Assessing mobility characteristics and activity levels of manual wheelchair users

Michelle Tolerico, Dan Ding, Rory A. Cooper, Donald M. Spaeth, Shirley G. Fitzgerald, Rosemarie Cooper, Annmarie Kelleher, Michael L. BoningerThe Journal of Rehabilitation Research and Development 2007 · DOI

TL;DR

This study used a custom data logger to objectively measure the daily mobility and activity levels of manual wheelchair users in their home environments and during the National Veterans Wheelchair Games (NVWG). The findings reveal that wheelchair users are significantly more active during organized events like the NVWG and that employment status positively correlates with higher daily activity levels.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Maintaining an active lifestyle is crucial for overall health and quality of life, yet a significant portion of wheelchair users lead sedentary lives. Quantifying their actual physical activity levels is challenging due to the variability in their conditions and the limitations of traditional self-report methods, which are prone to recall bias. This paper aims to address this gap by providing a more objective and comprehensive understanding of the mobility characteristics and activity levels of manual wheelchair users in both their everyday environments and during more vigorous, organized events. This understanding is vital for developing targeted interventions and promoting healthier lifestyles within this population.

Methods

The researchers employed a custom-developed data logger, approximately 5 cm in diameter and 3.8 cm in depth, designed for long-term monitoring of wheelchair activity. This device attaches to the wheelchair spokes and uses reed switches triggered by wheel rotation to record date and time stamps of movement. This approach allows for the measurement of distance traveled, speed, and duration of activity without requiring the participant to wear any device, thus minimizing discomfort and potential bias.

The study involved 52 manual wheelchair users who were monitored for 13 or 20 days. This monitoring period included 6 days during the National Veterans Wheelchair Games (NVWG) and either one or two additional weeks in their home environment. Data from the loggers were processed using a custom MATLAB program to calculate key metrics such as daily distance, average speed, active hours, accumulated movement time, and the frequency and distance of stops. Demographic data were collected via surveys. Statistical analyses, including repeated-measures ANOVA, Kruskal-Wallis tests, Wilcoxon signed rank tests, paired t-tests, and Spearman correlation coefficients, were used to compare activity levels across different settings, injury levels, and demographic factors.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from 52 manual wheelchair users. This data comprised:

  • Activity Data: Collected over 13 or 20 days per participant using a custom data logger attached to their primary wheelchair. This data included detailed logs of wheelchair movement.
  • Demographic Data: Collected via surveys, including age, years of wheelchair use, type of injury/disability, residential setting, employment status, satisfaction with their wheelchair, and perceived community accessibility.

No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, the study aimed to contribute to the existing understanding of wheelchair user activity levels by using a novel data collection method in real-world settings.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The NVWG as a Catalyst for Activity: The National Veterans Wheelchair Games (NVWG) significantly boosts the activity levels of manual wheelchair users. Participants traveled farther, faster, and were active for more hours during the NVWG compared to their home environments. This highlights the potential of organized events to promote physical activity.
  • Employment Matters: Being employed is a significant factor in higher daily activity levels for manual wheelchair users. Employed individuals covered more distance, accumulated more minutes of movement, and had longer continuous travel segments, suggesting that employment may provide both financial means and psychological benefits that encourage greater activity.
  • Objective Measurement is Key: Using a data logger attached to the wheelchair, rather than relying solely on self-reports, provides a more objective and reliable measure of actual mobility and activity. This method minimizes recall bias and the burden on participants.
  • Uniformity Across Injury Levels: Interestingly, the study found no significant differences in mobility characteristics or activity levels based on the level of spinal cord injury (SCI) or other disabilities. This contrasts with some previous research and suggests that other factors might be more influential.

Key Results

  • Home Environment Activity: In their home environments, manual wheelchair users traveled an average of 2,457.0 ± 1,195.7 meters per day at a speed of 0.79 ± 0.19 m/s for 8.3 ± 3.3 hours per day.
  • NVWG Activity: During the NVWG, participants traveled significantly farther (6,745.3 ± 1,937.9 m), faster (0.96 ± 0.17 m/s), and for more hours (12.4 ± 1.7 h/d) compared to their home environment (p < 0.001). Accumulated movement time also increased from 47.9 ± 21.4 minutes at home to 115.9 ± 25.5 minutes at the NVWG.
  • Employment Impact: Employed wheelchair users demonstrated significantly higher average daily distance traveled (p = 0.002), accumulated minutes per day (p = 0.006), and maximum daily distance between stops (p = 0.01) compared to unemployed individuals.
  • No Significant Differences by SCI Level: The study found no significant differences in mobility characteristics or activity levels among different levels of SCI (C5-C8, T1-T5, T6-T10, T11-L5) or other disability groups.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: * Primary Wheelchair Only: The data logger was only attached to the subjects' primary wheelchairs. This means that activity levels might be underestimated if participants used backup or sports wheelchairs, or engaged in activities where they were stationary in their primary wheelchair (e.g., using an arm ergometer). * Propulsion vs. Being Pushed: The study could not distinguish between self-propulsion and being pushed by another person. However, the authors believe this was minimal given the study population.

Future Work: * Include All Wheelchairs: Future studies should attach data loggers to all wheelchairs used by participants (primary, backup, sports) to obtain a more complete picture of activity. * Differentiate Populations: Further research is needed to explore differences in mobility and activity levels among specific populations, such as women, minorities, and individuals with disabilities other than SCI. * Compare SCI Levels: More research is required to investigate potential differences in mobility and activity levels between individuals with paraplegia and tetraplegia. * Contextualize Activity: Understanding whether subjects are involved in sports, other regular activities at home, or can walk would provide further context for their activity levels. * Explore Demographic Factors: Continued exploration of demographic factors that influence mobility and activity levels is warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Although engaging in an active lifestyle is beneficial for maintaining quality of life, a majority of wheelchair users are inactive. This study investigated the mobility characteristics and activity levels of manual wheelchair users in the residential setting and at the National Veterans Wheelchair Games (NVWG). Demographic factors that may have influenced activity in the home environment were also identified. Fifty-two manual wheelchair users completed a brief survey, and their activity was monitored with a custom data logger over a period of 13 or 20 days. We found that they traveled a mean +/- standard deviation of 2,457.0 +/- 1,195.7 m/d at a speed of 0.79 +/- 0.19 m/s for 8.3 +/- 3.3 h/d while using their primary wheelchair in the home environment. No significant differences in mobility characteristics or activity levels were found for level of spinal cord injury or disability. We also found that subjects traveled significantly farther and faster and were active for more hours during an average day at the NVWG than in the home environment (p < 0.001). We found that manual wheelchair users who were employed covered more distance, accumulated more minutes, and traveled a greater average maximum distance between consecutive stops than those who were unemployed. Results from this study provide a better understanding of the activity levels achieved by manual wheelchair users and insight into factors that may influence this activity.
BibTeX
@article{tolerico2007assessing,
  author = {Michelle Tolerico and Dan Ding and Rory A. Cooper and Donald M. Spaeth and Shirley G. Fitzgerald and Rosemarie Cooper and Annmarie Kelleher and Michael L. Boninger},
  title = {{Assessing mobility characteristics and activity levels of manual wheelchair users}},
  journal = {The Journal of Rehabilitation Research and Development},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.1682/jrrd.2006.02.0017},
}
Figure