Are the corporate voluntary disclosures and transparency in the transitional economy better than the pre-transitional economy? Evidence from developing country

Shamsul Nahar Abdullah, Mofijul Hoq Masum, Mohammad Faridul AlamInternational Journal of Management and Sustainability 2024 · DOI

Abstract

This study explores the evolution of corporate voluntary disclosure and transparency as strategic tools during a country's transition from "Least Developed Country" (LDC) status. Using a comparative approach, we analyze 307 paired annual reports from companies listed on the Dhaka Stock Exchange (DSE) across pre-transitional (2012–2015) and transitional (2016–2019) stages. Our findings indicate a significant increase in voluntary disclosures during the transitional phase. This shift suggests that firms leverage transparency to attract international investors and navigate the move from an aid-based to a trade-based economy, ultimately supporting Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).

Introduction

As developing nations graduate from LDC status, they face a critical economic pivot. While graduation signifies progress, it often results in the loss of preferential trade quotas and foreign aid. To sustain growth, these nations must transition to trade-based economies fueled by private investment. However, international investors often perceive transitional economies as high-risk due to information asymmetry. This paper investigates whether corporate behavior shifts to mitigate these risks through increased voluntary disclosure—information shared beyond legal requirements to signal legitimacy and attract capital.

Methodology and Data

The research employs a longitudinal, comparative design focusing on Bangladesh, which met the UN's graduation criteria in 2018.

Sample Selection

The study analyzed the population of companies on the Dhaka Stock Exchange. Starting with an initial pool of 872 annual reports, the researchers applied rigorous exclusion criteria, such as removing unaudited reports and companies without an eight-year history, to arrive at a final paired sample of 307 companies. This ensures that the comparison between the pre-transitional and transitional periods is consistent and robust.

Table 1: Sample selection process for pre-transition and transition periods.

The Voluntary Disclosure Index

A self-constructed, unweighted Voluntary Disclosure (VD) Index was developed, comprising 77 items across nine dimensions, including governance, climate change, and social disclosures. These items were uniquely mapped against the United Nations' three graduation criteria: Gross National Income (GNI) per capita, the Human Assets Index (HAI), and the Economic Vulnerability Index (EVI).

Results: The Shift Toward Transparency

Statistical analysis reveals a clear and significant upward trend in corporate transparency as the macro-economic environment shifted.

Table 2: Descriptive statistics of Voluntary Disclosure (VD) scores across both phases.

As shown in the statistical summary, the mean VD score increased from 16.11 in the pre-transition phase to 20.70 in the transition phase. A paired t-test confirmed this increase is statistically significant (t = 5.604, p < 0.001). Furthermore, the maximum disclosure score rose from 53 to 75, indicating that leading firms are pushing the boundaries of transparency. A moderate positive correlation (0.655) suggests that while the entire market improved, firms with existing transparency foundations led the transition.

Discussion: Transparency as a Strategic Tool

The findings support Legitimacy Theory, suggesting that as traditional aid-based support wanes, firms feel a heightened "social contract" to prove their value to global stakeholders. Voluntary disclosure evolves from a reporting chore into a survival mechanism. By opening their books, companies in transitional economies signal stability and alignment with international ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) standards, which are increasingly demanded by trade partners and foreign investors.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This study demonstrates a direct link between national economic milestones (LDC graduation) and micro-level corporate behavior. For transitional economies, fostering a culture of transparency is vital for attracting the investment needed to replace declining foreign aid.

Future research should expand this scope to other graduating LDCs like Nepal or Laos and incorporate qualitative interviews to better understand management's strategic intent. Additionally, investigating the direct link between increased disclosure and financial performance (e.g., cost of capital) remains a critical next step for researchers and policymakers alike.

Summary updated

Abstract

The study’s goal is to explore the role of corporate voluntary disclosure and transparency as a strategic tool rather than corporate reporting techniques. This empirical study employs a comparative approach to identify the variations in corporate voluntary disclosure in the pre-transitional and transitional stages of a developing country. A paired sample of 307 annual reports of the Dhaka Stock Exchange (DSE) listed companies is considered to explore their reporting practices between the pre-transitional and transitional stages. Lately, a paired t-test has been conducted to examine whether corporate voluntary disclosure significantly differs between the pre-transitional economy and transitional economy. It is found that the corporate people disclose more information in the transitional phase of the emerging economy rather than the pre-transitional phase. The findings of the study will assist emerging countries in designing their corporate strategies to achieve the Sustainable Development Goal (SDG). The study suggests that using voluntary disclosure as a strategic tool can help retain and attract both existing and prospective investors. This study also helps the regulatory body shape its macro-level corporate strategy to successfully graduate from the LDC to the developing economy. Moreover, this study will assist the transitional economy to transform from an aid-based economy to a trade-based economy.
BibTeX
@article{abdullah2024are,
  author = {Shamsul Nahar Abdullah and Mofijul Hoq Masum and Mohammad Faridul Alam},
  title = {{Are the corporate voluntary disclosures and transparency in the transitional economy better than the pre-transitional economy? Evidence from developing country}},
  journal = {International Journal of Management and Sustainability},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.18488/11.v13i4.3877},
}
Figure