Assessment of calf muscle constitution in chronic Achilles tendon disease using Dixon-based MRI

Sophia S. Goller, Georg Wilhelm Kajdi, Stephan Wirth, Jess G. Snedeker, Reto SutterSkeletal 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study quantifies calf muscle fat content (MFC) in patients with chronic Achilles tendon disease (ATD) using Dixon-based MRI, finding it to be consistently elevated (around 11%) regardless of whether the ATD is midportion or insertional. The research highlights that while MFC is similar, the specific tendon damage and associated co-pathologies differ significantly between these two ATD subtypes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Chronic Achilles tendon disease (ATD) significantly impacts functional performance and quality of life. While the Achilles tendon (AT) itself is the primary site of injury, research suggests that the health and composition of the surrounding calf muscles, particularly the triceps surae group, are closely linked to AT pathology. Specifically, altered mechanical properties of the AT in ATD are thought to lead to fatty infiltration of the calf muscles, and conversely, impaired muscle function might be a risk factor for ATD. However, a precise, quantitative understanding of calf muscle constitution, especially the degree of fatty infiltration, and how it relates to the specific location of ATD (midportion vs. insertional) has been lacking. This paper aims to fill this gap by using advanced MRI techniques to quantitatively assess calf muscle fat content and explore its relationship with AT damage and co-pathologies in different ATD subtypes.

Methods

The study employed a retrospective design, analyzing data from 91 patients diagnosed with chronic ATD. The core of the quantitative analysis involved two-point Dixon-based MRI (2pt-MRIDIXON). This technique is crucial as it allows for the separation of fat and water signals within tissues, enabling precise quantification of muscle fat content (MFC). The 2pt-MRIDIXON images were processed using ITK-Snap software to generate volumetric fat fractions (FF) and whole muscle volumes (WMV) for the medial gastrocnemius (MG), lateral gastrocnemius (LG), and soleus muscles.

In addition to quantitative analysis, a qualitative assessment was performed by two independent radiologists. This included evaluating the AT quality (tendinosis, partial tear, complete tear), grading fatty infiltration of the calf muscles using the Goutallier classification, and identifying co-pathologies such as muscle edema, Kager's fat pad edema, Haglund's deformity, bone marrow edema, and retrocalcaneal bursitis. Statistical analyses, including Chi-square tests, Mann-Whitney U tests, and Spearman's rank correlation, were used to compare groups and assess relationships between variables.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 91 patients with chronic Achilles tendon disease who underwent clinical routine MRI of the AT and calf muscles between June 2023 and June 2024. This dataset was collected retrospectively from a single institution. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Consistent Fatty Infiltration: Despite differences in AT damage, the overall calf muscle fat content (around 11%) remains remarkably consistent across both midportion and insertional ATD. This suggests that chronic ATD, regardless of its location, leads to a similar degree of muscle fatty infiltration.
  • Distinct Pathological Signatures: While MFC is similar, the types of AT damage and associated co-pathologies are distinct for midportion versus insertional ATD. This implies that the underlying mechanisms or consequences of ATD might manifest differently depending on its location.
  • Quantitative Superiority: The study reinforces the idea that quantitative MFC assessment (using 2pt-MRIDIXON) is superior to qualitative visual grading (Goutallier classification) for evaluating fatty muscle infiltration, as the latter shows significant overlap and potentially less discriminatory power.
  • Biomarker Potential: The consistent MFC findings, coupled with the known link between tendon and muscle health, suggest that quantitative MFC assessment could serve as a valuable biomarker for ATD, potentially aiding in diagnosis, prognosis, and treatment planning.

Key Results

  • The overall mean FF of the triceps surae muscle in the study cohort was 11.2 ± 9.3%.
  • There were no significant differences in mean FF or qualitative MFC grading between midportion (MP) and insertional (IN) ATD patients (P ≥ 0.22).
  • Midportion ATD was associated with more severe tendon thickening (11 vs. 9 mm, P < 0.001) and complete tears (29% vs. 9%, P = 0.025).
  • Insertional ATD was associated with a higher prevalence of partial tears (55% vs. 31%, P = 0.027).
  • Soleus muscle edema was significantly more prevalent in MP ATD (40% vs. 9%, P = 0.002).
  • Haglund's deformity (67% vs. 0%), bone marrow edema (61% vs. 2%), and retrocalcaneal bursitis (82% vs. 43%) were significantly more common in IN ATD (all P < 0.002).
  • Significant correlations were found between FF and AT diameter, age, and BMI (in MP ATD only).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sequence Choice: The study used a two-point Dixon sequence, which, while effective, might be susceptible to T1 bias compared to multi-point Dixon sequences. However, they note that previous studies suggest this bias did not significantly impair FF values in their context.
  • Scanner Variability: Patients were scanned on different MRI scanners and field strengths (1.5T and 3.0T), which could introduce some bias.
  • Retrospective Design: The study was retrospective, meaning patients were selected based on existing clinical indications for MRI, and a healthy control group without ATD was not included for direct comparison of MFC.

Future work could involve prospective studies with larger, diverse cohorts, including healthy controls, to further validate the findings and explore the prognostic value of MFC in ATD. Investigating the impact of different Dixon sequence parameters on FF quantification would also be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

In chronic ATD, calf MFC was statistically equivalent (approximately 11%), irrespective of the localization of tendon damage. More severe tendon thickening and complete tears were more common in midportion ATD, and, vice versa, partial AT tears were significantly more frequent in insertional ATD.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{goller2024assessment,
  author = {Sophia S. Goller and Georg Wilhelm Kajdi and Stephan Wirth and Jess G. Snedeker and Reto Sutter},
  title = {{Assessment of calf muscle constitution in chronic Achilles tendon disease using Dixon-based MRI}},
  booktitle = {Skeletal},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1007/s00256-024-04845-7},
}
Figure