Art for health’s sake or health for art’s sake: Disentangling the bidirectional relationships between arts engagement and mental health

Hei Wan Mak, Yang Hu, Feifei Bu, Jessica K. Bone, Daisy FancourtPNAS 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study tackles the long-standing question of whether engaging with the arts improves mental health, or if good mental health leads to more arts engagement. Using sophisticated causal inference methods on a large UK dataset, they found a clear bidirectional relationship: arts engagement can boost mental well-being and reduce distress, and conversely, better mental health encourages more arts participation. This suggests a "virtuous cycle" that interventions could leverage.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For years, research has shown a correlation between arts engagement and better mental health. However, correlation doesn't equal causation. The critical question has been: does art cause better mental health, or do people who already have good mental health tend to engage more with the arts? This ambiguity makes it difficult to design effective public health interventions. The paper aims to disentangle this relationship, determining the direction and strength of the causal links between various forms of arts engagement and different aspects of mental health.

Methods

The researchers employed a novel approach using nonrecursive instrumental variable (IV) models. This statistical technique is designed to address endogeneity and potential reverse causality in observational data.

Here's a breakdown of the key methodological aspects:

  • Nonrecursive Models: Unlike standard recursive models where causality flows in one direction, nonrecursive models allow for simultaneous, bidirectional relationships between variables. This is crucial for testing "feedback loops."
  • Instrumental Variables (IVs): To overcome the limitations of observational data (where unmeasured confounders can distort relationships), IVs were used. These are variables that are correlated with the "endogenous" variable (e.g., arts engagement) but not directly with the outcome (e.g., mental health), except through their effect on the endogenous variable. The study used several types of IVs:
  • Time-lagged variables: Past levels of arts engagement and mental health were used as instruments for current levels.
  • Average regional rates: The average rate of arts engagement in a person's region and the average rate of public library visits in their region were used as instruments for individual arts engagement.
  • Clinical diagnoses and life events: Diagnosed depression and experiencing the death of a loved one were used as instruments for mental health.
  • Two-Continuum Model: The study considered both mental distress (negative aspect) and mental well-being (positive aspect) separately, acknowledging that these are not simply opposite ends of a single spectrum.
  • Cross-Lagged Models: As a complementary analysis, cross-lagged structural equation models were used to examine lagged (i.e., over time) bidirectional effects, providing further support for the findings.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the United Kingdom Household Longitudinal Study (UKHLS). Specifically, data from two waves (Wave 2: 2010-2012 and Wave 5: 2013-2015) were analyzed. This dataset is a large, representative longitudinal survey of UK households, collecting rich information on demographics, socioeconomic status, leisure activities, and health. The analysis focused on a subsample of participants who completed a self-completion module containing mental health measures, resulting in a final analytical sample of 17,927 respondents. No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bidirectional Causality is Real: The most significant finding is the robust evidence for a two-way street between arts engagement and mental health. It's not just one influencing the other; they mutually reinforce each other.
  • Different Arts, Different Impacts: The study differentiated between arts participation (active creation), cultural attendance (e.g., museums, concerts), and heritage visits. Cultural attendance and heritage visits showed reciprocal links with both mental distress and mental well-being. Arts participation, however, was primarily linked to mental well-being, not distress.
  • Modest but Meaningful Effects: While the causal effects are described as "modest," the paper emphasizes that they are "clearly demonstrated." This suggests that even small, consistent influences can have a cumulative impact on population mental health.
  • Breaking the Vicious Cycle: The findings highlight the potential for a "vicious cycle" where poor mental health leads to less arts engagement, which in turn exacerbates poor mental health. Conversely, a "virtuous cycle" exists where good mental health encourages arts engagement, further boosting well-being. Interventions aimed at increasing arts engagement could be key to disrupting negative cycles.

Key Results

  • Cultural Attendance & Heritage Visits:
    • A one-standard deviation (SD) increase in cultural attendance or heritage visits was associated with a 0.06 SD reduction in mental distress and a 0.08 SD increase in mental well-being.
  • Conversely, a one-SD increase in mental distress was associated with a 0.08 SD reduction in cultural attendance and a 0.06 SD reduction in heritage visits.
  • Arts Participation:
    • A one-SD increase in arts participation was associated with a 0.04 SD increase in mental well-being.
  • However, no significant reciprocal association was found between arts participation and mental distress.
  • Lagged Effects: Cross-lagged models confirmed these bidirectional relationships over a ~3-year period, showing that past engagement influenced future mental health and vice versa.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Measurement of Arts Engagement: The study used broad measures of arts engagement frequency. Future work could explore the impact of specific types of activities within these categories and how engagement is measured (e.g., active vs. passive).
  • Mental Health Measures: While the GHQ-12 and SF-12 are standard, future research could explore if these bidirectional relationships hold for other specific mental health diagnoses (e.g., clinical depression, anxiety).
  • Unmeasured Heterogeneity: Despite the use of IVs, the possibility of unmeasured confounders influencing the results cannot be entirely ruled out.
  • Evolving Forms of Engagement: The study's data collection period predates some newer forms of digital arts engagement (e.g., social media creation), which could be explored in future research.
  • Life Course and Duration: The study did not deeply explore how these reciprocal relationships evolve across the lifespan or their long-term persistence.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that future research should continue to examine these bidirectional links, particularly exploring sociodemographic heterogeneities to inform targeted interventions. They also emphasize the need for interventions that increase arts engagement as a potentially more feasible approach to breaking negative feedback loops than solely focusing on mitigating mental health issues.

Summary updated

Abstract

Increasing evidence links arts engagement with mental health, but the directionality of the link remains unclear. Applying a novel approach to causal inference, we used nonrecursive instrumental variable models to analyze two waves of data from the United Kingdom Household Longitudinal Study (<i>n</i> = 17,927). Our findings reveal bidirectional causal relationships between arts engagement (arts participation, cultural attendance, and heritage visits) and mental health (GHQ-12 mental distress and SF-12 Mental Component Summary mental well-being). After adjusting for time 1 measures and identifying confounders, cultural attendance and heritage visits were reciprocally associated with mental distress and mental well-being, while arts participation was only reciprocally associated with mental well-being. The bidirectional effects between arts engagement and mental health are modest but clearly demonstrated not only from mental health to arts but also from arts to mental health. Our findings indicate that previous evidence of an association between arts engagement and mental health is due to bidirectional causal effects. Interventions that boost arts participation, cultural attendance, and heritage visits may help break the negative feedback loop and enhance mental health.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mak2024art,
  author = {Hei Wan Mak and Yang Hu and Feifei Bu and Jessica K. Bone and Daisy Fancourt},
  title = {{Art for health’s sake or health for art’s sake: Disentangling the bidirectional relationships between arts engagement and mental health}},
  booktitle = {PNAS},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1093/pnasnexus/pgae465},
}
Figure