Abstract
This paper aims to quantify the effect of sovereignty transfer on Hong Kong's economy. It compares the trajectory of Hong Kong's purchasing power parity (PPP) adjusted GDP per capita before and after the 1997 handover with the trajectory of a weighted combination of similar economies, including Japan, Singapore, South Korea and Taiwan. Using weights endogenously determined by data, we construct a synthetic Hong Kong to provide the counterfactual of what would have happened to Hong Kong's economy in the absence of transfer of sovereignty. By combining multiple economies as control, the synthetic approach is more robust than simply comparing Hong Kong to another similar economy before and after the 1997 handover. It also provides an interval estimate of possible treatment effects. We find that Hong Kong's economy is negatively affected by the handover. The gap between actual and synthetic Hong Kong in PPP adjusted GDP per capita from 1997 to 2001 is on average 7% of the 1996 level if Japan receives the greatest weight. The average negative effect becomes 9% if Singapore receives the greatest weight. The paper concludes by discussing possible confounding factors in the results, such as isolating the impact of the 1997 Asian Financial Crisis from the sovereignty transfer on Hong Kong's economy.
Introduction
Evaluating the economic impact of major political shifts, such as the 1997 transfer of sovereignty over Hong Kong, presents significant methodological challenges. Traditional "before-and-after" analyses often fail to account for broader regional or global economic trends that would have influenced the economy regardless of the political event. Furthermore, simple comparative studies—such as comparing Hong Kong solely to a single peer like Singapore—can introduce bias, as no two economies are identical. This research addresses these limitations by employing a data-driven counterfactual approach to estimate what Hong Kong’s economic trajectory would have been had the handover never occurred.
Methodology: The Synthetic Control Method
The study utilizes the Synthetic Control Method (SCM), a statistical framework designed for comparative case studies where a single unit (Hong Kong) undergoes a "treatment" (the sovereignty transfer).
Constructing the Counterfactual
Rather than selecting a single control country, SCM constructs a "Synthetic Hong Kong" from a weighted average of a "donor pool" of similar regional economies. The donor pool for this study includes Japan, Singapore, South Korea, and Taiwan.
Endogenous Weighting
The weights assigned to each economy in the donor pool are determined endogenously. The model selects weights that ensure the synthetic version’s economic performance closely matches Hong Kong’s actual Purchasing Power Parity (PPP) adjusted GDP per capita in the years leading up to 1997. This ensures that the counterfactual is grounded in historical data rather than arbitrary selection, making the model more robust than traditional comparative methods.
Empirical Results
The analysis focuses on the divergence between Hong Kong’s actual GDP per capita and that of the synthetic counterfactual between 1997 and 2001.
The Economic Gap
Immediately following the 1997 handover, the real-world data for Hong Kong began to lag behind the "Synthetic Hong Kong." This gap represents the estimated economic cost of the sovereignty transfer. The magnitude of this impact is sensitive to the weighting of the donor pool, providing an interval estimate of the treatment effect:
- Japan-weighted Scenario: If the model is weighted more heavily toward Japan, the negative impact is approximately 7% of the 1996 GDP per capita level.
- Singapore-weighted Scenario: If the model is weighted more heavily toward Singapore, the negative impact increases to approximately 9%.
By using the "Asian Tigers" and Japan as the donor pool, the study accounts for regional economic characteristics, providing a more credible estimate than a global comparison.
Discussion and Limitations
A primary challenge in this analysis is the temporal overlap between the sovereignty transfer and the 1997 Asian Financial Crisis. Because the crisis occurred almost simultaneously with the handover, isolating the specific political impact from the regional financial shock is difficult.
While the SCM helps mitigate this—as the donor countries were also subject to the crisis—the authors acknowledge that the "handover effect" observed might be influenced by these overlapping events. Future research is needed to determine if this divergence represents a temporary shock or a long-term structural shift in Hong Kong’s economic trajectory. Additionally, extending the timeframe beyond 2001 would provide insight into the long-term evolution of these economic trends and whether the gap continued to widen or eventually stabilized.
Summary updated