Assessment of efficiency of arm force only versus arm force plus wrist movement during closed method extractions

Shivendra Choudhary, Abhishek Sinha, Leena Priya, Taruna Taruna, Daya ShankarInternational Journal of Health Sciences 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Background: Atraumatic dental extraction preserves bone and maintains gingival architecture, thereby ensuring the option of replacement with implant supported prosthesis. The present study was conducted to compare the efficiency of arm force only versus arm force plus wrist movement during closed method extractions. Materials & Methods: 84 patients undergoing mandibular molar extraction of both genders were selected. Patients were divided into 2 groups. Each group comprised of 42 patients. In group I, interns used arm force only while in group II, interns used both arm force and wrist movement in extraction of mandibular molar. Parameters such as time taken for extraction, root fracture, bone plate facture, and adherence of buccal plate to the root were assessed. Results: Group I had 22 males and 20 females and group II had 18 males and 24 females. The mean time taken for extraction was 10.2 minutes in group I and 5.4 minutes in group II. The difference was significant (P < 0.05).

Introduction

In modern dentistry, the goal of tooth extraction has shifted from simple removal to "atraumatic extraction." This approach prioritizes preserving the surrounding alveolar bone and gingival architecture, which is essential if the patient later chooses to receive an implant-supported prosthesis. However, extractions are physically demanding and technically nuanced. Improper technique—often involving the application of excessive or misdirected force—frequently leads to complications like root fractures or damage to the buccal cortical plate.

A specific clinical question exists regarding the biomechanics of the operator's hand: is it more efficient to use raw arm force, or a combination of arm force and wrist movement? This study evaluates these two techniques to determine which yields better clinical outcomes, particularly when performed by less experienced practitioners (interns).

Methods

The researchers conducted a comparative clinical study involving 84 patients requiring mandibular molar extractions. The patients were divided into two equal groups (n=42):

  • Group I: Interns performed extractions using arm force only.
  • Group II: Interns performed extractions using a combination of arm force and wrist movement.

The study utilized the Choi et al. scoring system for extraction success, providing a standardized metric for evaluating surgical outcomes:

  • Score 5: Complete success
  • Score 4: Success with root tip fracture
  • Score 3: Success with root fracture
  • Score 2: Success with osteotomy
  • Score 1: Failure

Efficiency was measured by the time taken for extraction (in minutes), and complications such as root fractures and bone plate fractures were recorded. Statistical significance was determined using P-values ($P < 0.05$).

Results

The quantitative findings strongly favored the combined movement technique.

Procedure Time

Group II was significantly faster than Group I. The mean time taken for extraction was 5.4 minutes in Group II compared to 10.2 minutes in Group I ($P < 0.01$).

Comparison of mean extraction time (minutes) between Group I and Group II.

Success and Complications

Success rates were markedly higher in the group utilizing wrist movement. Group II achieved "Complete Success" (Score 5) in 14 cases, whereas Group I achieved this in only 6 cases. Conversely, Group I had a higher incidence of failures (Score 1) and procedures requiring bone removal (Score 2).

Distribution of Choi et al. success scores for both study groups.

Root and bone plate fractures were more common in the group using only arm force, suggesting that the lack of wrist control leads to more traumatic outcomes.

Discussion

The "wrist advantage" stems from the ability to apply more controlled, multi-axial movements—such as rocking and twisting—which are more effective at breaking periodontal ligaments than the linear application of arm force alone. The study highlights that many trainees use "arm only" force without realizing it. Explicit biomechanical training regarding wrist movement could significantly flatten the learning curve for dental students and improve patient outcomes.

Faster extractions in Group II were not just more efficient but also cleaner. The higher success scores indicate that the "arm plus wrist" technique is inherently more atraumatic, reducing the need for invasive measures like osteotomies.

Conclusion

Adding wrist movement to arm force during dental extractions nearly halves the procedure time and significantly improves success rates. This study demonstrates that the biomechanics of "arm plus wrist" movement is superior for performing atraumatic extractions, which are critical for preserving bone structure for future prosthetic rehabilitation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background: Atraumatic dental extraction preserves bone and maintains gingival architecture, thereby ensuring the option of replacement with implant supported prosthesis. The present study was conducted to compare the efficiency of arm force only versus arm force plus wrist movement during closed method extractions. Materials &amp; Methods: 84 patients undergoing mandibular molar extraction of both genders were selected. Patients were divided into 2 groups. Each group comprised of 42 patients. In group I, interns used arm force only while in group II, interns used both arm force and wrist movement in extraction of mandibular molar. Parameters such as time taken for extraction, root fracture, bone plate facture, and adherence of buccal plate to the root were assessed. Results: Group I had 22 males and 20 females and group II had 18 males and 24 females. The mean time taken for extraction was 10.2 minutes in group I and 5.4 minutes in group II. The difference was significant (P&lt; 0.05).
BibTeX
@article{choudhary2022assessment,
  author = {Shivendra Choudhary and Abhishek Sinha and Leena Priya and Taruna Taruna and Daya Shankar},
  title = {{Assessment of efficiency of arm force only versus arm force plus wrist movement during closed method extractions}},
  journal = {International Journal of Health Sciences},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.53730/ijhs.v6ns2.6804},
}
Figure