "sub-healthy" to "average" ecological status, highlighting the need for targeted conservation efforts to protect its vital ecosystem functions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Poyang Lake, a critical freshwater ecosystem in China, faces significant ecological challenges due to over-exploitation of water resources, urbanization, and pollution. Assessing its ecological integrity is crucial for understanding the impact of these pressures and guiding conservation strategies. While various methods exist, this paper addresses the need for a more comprehensive and long-term evaluation that integrates both biological and chemical indicators, moving beyond single-method assessments. The authors aim to provide a robust framework for understanding the lake's ecological health trends over an extended period.

Methods

The study employs a two-pronged approach:

  • O/E (Observation/Expectation) Model: This method, adapted from the RIVPACS system, uses benthic macroinvertebrate data. It compares the observed species richness at a monitoring site with the expected richness based on reference sites that are considered minimally disturbed. The model was refined using a Random Forest approach to predict reference point groups and calculate species probabilities of capture. Different probability thresholds (0 or 0.5) were used to calculate the O/E index, with values closer to 1 indicating better ecological health.
  • Chemical-Biological Composite Index: This index integrates multiple chemical parameters (total nitrogen, total phosphorus, dissolved oxygen, ammonia nitrogen, and permanganate index) and biological indicators (total taxonomic units, biodiversity index, and dominance index of benthic macroinvertebrates). Each indicator is standardized, and then combined using a weighted average method to derive a comprehensive score reflecting the overall ecological health.

A key novelty is the combination of these two methods and their application to over 20 years of data, offering a more objective and comprehensive assessment than either method alone.

Datasets

  • Benthic Fauna and Water Quality Data: Collected from 11 sampling points in Poyang Lake over a 20-year period (1998-2022).
  • Historical Data: Supplemented with data from the Institute of Aquatic Sciences, Chinese Academy of Sciences.
  • Natural Predictors: Geomorphological factors (lake area, shoreline length, average water depth, retention time) and climatic factors (average temperature, average rainfall) were also considered.
  • WorldClim Data: Used for historical climatic data from 1998-2022.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Benthic Community Simplification: The benthic community in Poyang Lake is characterized by low biodiversity and a simple structure, dominated by Insecta (Arthropoda) and Oligochaeta (Annelida). This suggests a simplified ecosystem response to environmental pressures.
  • Long-Term Ecological Stability (with caveats): Despite significant environmental pressures, the O/E model indicated a largely "sub-healthy" or "average" ecological status over the two decades, suggesting a degree of resilience and self-repairing capacity in the ecosystem.
  • Seasonal Fluctuations in Health: The chemical-biological composite index revealed distinct seasonal patterns, with better ecological health observed in the first quarter (Spring) due to increased rainfall and self-purification, and declining health in the fourth quarter (Winter) attributed to reduced water mobility and increased human activities.
  • Synergistic Assessment: The combined O/E and chemical-biological index approach provides a more comprehensive and objective evaluation, with results from both methods showing good agreement and mutual validation. This dual approach is highlighted as a novel contribution.
  • Biodiversity as a Key to Restoration: The paper emphasizes that protecting and restoring biodiversity is crucial for enhancing the resilience and ecological balance of Poyang Lake's aquatic ecosystem.

Key Results

  • O/E Model: The O/E index consistently showed "sub-healthy" or "average" health grades across most sampling points from 1998 to 2022. Point P6 exhibited a persistent "sub-healthy" status, while point P11 showed fluctuating changes due to its unique location at the lake's inlet.
  • Chemical-Biological Composite Index: The overall health status was generally "sub-healthy" or "general." Seasonal trends showed Q1 (Spring) > Q4 (Autumn/Winter) > Q2 (Summer) > Q3 (Autumn).
  • Dominant Benthic Groups: Insecta (Arthropoda) constituted 84.3% of the Arthropoda, and Oligochaeta constituted 42.4% of the Annelida. Mollusca represented 47.7% of the total taxonomic units.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Reference Site Selection: The authors acknowledge the difficulty in finding truly uncontaminated natural areas for reference sites in China, which can impact the accuracy of the O/E model. The number of reference points also influences accuracy.
  • Data Limitations: While the study covers two decades, the authors note that the accuracy of the O/E model is affected by objective factors and that in-depth research on technology and methodology is still needed for accurate river health evaluation.
  • Future Work: The study suggests that protecting biodiversity is a key factor for restoration. Further research could focus on developing more refined monitoring networks and ecological restoration strategies for rivers entering the lake. Improving sewage treatment efficiency and promoting environmentally friendly agricultural practices are also highlighted as crucial for protecting water quality and the ecological environment. The authors propose their combined method as a theoretical basis and technical support for future lake water environment quality evaluations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Ecological integrity, encompassing physical, chemical, and biological aspects, is crucial for sustaining ecosystem service functions and stability. As the largest freshwater lake in China, the ecological integrity of Poyang Lake has attracted much attention due to the over-exploitation of its water resources in recent years. In this study, several biological and water quality surveys on water ecological conditions were carried out at 11 sampling points of Poyang Lake from 1998 to 2022, and the ecological health of Poyang Lake was evaluated by use of the O/E (Observation/Expectation) model and the chemical-biological index method according to the status of the water quality and the structure of the benthic fauna in the four seasons, respectively. The results showed that the benthic community structure is simple, and the biodiversity is low, which is mainly dominated by Insecta in Arthropoda and Oligochaeta in Oroidea, accounting for 84.3% and 42.4%, respectively; the results of the O/E index evaluated under the threshold of probability of capture ≥ 0.5 showed that the health grade of all sections was sub-healthy or average, which was consistent with the results of the chemical-biological composite index evaluation. The dual evaluation method of the O/E model and chemical-biological composite index adopted in this study integrates more than twenty years of long-time scale data; this method combined with long time scale data has not been studied before, and its advantage is that it can more objectively show the change in the ecological situation of Poyang Lake for many years. The results of the present study could provide a theoretical basis and technical support for the evaluation of lake water environment quality.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2024assessment,
  author = {Jindong Wang and Wenjie Huang and Chenglian Feng and Hongyang Wang},
  title = {{Assessment of Organic Matter Influence on the Ecological Integrity of Poyang Lake Using O/E Model and Chemical–Biological Indices over the Past Two Decades}},
  booktitle = {Toxics},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/toxics13010001},
}
Figure