Assessing research trends and scientific advances in well-being studies

Hiroko Yamano, Ichiro SakataAAAI 2023

Introduction

Well-being has become a central focus in public policy, psychology, and technology. However, its definition remains fluid, historically tied to economic prosperity or physical health. As research volume accelerates, manual synthesis becomes impossible. This study uses a large-scale bibliometric analysis of over 67,000 papers to map the evolution of the field over three decades, identifying a significant shift toward individualized and mental constructs.

Methods

The authors developed a computational pipeline to analyze 67,464 papers from the Web of Science database:

  1. Citation Network Clustering: Using the Louvain method to identify research "communities" based on citation patterns.
  2. Keyword Extraction (tf-icf): Highlighting unique terms within each cluster to define their thematic focus.
  3. Linguistic Analysis (LIWC2015): Categorizing vocabulary into "mental" versus "physical" constructs to quantify the psychological weight of different research areas.
  4. Disciplinary Mapping: Correlating clusters with Web of Science journal categories to identify the academic fields driving specific trends.

Results: The 12 Pillars of Well-being Research

The analysis identified 12 distinct research clusters, ranging from traditional topics like "Income" and "Health" to emerging areas like "Mindfulness" and "Gratitude."

Summary of the 12 major research clusters identified in the study.

A significant finding is the "Mental Pivot." Older clusters, such as those centered on Income (#3) or General Health (#11), tend to focus on physical and economic indicators. In contrast, the newest and fastest-growing clusters, such as Mindfulness (#9) and Gratitude (#12), are almost entirely focused on mental and psychological constructs.

Shift from physical to mental well-being constructs across research clusters over time.

Key trends identified include:

  • Nature as a Psychological Tool: The "Nature" cluster (#7) has evolved from focusing on "ecosystem services" (physical provisions) toward "nature connectedness" and the psychological benefits of biophilia.
  • COVID-19 Acceleration: The pandemic acted as a catalyst, shifting the global research agenda toward mental health and resilience, resulting in a massive spike in publications starting in 2019.
  • Interdisciplinary Glue: While specific fields dominate certain clusters (e.g., Economics in Cluster #3), Psychology-Multidisciplinary serves as the common thread across nearly all 12 major clusters.

Discussion and Future Directions

The research highlights a move toward the "PERMA" model (Positive emotion, Engagement, Relationships, Meaning, Achievement), particularly in newer sub-clusters of positive psychology. However, the authors note limitations, such as keyword constraints and the lack of a formal predictive model for future trends.

The paper concludes by suggesting that "Socially Responsible AI" must move beyond simple efficiency. Future work should focus on how AI can support the nuanced, mental, and relational aspects of well-being identified in this study, such as curbing social fragmentation and supporting resilience.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{yamano2023assessing,
  author = {Hiroko Yamano and Ichiro Sakata},
  title = {{Assessing research trends and scientific advances in well-being studies}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2023},
}
Figure