Assessing Changes in the Ecosystem Services Value in Response to Land-Use/Land-Cover Dynamics in Shanghai from 2000 to 2020

Yuan Gong, Mengmeng Cai, Lei Yao, Linsong Cheng, Chunxu Hao, Zheng ZhaoInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study quantifies the impact of rapid urbanization on ecosystem services value (ESV) in Shanghai from 2000 to 2020. It reveals a significant decline in overall ESV due to shrinking cultivated land and expanding construction, with notable regional variations and a surprising disproportionate value contribution from small areas of trenches and lakes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Urbanization is a global phenomenon that profoundly alters land use and land cover (LULC), directly impacting the vital ecosystem services that support human life and well-being. While the general trend of declining ecosystem services with increasing urbanization is understood, there's a need for detailed, spatially explicit analyses in rapidly developing megacities to inform sustainable urban planning. This paper addresses this by investigating the specific LULC changes in Shanghai, a major Chinese metropolis, over two decades and quantifying their impact on the value of its ecosystem services. The study aims to provide a deeper understanding of these dynamics to guide better land management and urban development strategies.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Land Use/Land Cover (LULC) Dynamics Analysis: They analyzed changes in land use patterns over time using a land use dynamic degree (LUDD) index to quantify the rate of change for different land types.
  • Ecosystem Services Value (ESV) Estimation: They adapted a widely used method based on equivalent factors, adjusting it for Shanghai's specific context. This involved calculating the economic value of food crops to derive a local ESV per unit area. The Consumer Price Index (CPI) was used to ensure comparability across years.
  • Contribution Rate (CR) Analysis: This metric was used to understand the relative importance of different ecosystem services and land types to the total ESV.
  • Sensitivity Analysis (CS): To assess the reliability of their ESV estimates, they tested the sensitivity of the total ESV to changes in the ESV coefficients, adjusting them by ±50%.

Datasets

The study utilized the following datasets:

  • China Land Use and Cover Change (CNLUCC) dataset: This national dataset, based on Landsat TM, ETM+, and Landsat 8 remote sensing imagery, provided five land-use maps for Shanghai for the years 2000, 2005, 2010, 2015, and 2020.
  • Shanghai Statistical Yearbook (2001–2021) and China Statistical Yearbook (2001–2021): These provided socioeconomic data, including agricultural commodity output, sown areas of grain crops, and the Consumer Price Index (CPI), crucial for ESV calculations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Construction Land vs. Nature" Trade-off: The study starkly illustrates the direct trade-off between urban expansion and natural ecosystems. The significant increase in construction land directly corresponds to the loss of vital natural and agricultural lands, leading to a quantifiable decline in ecosystem services.
  • Disproportionate Value of Water Bodies: A striking finding is the immense ecological value attributed to trenches and lakes. Despite occupying a very small percentage of Shanghai's total land area (1.67–3.16%), these water bodies contribute a substantial portion of the total ESV (23.80–50.70%). This highlights their critical role in maintaining ecosystem health and function.
  • Urbanization's Uneven Impact: The ESV changes are not uniform across Shanghai. While some districts, particularly Chongming and Pudong, experienced significant declines, others, like Qingpu, showed improvements in specific services due to targeted planning and resource endowments. This underscores the importance of localized planning strategies.
  • Sensitivity Analysis Confirms Robustness: The sensitivity analysis indicated that Shanghai's ESV is relatively inelastic to the ESV coefficients used. This suggests that the chosen coefficients are reasonably representative of the actual situation, lending credibility to the study's findings.

Key Results

  • Overall ESV Decline: From 2000 to 2020, Shanghai experienced an overall decrease in ESV of approximately 1138.40 million yuan.
  • LULC Shifts: Cultivated land decreased by 123.96 thousand hm², while construction land increased by 141.26 thousand hm².
  • Major Contributors to Decline: Hydrological adjustment and biodiversity services were particularly affected by LULC changes, showing significant declines.
  • District-Level Variations: Chongming District and Pudong New Area saw the most substantial declines in ESV. Conversely, Qingpu District experienced improvements in hydrological adjustment, water supply, and environmental purification.
  • High Value of Water Features: Trenches and lakes, despite their small land area, accounted for a significant portion of the total ESV, ranging from 23.80% to 50.70%.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Exclusion of Construction Land ESV: Construction land, with an ESV equivalent to less than 0, was excluded from the analysis. This means the actual ESV loss due to urban expansion might be underestimated.
  • Socioeconomic Factors: The study did not fully incorporate the impact of socioeconomic factors, such as land conversion policies and public willingness, which can significantly influence LULC and ESV.
  • Uncertainty in ESV Coefficients: While sensitivity analysis was performed, the inherent uncertainties in ecosystem service valuation methods and biological community representations were noted.

Future research could focus on:

  • Developing more comprehensive models that integrate socioeconomic drivers and policy impacts.
  • Refining ESV estimation methods to better capture the nuances of urban ecosystems.
  • Conducting more in-depth analyses of specific ecosystem services and their spatial interactions within urban landscapes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Land resources are foundational for human survival and development. In contrast, land use/land cover (LULC) dynamics drive considerable changes in ecosystem services. Recently, China witnessed a new stage of rapid urbanization. Therefore, investigating the relationships between ecosystem services value (ESV) and LULC in these areas is highly relevant. Based on the data of land use and socioeconomic development in Shanghai from 2000 to 2020, we adopted a land use/land cover dynamics analysis method and established the ESV per unit area at the city scale, discussed the impact of LULC on ESV spatially and quantitatively, and tested the research process based on the sensitivity analysis of the ESV coefficient. The results show that from 2000 to 2020, the LULC pattern in Shanghai rapidly changed. In particular, the area of cultivated land has shrunk by 123.96 thousand hm<sup>2</sup>, while the construction land has expanded by 141.26 thousand hm<sup>2</sup>, which has led to a decline in ESV of the entire city (especially regarding hydrological adjustment and biodiversity). Nevertheless, although the area of trench and lakes only occupies 1.67-3.16% of the total area of land, its ecological value accounts for an astonishing 23.80-50.70% of the total ESV. At the district level, the primary decline in eco-system services value was noted in the Chongming District in the north and Pudong New Area in the east of Shanghai. However, due to the overall planning of the city and the advantages of its resource endowment, Qingpu District and its surrounding areas in western Shanghai have witnessed improvements in terms of the values of hydrological adjustment, water supply, and environmental purification. This study presents a deeper and more comprehensive understanding of issues regarding ESV in rapidly urbanized areas, thereby providing an important reference for decision-makers regarding the rational layout of cities, sustainable use of land, and management of natural ecosystems.
BibTeX
@article{gong2022assessing,
  author = {Yuan Gong and Mengmeng Cai and Lei Yao and Linsong Cheng and Chunxu Hao and Zheng Zhao},
  title = {{Assessing Changes in the Ecosystem Services Value in Response to Land-Use/Land-Cover Dynamics in Shanghai from 2000 to 2020}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph191912080},
}
Figure