Argumentation in Representation Semantics

Pierre-Yves RaccahCOLING 1984

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel "Representation Semantics" framework that integrates argumentative indications into sentence meaning, going beyond traditional informative content. It argues that understanding how sentences are used to argue for conclusions is crucial for a complete semantic analysis, and outlines a method to formally capture this "pre-argumentative" aspect.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional semantic theories often focus on the literal, informative content of sentences, neglecting how language is used to persuade or influence. The paper highlights that the same sentence can be used to argue for different, even opposite, conclusions depending on the context and underlying beliefs (e.g., "It is 8 o'clock" can imply it's late or early). This gap means that a purely informative semantic analysis fails to capture the full argumentative power of language. The authors aim to bridge this gap by developing a formal semantic framework that explicitly accounts for these argumentative orientations.

Methods

The paper introduces "Representation Semantics," a framework inspired by Montague grammar but with a key divergence: it aims to represent aspects of meaning rather than a single, complete meaning. This includes:

  • Partial Models: Representing presuppositional, informative, and pre-argumentative content through partial models.
  • Conventional Implicature: Utilizing Karttunen and Peters' framework for conventional implicature.
  • Pre-argumentative Analysis: A novel component that identifies "argumentative indications" within sentences. These indications, distinct from informative content, guide how a sentence can be used in argumentation.
  • Topoi: Adopting and adapting Aristotle's concept of "topoi" (argument schemes) to describe the movement from an utterance to a conclusion. The paper proposes a specific form for topoi that considers the speaker's epistemic relation to the premise.
  • Compositional Description of Connectives: Developing rules for how argumentative aspects are composed when connectives like "but" are used, ensuring that the meaning of the whole reflects the argumentative orientations of its parts.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Argumentation is Semantic: The paper argues that argumentative power is not purely pragmatic but is encoded within the semantics of sentences as "argumentative indications."
  • Beyond Informative Content: The meaning of a sentence must include more than just what it states; it needs to convey how it can be used to support or oppose conclusions.
  • "Pre-argumentation" as a Semantic Component: The concept of "pre-argumentation" is introduced as a formal semantic construct that captures the inherent argumentative potential of a sentence, independent of specific utterance situations.
  • Topoi as Argumentative Bridges: Topoi are crucial for connecting the semantic pre-argumentative content to actual argumentative conclusions, and their form needs to account for speaker belief.
  • Compositionality of Argumentation: Connectives like "but" have a compositional effect on argumentative orientation, dictating how the arguments of connected clauses interact.

Key Results

The paper provides a formal framework for analyzing the argumentative aspects of sentences, illustrated with an example of the sentence "The present king of France is very old but he plays Jazz." The analysis correctly predicts:

  • The presupposition that there is a unique "present king of France."
  • The assertion that this entity is "very old" and "plays Jazz."
  • The argumentative orientation of "but" which requires that the two clauses be interpreted as oriented towards opposite conclusions.
  • The selection of appropriate topoi (e.g., old people tend not to like Jazz vs. people who play Jazz tend to like it) based on the pre-argumentative content.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Young Theory: The authors acknowledge that the theory is still in its early stages, with its formal version being even younger and imperfect.
  • Methodological Incursion: While the focus is on semantics, the authors admit to a slight methodological incursion into pragmatics to guide their semantic analysis.
  • Empirical Justification: The justification for "pre-argumentation" is presented as theoretical rather than empirical, with the authors noting that even "ugly" notions like informative content have more intuitive backup.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that a computer version of a fragment of French is under study, and much work remains to be done on the pre-argumentative aspects and topoi rules. The authors also express a desire for the theory to be tested for its applicability to Artificial Intelligence.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{raccah1984argumentation,
  author = {Pierre-Yves Raccah},
  title = {{Argumentation in Representation Semantics}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Computational Linguistics},
  year = {1984},
}
Figure