Arguing Using Opponent Models

Nir Oren, Timothy J. NormanArgMAS 2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel strategy for artificial agents to engage in argumentative dialogues by building and utilizing "opponent models." This approach allows agents to dynamically adapt their arguments based on their beliefs about the other participant's knowledge and goals, leading to more effective persuasion and negotiation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the realm of artificial intelligence and argumentation, much research has focused on the logical structure of arguments and determining their acceptability. However, a critical aspect often overlooked is the strategic element of argumentation: how an agent should choose which argument to present at any given moment in a dialogue to achieve its objectives. This paper addresses this gap by proposing a heuristic that leverages opponent modeling to inform argument selection. Traditional approaches often assume a fixed or adversarial opponent, whereas this work aims to equip agents with the ability to reason about and exploit an opponent's specific beliefs and goals, moving beyond simple min-max strategies.

Methods

The core of the paper's contribution lies in adapting and extending the M search algorithm, a technique commonly used in game playing, for the domain of argumentation. The M algorithm, originally designed for calculating optimal moves in games with adversarial opponents, is modified to incorporate an "opponent model." This opponent model is essentially a representation of the agent's beliefs about the other participant, including their knowledge base, goals, and even their own opponent model (leading to recursive modeling).

The paper introduces two key enhancements:

  1. Opponent Model Integration: The M* algorithm is adapted to take an agent's opponent model as input. This allows the agent to predict the opponent's likely responses and choose arguments that maximize its own utility, considering these predicted responses.
  2. Relevance Filtering: To prune the search space and improve efficiency, the authors introduce a "relevance" concept. An argument is considered relevant if it can affect the status of the agent's goal arguments. This filtering mechanism, along with a specialized legalMoves function that incorporates argumentation semantics, helps to focus the search on more promising lines of argument.

The paper defines abstract arguments and dialogues, and then formalizes the agent's structure, including its knowledge base, goals, and opponent model. The proposed algorithm, M*el, uses these components to search for the optimal argument to advance.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Opponent Modeling is Crucial for Strategic Argumentation: Simply having a strong logical argument isn't enough; knowing when and how to present it, based on an understanding of the opponent, is key to achieving dialogue goals.
  • Recursive Opponent Modeling: The ability for an agent to model its opponent's model of itself (and so on) allows for deeper strategic reasoning, akin to thinking multiple steps ahead in a game.
  • Relevance as a Pruning Mechanism: Focusing on arguments that directly impact the agent's goals significantly reduces the search space, making complex strategic reasoning more computationally feasible.
  • Bridging Logic and Strategy: The work effectively bridges the gap between the logical evaluation of arguments and the strategic, procedural aspects of dialogue management.

Key Results

The paper primarily presents a theoretical framework and algorithmic approach. While specific quantitative results are not detailed, the authors argue that their approach, by incorporating opponent modeling, will outperform simpler strategies like min-max search. They highlight that their relevance-based pruning and specialized legalMoves function are designed to reduce computational complexity and improve the efficiency of the search process. The example provided illustrates how an agent can use its opponent model to anticipate a winning move (an opponent passing) that a non-strategic agent might miss.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest promising avenues for future research:

  • Errors in Opponent Models: The current framework assumes accurate opponent models. Future work should investigate the impact of errors or uncertainty in these models on strategy quality and explore how agents can adapt to imperfect information.
  • Probabilistic Opponent Modeling: Extending the approach to handle probabilistic beliefs about the opponent's knowledge and goals would allow for more robust strategies in uncertain environments.
  • Learning Opponent Models: The paper assumes opponent models are given. Future research could focus on how agents can learn or update their opponent models during a dialogue or through repeated interactions.
  • More Complex Dialogue Structures: The current work primarily deals with turn-based dialogues where agents make single utterances. Extending the framework to handle more complex dialogue structures and interaction patterns is a potential future direction.
  • Computational Complexity: While pruning techniques are introduced, the worst-case computational complexity remains a concern. Further optimizations and exploration of techniques like alpha-beta pruning and transposition tables are suggested.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{oren2009arguing,
  author = {Nir Oren and Timothy J. Norman},
  title = {{Arguing Using Opponent Models}},
  booktitle = {ArgMAS},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-642-12805-9\_10},
}
Figure