Abstract
Gravitational-wave astronomy has developed enormously over the last decade with the first detections and continuous development across broad frequency bands. However, the decihertz range has largely been left out of this development. Gravitational waves in this band are emitted by some of the most enigmatic sources, including intermediate-mass binary black hole mergers, early inspiraling compact binaries—whose late evolution and merger are seen by Earth-based detectors—, and possibly primordial gravitational waves. To tap this exciting band, we propose the construction of a detector based on pulsar timing principles, the Artificial Precision Timing Array (APTA). We envision APTA as a solar system array of artificial “pulsars”—precision-time-reference-carrying satellites that emit periodic electromagnetic signals towards Earth or other satellite constellation centrum. In this fundamental study, we estimate the clock precision needed for APTA to be able to detect gravitational waves. Our results suggest that 6 satellites and a clock relative uncertainty of $10^{-18}$ at 1 s of averaging, which is currently attainable with atomic clocks, would be sufficient for APTA to reach pristine sensitivity in the decihertz band and be sensitive to $10^3–10^4 M_\odot$ black hole mergers and the early inspiral of heavy LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA sources. Future time reference, oscillator, and clock technologies realistically expected in the next decade(s) would enable the detection of an increasingly diverse set of sources and allow APTA to reach a better sensitivity than other detector concepts proposed for the decihertz band. This work opens up a new area of research into designing and constructing gravitational-wave detectors relying on principles used successfully in pulsar timing.
Introduction
The landscape of gravitational-wave (GW) astronomy is currently divided into two primary observational windows. High-frequency signals (10 Hz – kHz) are detected by ground-based interferometers like LIGO, Virgo, and KAGRA, primarily capturing the final moments of stellar-mass black hole mergers. Conversely, ultra-low frequency signals (nHz) are probed by Pulsar Timing Arrays (PTAs), which utilize natural pulsars to detect the stochastic background from supermassive black hole binaries.
However, a significant "decihertz gap" (0.1–10 Hz) remains largely unexplored. This frequency range is inaccessible to ground-based detectors due to seismic noise and gravity gradients, and it falls above the sensitive band of planned space-based interferometers like LISA. This gap is scientifically critical, hosting signals from intermediate-mass black holes (IMBHs) ($10^3–10^4 M_\odot$), the early inspiral phases of stellar-mass binaries, and potential primordial GWs from the early universe.
The Artificial Precision Timing Array (APTA) Concept
To address this gap, we propose the Artificial Precision Timing Array (APTA). APTA adapts the principles of PTAs to a man-made constellation of satellites. Instead of natural pulsars, APTA utilizes satellites in solar orbit equipped with ultra-precise atomic clocks, such as strontium optical lattice clocks.
These "artificial pulsars" emit periodic electromagnetic signals (radio, optical, or X-ray) to a central receiver. A passing gravitational wave induces timing residuals—slight variations in the arrival times of these pulses. By modeling and subtracting known timing effects, the GW signal can be extracted. This approach leverages technological synergies in optical frequency combs and X-ray pulse generation to transfer clock precision to the transmitted signals.
Sensitivity and Comparative Performance
Our feasibility study indicates that current atomic clock technology is already sufficient to begin exploring the decihertz band. A baseline configuration of six satellites with a clock relative uncertainty of $10^{-18}$ at 1 second of averaging—a performance level currently achievable—would allow for the detection of $10^3–10^4 M_\odot$ black hole mergers at cosmological distances.
As shown in the sensitivity analysis, APTA's performance scales significantly with improvements in clock technology. With near-future clock precision ($10^{-20.5}$), APTA could surpass the sensitivity of other proposed decihertz missions like ALIA or DECIGO in specific frequency ranges. Furthermore, APTA could provide vital early-warning data for multi-messenger astronomy by tracking the inspiral of stellar-mass binaries weeks before they enter the LIGO band, allowing for precise localization and advance pointing of electromagnetic telescopes.
Discussion and Future Directions
While the theoretical foundation for APTA is robust, several practical challenges must be addressed. Future work must incorporate complex timing models to account for Solar System noise, including Shapiro delays and gravity gradients from the asteroid belt. Additionally, while PTAs do not require synchronization, APTA's sensitivity would benefit from advanced time-transfer techniques between satellites. Ensuring that communication link noise (photon noise) remains below the clock-limited threshold is also paramount.
In conclusion, APTA represents a promising new frontier in GW detection, bridging the decihertz gap using established pulsar timing principles and rapidly advancing atomic clock technology. This proposal offers a path toward a more complete understanding of the gravitational-wave universe.
Summary updated