Assessing Multiple Risks in Regulating Reservoirs: Perspectives on Heavy Metal Contamination

Hui Zhou, Zhiping Li, Anming Wang, Jiawei Zhu, Zhi‐Yong Han, Yalin Zhang, Dongdong ChenToxics 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study assessed heavy metal (HM) contamination in Dongping Lake, a crucial reservoir for China's water supply. While surface water quality is good, sediments show HM enrichment, with Cadmium (Cd) posing a high ecological risk and a significant carcinogenic risk to children. Industrial and agricultural activities are identified as the primary sources of this pollution.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Dongping Lake is a vital component of China's South-to-North Water Diversion Project, supplying water to millions. However, rapid economic development in the surrounding region has led to increased pollution from industrial discharge, agricultural runoff, and aquaculture. This poses a threat to the lake's ecosystem and human health. Previous research had identified HM contamination in Dongping Lake sediments, but critical knowledge gaps remained regarding HM mobility, release risks from sediments, and comprehensive health risk assessments considering multiple exposure pathways. This paper aims to fill these gaps by providing an integrated assessment of HM pollution in Dongping Lake's water-sediment system.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to assess HM contamination:

  • Water and Sediment Sampling: 33 water and 31 sediment samples were collected from systematic grid sites across Dongping Lake.
  • Heavy Metal Analysis: Concentrations of 12 heavy metals (Ti, V, Cr, Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu, Zn, As, Cd, Pb) were determined in both water and sediment samples.
  • Pollution Assessment:
    • Heavy Metal Pollution Index (HPI): Used to evaluate surface water quality.
  • Potential Ecological Risk Index (PERI): Assessed the synergistic ecological threats from multi-metal interactions in sediments.
  • Geo-Accumulation Index (Igeo): Evaluated the degree of HM pollution in sediments relative to background values.
  • Chemical Speciation: The BCR sequential extraction method was used to determine the different chemical forms (fractions) of HMs in sediments, providing insights into their mobility and bioavailability.
  • Health Risk Assessment: A probabilistic health risk assessment using Monte Carlo simulation was conducted to evaluate risks from drinking water and sediment exposure for different demographic groups (adults and children). This included assessing both non-carcinogenic and carcinogenic risks.
  • Source Apportionment: Correlation analysis between HMs and environmental parameters, along with existing literature, was used to identify pollution sources.

Datasets

The study utilized data from:

  • Field samples: Water and sediment samples collected from 33 and 31 sites, respectively, in Dongping Lake during April 2024.
  • Regional Sediment Background Values: Data from the Yellow River sediments were used as a reference for sediment HM evaluation.
  • Existing Literature: Previous studies on Dongping Lake and other Chinese lakes were referenced for comparison and source identification.
  • U.S. EPA Databases: Data from the U.S. EPA IRIS database and other EPA guidelines were used for toxicological parameters and health risk assessment methodologies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Sediments as HM Sinks: The study reinforces the understanding that lake sediments act as significant sinks for heavy metals, with concentrations orders of magnitude higher than in the overlying water.
  • Cd's High Ecological Risk: Cadmium (Cd) stands out as the primary ecological risk factor, exhibiting high bioavailability and posing a serious point-source pollution threat, significantly exceeding background levels and contributing heavily to the potential ecological hazard index.
  • Children's Vulnerability: Children are identified as the most susceptible group to both carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic health risks from sediment HM exposure, primarily due to their physiological characteristics and behaviors like playing near water and inadvertent ingestion.
  • Speciation Matters: The chemical form (speciation) of HMs is crucial. While many metals are in stable residual fractions, Cd's extractable and reducible forms highlight its mobility and potential for direct absorption by organisms.
  • Industrial and Agricultural Nexus: The study strongly links industrial emissions and agricultural practices (fertilizers, pesticides) to HM contamination, particularly for Cd, Zn, and Pb, underscoring the need for integrated pollution control strategies.

Key Results

  • Water Quality: Surface water HM concentrations were below WHO limits, indicating good water quality.
  • Sediment Pollution: Sediment HM enrichment was observed, with Cd posing a high ecological risk (mean E<sub>r</sub> = 135) and contributing to a moderate overall pollution level.
  • Speciation Findings: V, Cr, Co, Ni, Cu, Zn, and Pb were predominantly in residual fractions, suggesting geogenic origins and low bioavailability. Cd showed high bioavailability, while Pb was mainly in a reducible state.
  • Ecological Risk Assessment: V and Cr posed minimal risk. Co, Ni, Cu, Zn, and Pb caused slight pollution. Cd caused serious point-source pollution.
  • Health Risk Assessment:
    • Non-carcinogenic risks from sediments were negligible for all demographics.
  • Carcinogenic risks were not negligible for children, with Cd and Cr being key contributors. The total carcinogenic risk index (TCRI) for children was higher than for adults.
  • Source Apportionment: Industrial emissions were identified as the primary HM contributors. Cd pollution was linked to agricultural runoff (phosphate fertilizers) and industrial discharges.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Exposure Pathways: While the study assessed drinking water and sediment exposure, it acknowledges that dermal exposure poses minimal risks. However, occupational groups (fishers, tourism workers) and populations near Cd-emitting industries require special attention.
  • Focus on Specific Metals: While 12 HMs were analyzed, the study focused on the risk assessment of nine key metals.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest strengthening research on the different forms of HMs to better understand their bioavailability and environmental toxicity. They also emphasize the need for controlling agricultural pollution around Dongping Lake to prevent continuous diffusion of pollutants and further degradation of the water environment. Further investigation into OM-Cd complexation in sediments is also warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

As the terminal reservoir of the South-to-North Water Diversion's Eastern Route, Dongping Lake is critical for safeguarding the northern water supply. Analysis of 33 water-sediment sites revealed the following. (1) Waterborne heavy metals (HMs) below WHO limits, confirming the good water quality. (2) Sediment HM enrichment exceeding background levels, with Cd posing high ecological risk (mean <i>E<sub>r</sub></i> = 135), and moderate overall pollution. (3) Speciation showed V, Cr, Co, Ni, Cu, Zn, and Pb predominantly in residual fractions, while Cd exhibited high bioavailability and Pb was in reducible state. Ecological risk assessment indicated that V and Cr tend not to cause environmental pollution; Co, Ni, Cu, Zn, and Pb only cause slight pollution; and Cd causes serious point-source pollution. The carcinogenic risk of surface sediments to children is not negligible. (4) Source apportionment identified industrial emissions as the primary HM contributors, with Cd deriving from agricultural runoff (phosphate fertilizers) and industrial discharges. This study offers valuable baseline information for water quality management in mega-water-transfer projects, directly supporting the Jiaodong Main Line and Yellow River Crossing operations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhou2025assessing,
  author = {Hui Zhou and Zhiping Li and Anming Wang and Jiawei Zhu and Zhi‐Yong Han and Yalin Zhang and Dongdong Chen},
  title = {{Assessing Multiple Risks in Regulating Reservoirs: Perspectives on Heavy Metal Contamination}},
  booktitle = {Toxics},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/toxics13090762},
}
Figure