TL;DR
This paper introduces a novel, two-dimensional framework for assessing the "Economic Energy Level" (EEL) of regions, moving beyond traditional internal development metrics to include external economic connections. Applying this to the Chengdu-Chongqing Economic Circle (CCEC), the study reveals distinct strengths between Chengdu and Chongqing, highlighting their complementary potential for regional growth.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Evaluating the economic vitality of a region, termed "Economic Energy Level" (EEL), has traditionally focused on internal factors like production, living standards, and ecological health. However, this approach overlooks the crucial role of a region's interconnectedness with the outside world – its "external economic connection level." This is particularly problematic in today's globalized economy, where "flow space" and inter-regional dynamics are paramount. The authors argue that this single-dimensional view leads to misestimations and hinders effective strategies for high-quality, sustainable development. They specifically address this gap by proposing a more comprehensive EEL assessment for the Chengdu-Chongqing Economic Circle (CCEC), a key national development strategy area in China that, despite its strategic importance, lags behind other major economic hubs.
Methods
The core of this research lies in developing and applying a new EEL evaluation framework. This framework is built on two interdependent dimensions: "internal comprehensive development level" (PLE) and "external economic connection level" (OI). The authors then construct a preliminary index system with 29 indicators, which is refined through reliability and validity analyses (Cronbach's alpha, factor analysis). To quantify the EEL, they employ a comprehensive weighted fuzzy integral method. This approach is chosen to handle the inherent vagueness and interdependence among indicators. The weights are determined by combining objective entropy weights with subjective expert scores. The final EEL is calculated using the Choquet fuzzy integral.
Datasets
The study utilizes statistical data for four cities: Chengdu, Chongqing, Beijing, and Tianjin, covering the period from 2000 to 2019. The data for 29 indicators are sourced from national and municipal statistical yearbooks, government reports, investment guides, and input-output tables. Beijing and Tianjin are included as benchmark cities for horizontal comparison to validate the model's empirical rationality.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Beyond Internal Metrics: The most significant insight is the critical need to incorporate "external economic connection level" into EEL assessments. Ignoring this dimension can lead to a skewed understanding of a region's true economic vitality.
- Complementary Strengths in CCEC: Chengdu and Chongqing, while often seen as competitors, possess distinct strengths. Chengdu excels in internal development (PLE), while Chongqing leads in external connections (OI). This complementarity offers a pathway for synergistic growth rather than stiff competition.
- "Field Source" and "Field" Interdependence: The theoretical underpinning of "field source" (internal development) and "field" (external connections) highlights their co-existence and mutual influence, providing a robust conceptual basis for the two-dimensional EEL framework.
- Impact of Global Shifts: The study points to the inflection point in 2019 for both Chengdu and Chongqing's EELs, directly linking it to deglobalization and the Sino-US trade war, underscoring the sensitivity of regional economies to global trends.
Key Results
- EEL Trends: The EELs of both Chengdu and Chongqing showed a general upward trend from 2000 to 2018, with a notable inflection point in 2019.
- Horizontal Comparison: Beijing consistently maintained the highest EEL, followed by Tianjin, then Chengdu and Chongqing, which largely overlapped. This confirms Beijing's status as a national economic powerhouse and highlights room for improvement in the CCEC.
- Sub-Index Strengths: Chongqing demonstrated a stronger "external economic connection level" (OI), while Chengdu led in "internal comprehensive development level" (PLE).
- Model Validation: The proposed EEL evaluation system, when benchmarked against Beijing and Tianjin, proved to be empirically sound and consistent with qualitative judgments.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that the assumption that information and technology flows are primarily attached to goods and personnel might be a limitation, especially in the current era of advanced communication technologies and post-pandemic shifts. They suggest that future work should explicitly incorporate information and technology flows into the framework for a more comprehensive assessment of the "external economic connection level."
Summary updated