Artificial Lateral Line Based Relative State Estimation for Two Adjacent Robotic Fish

Xingwen Zheng, Wei Wang, Liang Li, Guangming XiearXiv 2020 · DOI · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method for estimating the relative positions and orientations of two adjacent robotic fish using an artificial lateral line system (ALLS) that mimics fish's natural flow sensing. By applying machine learning techniques to pressure sensor data, the system can accurately determine how one fish is positioned and oriented relative to another, a crucial step for coordinated underwater robot behavior.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Coordinated movement and formation control are essential for underwater robot groups, but accurately sensing the relative states (position, orientation, etc.) between individual robots is a significant challenge. Fish, however, excel at this using their natural lateral line system, which detects subtle changes in water flow. This paper aims to replicate this capability by developing an artificial lateral line system (ALLS) for robotic fish that can estimate their relative states, specifically focusing on a leader-follower formation. Previous work has focused on individual robot applications or simpler flow stimuli; this research tackles the more complex scenario of inter-robot sensing using realistic flow patterns generated by one robot's movement.

Methods

The core of this work involves establishing a regression model that links the hydrodynamic pressure variations (HPVs) measured by an ALLS on a "follower" robotic fish to the relative states between it and a "leader" robotic fish.

  • Artificial Lateral Line System (ALLS): The system uses an array of nine pressure sensors strategically placed on the follower robot to capture HPVs generated by the leader's oscillating caudal fin.
  • Sensor Sensitivity and Redundancy Analysis: Before regression, two novel criteria (Ck1 and Ck2) were developed to quantify the sensitivity of each pressure sensor to variations in relative states. This analysis helps identify which sensors are most informative and determine the optimal number of sensors needed, reducing redundancy and computational load.
  • Regression Models: Four common regression algorithms were employed to build the models:
  • Random Forest (RF)
    • Support Vector Regression (SVR)
    • Back Propagation Neural Network (BPNN)
    • Multiple Linear Regression (REG)
  • Model Evaluation: The performance of these models was compared using Mean Absolute Error (MAE) and the coefficient of determination (R²).

Datasets

The study utilized experimental data collected from flume experiments involving two adjacent robotic fish. The upstream (leader) fish had an oscillating caudal fin, generating flow stimuli. The downstream (follower) fish, equipped with the ALLS, recorded the resulting HPVs. The relative states investigated included distance, oscillating frequency, amplitude, offset, yaw angle, pitch angle, and roll angle. The paper does not explicitly mention publicly available datasets but describes the creation of a "sample set O" for training and validation, with specific sizes detailed for different relative states (e.g., 8750 samples for distance 'd').

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Biomimicry for Inter-Robot Sensing: The paper demonstrates that mimicking fish's lateral line system can be highly effective for underwater robots to sense their neighbors, opening doors for more sophisticated multi-robot coordination.
  • Sensor Optimization is Crucial: The proposed sensitivity and redundancy analysis (Ck1, Ck2) is a significant contribution, showing that not all sensors are equally valuable and that using fewer, more informative sensors can improve efficiency without sacrificing accuracy.
  • Random Forest Outperforms: The Random Forest algorithm consistently showed superior performance in estimating relative states compared to SVR, BPNN, and REG, highlighting its robustness and effectiveness for this type of complex, noisy data.
  • Flow Patterns Matter: The use of a realistic flow stimulus (reverse Kármán vortex street from an oscillating caudal fin) is more challenging but more representative of natural underwater interactions than simpler flow conditions.

Key Results

  • High Estimation Accuracy: The Random Forest model achieved excellent estimation performance, with R² values generally above 0.95 for most relative states. For example, for relative distance 'd', the best model achieved R² = 0.972 and MAE = 3.250 mm using only 4 pressure sensors.
  • Optimal Sensor Count Identified: The analysis determined optimal numbers of pressure sensors (M_r) for each relative state, ranging from 1 (for oscillating amplitude 'A') to 7 (for yaw angle 'α'), demonstrating the effectiveness of the sensor selection criteria.
  • Yaw Angle Estimation Challenges: While generally successful, the estimation of relative yaw angle showed degraded performance for larger angles, attributed to a low signal-to-noise ratio in the pressure sensor readings.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Hardware Limitations: The paper acknowledges that the hardware deficiency of the pressure sensors and background noise limit estimation accuracy, particularly for larger relative yaw angles.
  • Controlled Environment: The experiments were conducted in a flume, a controlled environment. Real-world underwater scenarios with more complex and dynamic flow conditions will present greater challenges.
  • Future Work: The authors plan to extend this work to online estimation of relative states for two adjacent freely-swimming robotic fish. They also aim to investigate the impact of the fish's own body motions on the ALLS readings and explore data fusion techniques (e.g., combining ALLS and IMU data) to improve estimation accuracy.

Summary updated

Abstract

The lateral line enables fish to efficiently sense the surrounding environment, thus assisting flow-related fish behaviours. Inspired by this phenomenon, varieties of artificial lateral line systems (ALLSs) have been developed and applied to underwater robots. This article focuses on using the pressure sensor arrays based on ALLS-measured hydrodynamic pressure variations (HPVs) for estimating the relative state between two adjacent robotic fish with leader-follower formation. The relative states include the relative oscillating frequency, amplitude, and offset of the upstream robotic fish to the downstream robotic fish, the relative vertical distance, the relative yaw angle, the relative pitch angle, and the relative roll angle between the two adjacent robotic fish. Regression model between the ALLS-measured and the mentioned relative states is investigated, and regression model-based relative state estimation is conducted. Specifically, two criteria are proposed firstly to investigate not only the sensitivity of each pressure sensor to the variations of relative state but also the insufficiency and redundancy of the pressure sensors. And thus the pressure sensors used for regression analysis are determined. Then four typical regression methods, including random forest algorithm, support vector regression, back propagation neural network, and multiple linear regression method are used for establishing regression models between the ALLS-measured HPVs and the relative states. Then regression effects of the four methods are compared and discussed. Finally, random forest-based method, which has the best regression effect, is used to estimate relative yaw angle and oscillating amplitude using the ALLS-measured HPVs and exhibits excellent estimation performance. This work contributes to local relative estimation for a group of underwater robots, which has always been a challenge.
BibTeX
@misc{zheng2020artificial,
  author = {Xingwen Zheng and Wei Wang and Liang Li and Guangming Xie},
  title = {{Artificial Lateral Line Based Relative State Estimation for Two Adjacent Robotic Fish}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2006.14421},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2006.14421},
}
Figure