Are Sustainable Banks Efficient and Productive? A Data Envelopment Analysis and the Malmquist Productivity Index Analysis

Akber Aman Shah, Desheng Wu, Vladmir KorotkovSustainability 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates whether sustainable banks are more efficient and productive than their non-sustainable counterparts. Using Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) and the Malmquist Productivity Index (MPI) on a dataset of banks from 2010-2018, the research finds that sustainable banks indeed exhibit higher efficiency and productivity, suggesting that integrating sustainability into business strategy can lead to better performance.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the question of whether corporate sustainability, encompassing environmental protection, financial benefit, and social responsibility, translates into tangible improvements in operating performance and productivity for banks. While the concept of sustainability is gaining traction, there's a lack of conclusive evidence demonstrating its direct link to financial outcomes, especially when investors begin to standardize sustainable strategies. This ambiguity creates a challenge for banks in adopting and justifying sustainable practices, and for investors in evaluating them. The study aims to fill this gap by providing empirical evidence on the performance of sustainable banks compared to non-sustainable ones.

Methods

The study employs a two-stage performance evaluation framework.

  1. Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA): This non-parametric method is used to assess the relative efficiency of decision-making units (DMUs), in this case, banks. DEA is chosen because it can handle multiple inputs and outputs without requiring pre-defined weights or explicit functional relationships. The study utilizes both the CCR (Charnes, Cooper, and Rhodes) and BCC (Banker, Charnes, and Cooper) models to measure overall technical efficiency, pure technical efficiency, and scale efficiency. Input-oriented and output-oriented approaches are considered.
  2. Malmquist Productivity Index (MPI): This index is used to measure productivity changes over time. It decomposes productivity growth into two components: technical efficiency change (catch-up effect) and technological change (frontier shift). MPI is particularly useful as it doesn't require input/output prices and can handle multiple inputs/outputs.

The integration of these two techniques allows for a comprehensive evaluation of both static efficiency and dynamic productivity changes over a nine-year period.

Datasets

The study uses data from 2010 to 2018 for a sample of banks.

  • Sustainable Banks (SBs): These are identified as banks listed in the Dow Jones Sustainability Indices (DJSI) in 2018.
  • Non-Sustainable Banks (NSBs): These are banks from the same countries as SBs and with similar specializations, but not listed in the DJSI.

The dataset comprises 33 SBs and 247 NSBs, totaling 248 banks from 14 countries. The inputs used are assets, equity, employees, and expenses, while the outputs are revenue and profit. All values are in thousands of USD, except for employees, which are in thousands.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Sustainability Pays Off: The core finding is that sustainable banks are demonstrably more efficient and productive than their non-sustainable counterparts. This provides strong empirical support for the business case of sustainability.
  • External vs. Internal Drivers: The study suggests that the productivity of sustainable banks is more influenced by external factors (like government policies and technological advancements), while non-sustainable banks' productivity is more driven by internal factors (how they utilize their own resources). This highlights how SBs might be more attuned to broader market and policy shifts.
  • Regional and Specialization Differences: The analysis reveals that efficiency and productivity can vary significantly based on a bank's region and its specific specialization. This implies that a one-size-fits-all approach to sustainability might not be optimal, and tailored strategies could be more effective.
  • DEA and MPI as Powerful Tools: The paper successfully demonstrates the utility of combining DEA and MPI for a robust evaluation of bank performance, offering a nuanced view of both static efficiency and dynamic productivity.

Key Results

  • Efficiency Scores: Sustainable banks consistently achieved higher mean efficiency scores across various measures (technical efficiency, pure technical efficiency, scale efficiency) compared to non-sustainable banks. For instance, the mean technical efficiency for SBs was 0.908, significantly higher than the 0.659 for NSBs.
  • Productivity Growth: The Malmquist Productivity Index analysis showed that SBs had a higher mean productivity score (1.030) compared to NSBs (0.991), indicating overall productivity growth for sustainable banks over the study period.
  • Drivers of Productivity: Technical Change (TC) was found to be a more significant driver of productivity for SBs, while Technical Efficiency Change (TEC) was more influential for NSBs.
  • Statistical Significance: The differences in means and medians for technical efficiency, pure technical efficiency, and scale efficiency between SBs and NSBs were statistically significant (p-values < 0.05), reinforcing the robustness of the findings.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations: The study acknowledges that the selection of SBs was based on DJSI listing in 2018, which might not capture all banks genuinely practicing sustainability. Future research could explore broader sustainability criteria.
  • Causality: While the study shows a correlation between sustainability and performance, it doesn't definitively establish causality. Further research could explore causal mechanisms more deeply.
  • Framework Development: The authors suggest developing new frameworks that combine parametric and non-parametric approaches, as well as exploring methods like the stochastic frontier approach and analytical hierarchical process, to further refine the study of bank efficiency and productivity.
  • Broader Application: The developed framework could potentially be applied to other industries beyond banking, such as insurance, production, and healthcare.

Summary updated

Abstract

Corporate sustainability is the integration of environmental protection, financial benefit, and social responsibility into management and business operations. There is insufficient evidence for its relationship with operating performance and productivity. Furthermore, it becomes doubtful when investors standardize corporate sustainable strategies. This study evaluates the performance and productivity of sustainable banks, exploring practical issues by providing supporting evidence. A two-stage performance evaluation is employed with the integration of data envelopment analysis (DEA) and Malmquist productivity index (MPI) to evaluate sustainable bank performance and productivity for 9 years (2010–2018) in comparison with non-sustainable banks. DEA is used to define dynamic benchmarking, and MPI builds on time-series analysis. The results of our study reveal that sustainable banks are more efficient and productive. The productivity of sustainable banks and non-sustainable banks was influenced by external and internal factors, respectively.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shah2019are,
  author = {Akber Aman Shah and Desheng Wu and Vladmir Korotkov},
  title = {{Are Sustainable Banks Efficient and Productive? A Data Envelopment Analysis and the Malmquist Productivity Index Analysis}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/su11082398},
}
Figure