Assessing randomness and complexity in human motion trajectories through analysis of symbolic sequences

Zhen Peng, Tim Genewein, Daniel A. BraunFrontiers in Human Neuroscience 2014 · DOI

Abstract

Complexity is a hallmark of intelligent behavior, consisting of both regular patterns and random variation. To quantitatively assess the complexity and randomness of human motion, we designed a motor task in which we translated subjects' motion trajectories into strings of symbol sequences. In the first part of the experiment, participants were asked to perform self-paced movements to create repetitive patterns, copy pre-specified letter sequences, and generate random movements. To investigate whether the degree of randomness can be manipulated, in the second part of the experiment, participants were asked to perform unpredictable movements in the context of a pursuit game, where they received feedback from an online Bayesian predictor guessing their next move. We analyzed symbol sequences representing subjects' motion trajectories with five common complexity measures: predictability, compressibility, approximate entropy, Lempel-Ziv complexity, as well as effective measure complexity. We found that subjects’ self-created patterns were the most complex, followed by drawing movements of letters and self-paced random motion. We also found that participants could change the randomness of their behavior depending on context and feedback. Our results suggest that humans can adjust both complexity and regularity in different movement types and contexts and that this can be assessed with information-theoretic measures of the symbolic sequences generated from movement trajectories.

Introduction

In fields ranging from biology to the search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI), complexity is often viewed as a hallmark of an intelligent organism. However, "complexity" is frequently confused with "randomness." A sequence of coin flips is highly random (unpredictable) but structurally simple, whereas human language is complex because it balances predictability with long-range structure.

This study addresses two main problems:

  1. Measurement: Quantitatively distinguishing between the randomness of a movement and its organizational complexity.
  2. Adaptability: Determining if humans can consciously increase the randomness of their movements when provided with feedback, or if our "randomness ceiling" is biologically fixed.

Methodology

The researchers designed a motor task where participants moved a cursor in a 3D virtual environment. These trajectories were discretized into a 10x10 grid and converted into symbolic sequences of four possible transitions: up, down, left, and right.

Example of human motion trajectories discretized on a 10x10 grid for symbolic analysis.

Data Collection and Analysis

The experiment involved 20 human subjects and three synthetic baselines to provide "floor" and "ceiling" comparisons:

  • Artificial Rhythmic (AS): A perfectly regular up-down sequence.
  • Artificial Random (AR): A true random walk on a 10x10 grid.
  • Artificial Frequency-matched (AF): Random sequences matching human symbol frequencies.

Five distinct measures were employed to analyze the sequences: predictability (using Context-Tree Weighting), compressibility (Lempel-Ziv and CTW), Approximate Entropy (ApEn), Lempel-Ziv Complexity, and Effective Measure Complexity (EMC).

Key Insights and Results

The study revealed a "Complexity Paradox": the most complex movements (highest EMC) were self-created patterns like spirals or squares. While more predictable than random motion, these patterns contain significantly more structural information, proving that complexity is not synonymous with randomness.

Performance Rankings

  • Predictability: Artificial Rhythmic > Self-generated Patterns > Letter Drawing > Self-paced Random > Pursuit Game Random > Artificial Random.
  • Complexity (EMC): Self-generated Patterns > Letter Drawing > Random Motion > Artificial Processes.

A key finding was the Pursuit Effect: participants' predictability dropped significantly during the pursuit game compared to self-paced random motion. This demonstrates that humans can adapt their behavioral entropy based on environmental feedback, although they still fall short of true mathematical randomness due to innate local correlations.

Conclusion

This research highlights the robustness of symbolic dynamics in assessing human behavior. The relative ranking of movement types remained consistent across various grid sizes and visibility conditions. Future applications of these complexity measures could include biomarkers for personality traits, creativity, or neurological health, where motor patterns may become abnormally stereotyped or disorganized.

Summary updated

Abstract

Complexity is a hallmark of intelligent behavior consisting both of regular patterns and random variation. To quantitatively assess the complexity and randomness of human motion, we designed a motor task in which we translated subjects' motion trajectories into strings of symbol sequences. In the first part of the experiment participants were asked to perform self-paced movements to create repetitive patterns, copy pre-specified letter sequences, and generate random movements. To investigate whether the degree of randomness can be manipulated, in the second part of the experiment participants were asked to perform unpredictable movements in the context of a pursuit game, where they received feedback from an online Bayesian predictor guessing their next move. We analyzed symbol sequences representing subjects' motion trajectories with five common complexity measures: predictability, compressibility, approximate entropy, Lempel-Ziv complexity, as well as effective measure complexity. We found that subjects’ self-created patterns were the most complex, followed by drawing movements of letters and self-paced random motion. We also found that participants could change the randomness of their behavior depending on context and feedback. Our results suggest that humans can adjust both complexity and regularity in different movement types and contexts and that this can be assessed with information-theoretic measures of the symbolic sequences generated from movement trajectories.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{peng2014assessing,
  author = {Zhen Peng and Tim Genewein and Daniel A. Braun},
  title = {{Assessing randomness and complexity in human motion trajectories through analysis of symbolic sequences}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Human Neuroscience},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.3389/fnhum.2014.00168},
}
Figure