Assessing the Attraction of Cities on Venture Capital From a Scaling Law Perspective

Ruiqi Li, Lingyun Lu, Tianyu Cui, Weiwei Gu, Shaodong Ma, Gang Xu, Harry Eugene StanleyIEEE Access 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the relationship between urban characteristics and venture capital (VC) attraction in Chinese cities using a scaling law perspective. They discover a nonlinear scaling relationship between VC activities and urban population, and introduce a "Scale-Invariant Metropolitan Indicator" (SIMI) to objectively assess city attractiveness, revealing distinct city development modes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cities are recognized as hubs for innovation and capital, with venture capital playing a crucial role in fostering new technologies and business models. However, a quantitative understanding of what makes cities attractive to VC, especially in relation to their size and characteristics, has been lacking. Traditional per capita metrics can be misleading in complex, nonlinear systems like cities, where scaling laws often apply. This paper aims to bridge this gap by applying scaling law analysis to understand VC attraction in Chinese cities and develop a more objective metric for city attractiveness.

Methods

The authors employ a scaling law approach, modeling the relationship between venture capital activities (Y) and urban population (P) as a power law: $Y_i(t) = Y_0(t)P_i(t)^\beta \xi_i(t)$. They find that VC activities scale superlinearly with population ($\beta > 1$), indicating increasing returns to scale and higher concentration in larger cities. To overcome the bias of per capita metrics in such nonlinear systems, they introduce the Scale-Invariant Metropolitan Indicator (SIMI), which is the residual ($\xi_i(t)$) from the scaling law prediction. This SIMI serves as a size-independent measure of a city's performance relative to its expected VC attraction based on its population. They also analyze the temporal evolution of SIMI to classify cities into groups based on their investment-enhancing or declining trends.

Datasets

The primary dataset used is the SiMuTong dataset (purchased from Zero2IPO Group), which contains detailed venture capital investment records in China. This dataset includes information on investors, invested companies (industry, location), investment dates, amounts, and stages. Complementary location information was obtained from Qichacha (www.qcc.com). Industry classifications were mapped to the Industrial Classification for National Economic Activities of China (ICNEAC).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Nonlinear Scaling of VC Attraction: Venture capital investment doesn't scale linearly with city population; it exhibits superlinear scaling, meaning larger cities attract disproportionately more VC. This suggests a concentration of VC activity in megacities.
  • Limitations of Per Capita Metrics: Traditional per capita measures are inherently biased in nonlinear scaling systems. For superlinear scaling, they overstate the attractiveness of larger cities and understate smaller ones.
  • SIMI as an Objective Metric: The Scale-Invariant Metropolitan Indicator (SIMI) provides a more objective way to assess a city's VC attractiveness by accounting for the nonlinear scaling effects. It helps distinguish between growth due to population size and growth driven by local factors.
  • Distinct City Development Modes: The temporal evolution of SIMI reveals three distinct groups of cities: investment-enhancing, investment-stable, and investment-declining. This classification highlights different development trajectories and potentially the impact of local policies.
  • Regional Differences in VC Dynamics: The study highlights significant differences in VC dynamics between major urban agglomerations. For instance, Beijing exhibits a "siphon effect" in the Jing-Jin-Ji region, while cities in the Yangtze River Delta show more coordinated development and positive relationships.
  • Dynamic Scaling Exponents: The scaling exponents for VC activities fluctuate more significantly over time compared to metrics like GMP, suggesting a more dynamic and complex system. This evolution can be explained by the differential growth dynamics of cities of different sizes.

Key Results

  • VC activities (both investment amount and number of investments) scale superlinearly with urban population in China, with scaling exponents ($\beta$) significantly larger than those for Gross Metropolitan Product (GMP). For example, $\beta$ for VC investment amount was found to be around 1.53, compared to 1.17 for GMP.
  • Analysis of SIMI reveals that while large cities may underperform in GMP relative to their size, they generally overperform in attracting VC investments. Beijing, for instance, ranks high in VC investments but much lower in GMP.
  • The temporal evolution of SIMI shows larger fluctuations for VC activities than for GMP, indicating a lack of long-term memory in VC attraction.
  • Hierarchical clustering of SIMI time series identified three groups of cities: investment-enhancing, investment-stable, and investment-declining. Two of these groups show clear increasing and decreasing trends, respectively.
  • The study proposes a conceptual model that explains the evolution of scaling exponents by considering the differential growth dynamics of small, medium, and large cities, showing a strong correlation between the change in scaling exponent and the growth dynamics.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations: While the SiMuTong dataset is authoritative, the paper notes limitations in industry classification resolution and the inability to disclose raw investment data from specific firms.
  • Causality: While the study identifies correlations and potential drivers (e.g., local policies), establishing direct causality for the observed trends requires further investigation.
  • Generalizability: The authors assume their conceptual model for explaining scaling exponent evolution is generalizable to other scenarios (e.g., traffic congestion, built-up areas), but this requires empirical validation.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest integrating these scaling relationships into predictive theories of endogenous urban growth and exploring the link between VC activities and patenting in cities. Further research into the hierarchical structure of cities and its relation to scaling laws is also proposed.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{li2021assessing,
  author = {Ruiqi Li and Lingyun Lu and Tianyu Cui and Weiwei Gu and Shaodong Ma and Gang Xu and Harry Eugene Stanley},
  title = {{Assessing the Attraction of Cities on Venture Capital From a Scaling Law Perspective}},
  journal = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1109/access.2021.3068317},
}
Figure