ASSESSING THE RESILIENCE OF INDUSTRIAL AREAS FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF URBAN RESILIENCE AND COMMONPOOL RESOURCES: THE CASE STUDY OF TAIWAN

Keren Wang, Shanlang Lin, Yingwen ChenApplied Ecology and Environmental Research 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a quantitative framework for assessing the disaster resilience of industrial areas by treating urban disaster-prevention assets as "Common-Pool Resources" (CPRs). Using a hybrid of the Fuzzy Delphi Method and a Dynamic Analytic Network Process, the researchers identify that while physical infrastructure is vital, the true linchpin of resilience lies in governance and adaptation—specifically emergency planning and organizational management.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As climate change intensifies extreme weather events, industrial zones—often located in or near densely populated urban centers—face escalating risks. A disaster in a factory isn't just a private loss; it creates a "spillover effect" that can paralyze surrounding cities.

The authors argue that industrial resilience shouldn't be studied in a vacuum. Instead, factories and cities share a set of common resources (infrastructure, emergency services, information networks). These are "Common-Pool Resources" (CPRs), which are prone to the "tragedy of the commons"—where individual actors over-rely on shared assets without contributing to their maintenance or coordination. The paper seeks to bridge the gap between urban planning and industrial management by creating a tool that measures how well these areas can reorganize and adapt through collective governance.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-stage, hybrid methodological approach to handle the complexity and subjectivity of "resilience":

  1. Indicator Selection: Based on an extensive literature review, they initially identified 5 dimensions and 45 indicators.
  2. Fuzzy Delphi Method (FDM): To filter these indicators, they surveyed 10 experts (from academia, government, and industry). The "Fuzzy" aspect allows for human uncertainty in responses, using "double triangular fuzzy numbers" to find a consensus threshold. This narrowed the list to 24 critical indicators.
  3. DEMATEL-based Analytic Network Process (DANP): Standard linear models often fail to capture how one factor influences another (e.g., how "governance" affects "vulnerability"). DANP allows for a non-linear, networked analysis. It calculates both the weight (importance) and the centrality (how much a factor influences or is influenced by others) of each indicator.

Datasets

The study is a case study focused on Taiwan, a region uniquely susceptible to typhoons and earthquakes.

  • Primary Data: Responses from a panel of 10 experts with professional backgrounds in urban planning and industrial land management.
  • Contextual Data: The study references industrial land supply data from the Taiwan Industrial Development Bureau (approx. 47,916 hectares) and population density statistics to frame the geographic necessity of the research.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Governance as the "Leading" Indicator: The analysis categorized dimensions into "leading" (causes) and "influenced" (effects). Vulnerability and factory properties are leading indicators, but Governance and Adaptation—while an influenced dimension—had the highest centrality. This means that improving management and planning has the highest "multiplier effect" on overall resilience.
  • Validation of Ostrom’s Theory: The results strongly support Elinor Ostrom’s (2009) work on CPRs. The authors found that resilience isn't just about having a bigger fire truck; it’s about the "autonomy and growth of institutions" that regulate how that fire truck is used across the industrial-urban boundary.
  • The Scale Shift: Resilience research is moving from large-scale national contexts to "small-scale spaces" like industrial parks. The paper highlights that these small spaces are mutually dependent on the large-scale urban resources surrounding them.

Key Results

The framework identified 5 dimensions: Vulnerability, Urban Environment, Industrial Environment, Factory Properties, and Governance and Adaptation.

  • Top 5 Indicators by Weight:
    1. Emergency response and planning (E3)
    2. Management organization (E1)
    3. Employee awareness of disaster prevention (D3)
    4. Supervision (E2)
    5. Industry type (D2)
  • The Infrastructure Paradox: While "Industrial Environment" (physical assets like drainage and power) received the highest total weight, the "Governance" indicators dominated the top individual rankings. This suggests that even the best infrastructure fails without a robust organizational "software" to run it.
  • Centrality: Vulnerability and Governance/Adaptation tied for the highest centrality (1.478), marking them as the most influential areas for policy intervention.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge a few key constraints:

  • Expert Sample Size: While 10 experts meet the methodological standards for FDM/DANP, a larger, more diverse pool could provide broader perspectives.
  • Geographic Specificity: The model is tuned to Taiwan’s specific industrial and geological landscape. While the method is portable, the specific indicator weights might vary in different regulatory or climatic environments.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that future research should propose specific, differentiated adaptation strategies for different types of industrial parks (e.g., high-tech science parks vs. traditional manufacturing zones) based on these indicators.

Summary updated

Abstract

Industrial development is a critical factor for the economic development of a country.This study applies the fuzzy Delphi method (FDM) and a dynamic analytic network process (DANP) to develop a tool for the assessment of the resilience of industrial areas in Taiwan from the common-pool resources (CPRs) perspective to enhance the resilience of industrial areas and also ensure the efficient use of common urban disaster prevention resources.This study is innovative and may facilitate the assessment of the resilience of industrial areas and the validation of interactions between urban resilience, industrial area resilience and CPRs.The influencers of the resilience of industrial areas can be categorized into 5 dimensions and 24 indicators.The five dimensions are vulnerability, urban environment, industrial environment, factory properties, and governance and adaptation.The governance and adaptation dimension is the most crucial, and the five indicators with the highest weights are emergency response and planning, management organization, supervision, employee awareness of disaster prevention, and industry type.The results indicate the importance of adaptation and governance and response to the importance of Ostrom's (2005) CPRs.The study can be used as a reference for countries assessing the resilience of industrial areas and developing adaptation strategies.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2023assessing,
  author = {Keren Wang and Shanlang Lin and Yingwen Chen},
  title = {{ASSESSING THE RESILIENCE OF INDUSTRIAL AREAS FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF URBAN RESILIENCE AND COMMONPOOL RESOURCES: THE CASE STUDY OF TAIWAN}},
  booktitle = {Applied Ecology and Environmental Research},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.15666/aeer/2104\_37113736},
}
Figure