Are You Being Served?

AAAI 1997

TL;DR

This paper introduces Captain Peacock and Mr. Humphries, a pair of service robots designed to provide a high-touch, socially aware catering experience at AI conferences. They aim to go beyond mere functionality, offering a sophisticated level of service that mimics human butlers, prioritizing social standing and customer pampering.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The authors identify a gap in current service robot capabilities: while functional, they lack "panache" and social intelligence. In contexts like AI conferences, where social standing and a pampered experience are highly valued, existing robots fail to meet expectations. The paper addresses the challenge of creating robots that not only perform tasks like food delivery but do so with a level of style and social awareness that elevates the user experience, moving beyond purely utilitarian service.

Methods

The system employs a multi-robot approach, with Captain Peacock acting as the primary service coordinator and Mr. Humphries as the direct service provider.

  • Captain Peacock: A sophisticated robot that roams the floor, identifies individuals needing service, and then "calls in" Mr. Humphries. It uses a RWI B-21 robot base, a Cognachrome vision system for tracking Mr. Humphries, and interacts via paddle buttons, an onboard voice synthesizer, and a simple voice recognition system on a Powerbook.
  • Mr. Humphries: A modified TinMan robotic wheelchair equipped with a motorized tray system for easy food delivery. It also features a Cognachrome system to track Captain Peacock and a sonar system for obstacle avoidance.
  • Inter-robot Communication: Robots are connected via radio modems.
  • Navigation and Tracking: Both robots use color targets for tracking each other. They are equipped with sonars, IR proximity sensors, and bump sensors for obstacle avoidance. Captain Peacock uses color tracking and a downward-looking sensor to observe room boundaries and employs dead reckoning for navigation.
  • Human-Robot Interaction: Mr. Humphries can detect when a person is seated or entering/leaving a seat. It can also allow for shared control via a joystick, factoring user input into its obstacle avoidance.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Servant Robot" Ideal: The paper highlights the desire for "servant robots" that offer social status and pampering, not just functional assistance, drawing a parallel to the desire for human butlers without the social complexities.
  • Multi-Robot Synergy: The division of labor between Captain Peacock (coordination and identification) and Mr. Humphries (direct service) creates a more sophisticated and efficient service model.
  • Style Over Pure Functionality: The emphasis is on delivering service with "old-world flavor" and social inferiority, suggesting that the manner of service is as crucial as the service itself for certain social contexts.
  • Social Awareness in Service: Mr. Humphries' ability to detect seating status and allow for shared control demonstrates a nascent form of social awareness, adapting its behavior based on the user's state.

Key Results

The paper describes the successful implementation and deployment of Captain Peacock and Mr. Humphries at the AAAI-97 Conference Reception. The robots were able to roam the floor, identify individuals, deliver food, and offer seating assistance. The authors conclude that while distributing food is easy, serving it with style is a more difficult task, and they believe their robots achieve this goal, pampering customers beyond robotic peers and even human counterparts.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: The paper implicitly acknowledges the limitations of current AI by referencing Batman's Alfred as an example of abilities "well beyond the current state of AI" for managing a large estate. The reliance on distinct color targets for tracking might be a limitation in more cluttered or dynamically changing environments.
  • Future Work: The paper doesn't explicitly detail future work but implies that enhancing the robots' social intelligence and interaction capabilities would be a natural progression. The concept of shared control via joystick suggests a direction towards more intuitive and collaborative human-robot interaction.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{1997are,
  title = {{Are You Being Served?}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {1997},
}
Figure