Assessment of Agricultural Drought Based on Reanalysis Soil Moisture in Southern China

Wei Shangguan, Ruqing Zhang, Lu Li, Shulei Zhang, Ye Zhang, Feini Huang, Jianduo Li, Wei LiuLand 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study evaluates the suitability of two reanalysis soil moisture datasets (ERA5-Land and CLDAS) for assessing agricultural drought in Southern China over a 40-year period. The findings indicate that both datasets, when used to calculate the Soil Water Deficit Index (SWDI), correlate well with in-situ measurements, with ERA5-Land being recommended for long-term analysis due to data availability. The research reveals that droughts in the region have become more severe and prolonged over the last four decades, particularly between 2001-2010.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Agricultural drought, a critical natural hazard, significantly impacts crop yields, food security, and the socio-economic well-being of regions. Accurately assessing and understanding agricultural drought is crucial for effective risk management. Southern China, despite its reputation for abundant rainfall, experiences frequent and severe droughts that have caused substantial crop failures and economic losses. While various drought indices exist, this paper focuses on the Soil Water Deficit Index (SWDI), which incorporates soil properties and is considered a robust indicator of agricultural drought. However, there's a need to evaluate the performance of readily available reanalysis soil moisture datasets for this purpose in Southern China, especially over longer time scales and across different climate zones within the region. Previous studies have been limited in their temporal scope or the datasets used, leaving gaps in our understanding of long-term drought trends and characteristics.

Methods

The study employs the Soil Water Deficit Index (SWDI) as the primary metric for assessing agricultural drought. The SWDI is calculated using soil moisture (SM) data, field capacity, wilting point, and available water capacity. To evaluate the performance of reanalysis datasets, the researchers used in-situ soil moisture data as a benchmark. They also introduced the Atmospheric Water Deficit Index (AWD) to investigate the relationship between meteorological and agricultural drought. Drought characteristics, such as number, severity, duration, and interval, were analyzed. For trend detection, the nonparametric Mann-Kendall (M-K) test was applied to identify significant long-term changes in drought duration and severity.

Datasets

  • In-situ Soil Moisture Data: Obtained from the China Meteorological Information Center (CMA) for the period 2013–2017. This data was quality-controlled and used as a benchmark for evaluating reanalysis datasets.
  • CLDAS (China Land Data Assimilation System) Soil Moisture Data: A reanalysis dataset used for the period 2013–2017. It was processed to match the spatial resolution and depth of ERA5-Land for comparison.
  • ERA5-Land Soil Moisture Data: A global reanalysis dataset from the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF) used for the extended period of 1981–2020. This dataset was chosen for its comprehensive historical coverage.
  • Meteorological Data (Precipitation and Potential Evapotranspiration): Derived from ERA5-Land for calculating the Atmospheric Water Deficit Index (AWD).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Reanalysis Datasets are Viable for Drought Assessment: Both ERA5-Land and CLDAS soil moisture data, when used to calculate SWDI, show good correlation with in-situ measurements, validating their utility for agricultural drought monitoring in Southern China.
  • ERA5-Land Preferred for Long-Term Studies: While both datasets perform similarly in short-term evaluations, ERA5-Land is recommended for long-term drought analysis due to its longer historical data availability.
  • Droughts are Intensifying in Southern China: The study reveals a concerning trend of increasing drought severity and duration over the past 40 years, with the decade of 2001–2010 being particularly severe. This highlights the growing vulnerability of the region to drought.
  • Meteorological Drought Drives Agricultural Drought: The research confirms a strong correlation between meteorological drought (measured by AWD) and agricultural drought (measured by SWDI), especially when using total evapotranspiration instead of potential evapotranspiration. This underscores the fundamental role of meteorological conditions in shaping agricultural drought.
  • Climate Zones Matter: Differences in drought characteristics were observed across the three analyzed climate zones (tropical, temperate no dry season, and temperate dry winter), indicating that regional climate variations influence drought patterns.

Key Results

  • SWDI Correlation: ERA5-Land_SWDI and CLDAS_SWDI showed good correlation with in-situ SWDI across the study area and climate zones.
  • Bias in Reanalysis SM: Both ERA5-Land and CLDAS exhibited a wet bias in soil moisture compared to in-situ data, though this bias was reduced when calculating the SWDI.
  • Drought Severity Trend: Droughts from 2001–2010 were found to be more serious than in other decades.
  • Long-Term Trends: Over the 40-year period (1981–2020), drought duration showed a significant upward trend in Yunnan, parts of Guangxi, and southern Guangdong. Drought severity also showed an upward trend in specific areas of Yunnan and Guangxi.
  • AWD vs. SWDI Correlation: Using total evapotranspiration (AWDt) in the meteorological drought index resulted in a higher correlation with agricultural drought (SWDI) compared to using potential evapotranspiration (AWDp).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Availability: The study acknowledges the limited data availability for CLDAS, which restricts its use for long-term analysis.
  • Bias Correction: The authors suggest future research to implement bias correction methods to further improve the accuracy of reanalysis data against in-situ observations.
  • Alternative Drought Indices: Exploring a variety of drought indices beyond SWDI is recommended to provide a more comprehensive understanding of agricultural drought conditions.
  • Zoning Criteria: Investigating different criteria for dividing the study area, such as vegetation distribution and altitude, could offer new insights.
  • Drought Forecasting: The ultimate goal is to use this understanding to forecast future agricultural drought conditions and associated risks, enabling better preparedness and mitigation strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Accurate assessment of agricultural drought is useful for ecosystem services. This is a successive work of our previous study that assessed agricultural drought using the soil water deficit index (SWDI) based on ERA5-Land in the four southern provinces of China from 2017 to 2019. Firstly, in addition to ERA5-Land, the suitability of CLDAS (China Land Data Assimilation System) soil moisture for drought assessment was investigated. Then, the study was extended with more comprehensive analysis and a much longer period (1981–2020). Based on three climate zones, in situ soil moisture was used for evaluation of both reanalysis datasets and agricultural drought. It was found that ERA5-Land_SWDI and CLDAS_SWDI have a good correlation with the in situ SWDI. ERA5-Land and CLDAS demonstrate some differences in representing agricultural drought but have a similar performance evaluated by in situ soil moisture. Droughts from 2001 to 2010 were more serious than in the other three decades, and droughts have become longer and severer in some areas in the last 40 years. There was a good correlation between agricultural drought and meteorological drought. Our work offers important insights for agricultural drought risk management in the four southern provinces of China.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shangguan2022assessment,
  author = {Wei Shangguan and Ruqing Zhang and Lu Li and Shulei Zhang and Ye Zhang and Feini Huang and Jianduo Li and Wei Liu},
  title = {{Assessment of Agricultural Drought Based on Reanalysis Soil Moisture in Southern China}},
  booktitle = {Land},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/land11040502},
}
Figure