Abstract: We investigate whether stablecoins are safe havens for traditional cryptocurrencies with fresh evidence from the recent crisis period of the COVID-19 pandemic. Our results support the safe-haven properties of Tether for both before and during the pandemic. For Digix, a gold-backed stablecoin with relatively small market capitalization, we find a change in characteristics before and during the pandemic, but do not find statistically significant evidence for its safe-haven properties. Furthermore, we document that, when considering the economic benefits and costs of adding safe-haven assets into cryptocurrency portfolios, the one with Tether outperforms both a naked portfolio and the portfolio with a traditional safe-haven asset such as gold.
Introduction
Cryptocurrencies are notoriously volatile, leading investors to seek "safe havens"—assets that maintain or increase in value during market downturns. While traditional finance relies on gold or treasury bonds, the cryptocurrency ecosystem has developed "stablecoins" as a native solution. This study, published in Applied Finance Letters, investigates whether stablecoins lived up to their name during the extreme market volatility of the COVID-19 pandemic. By analyzing Tether (USD-backed) and Digix (gold-backed), the researchers evaluate if these assets provide genuine protection during a global liquidity crisis.
Methodology
The researchers employed a two-pronged approach using bi-hourly price data from Bitfinex.com spanning December 2018 to June 2020. This period was divided into pre-pandemic (Dec 2018 – Dec 2019) and pandemic (Jan 2020 – June 2020) phases.
Econometric Modeling
The study utilized a regression model specifically designed to capture "extreme downward movements," defined as the bottom 10% of Bitcoin’s return distribution. This allowed the authors to isolate how stablecoins reacted specifically when Bitcoin experienced significant losses.
Portfolio Analysis
Four hypothetical $1 million portfolios were constructed: Bitcoin only, and Bitcoin mixed with Tether, Digix, or physical Gold. The authors argue that the standard Sharpe ratio is mathematically flawed when returns are negative. Consequently, they employed three alternative metrics:
- Certainty Equivalent Return (CER): The guaranteed return an investor would accept over a risky portfolio.
- Expected Shortfall (ES): The average loss in worst-case scenarios.
- Economic Value of the Incremental Expected Shortfall (EVIES): A novel metric evaluating the cost-efficiency of hedging strategies.
Key Results and Discussion
The empirical results confirm that Tether (USDT) consistently served as a safe haven for Bitcoin investors. During extreme crashes, Tether showed a statistically significant negative correlation with Bitcoin, effectively acting as a buffer. In contrast, Digix (DGX), despite being backed by gold, failed to provide statistically significant protection. The authors attribute this to Digix's low market capitalization ($7 million at the time), suggesting that liquidity and market dominance are more critical for a safe haven than the nature of the underlying collateral.
As shown in Figure 1, the portfolios containing safe-haven assets maintained higher performance levels during the sharp decline in mid-March 2020 compared to the "Naked Portfolio of Bitcoin."
Economic Benefits of Hedging
The study found that a crypto-native hedging strategy using Tether outperformed traditional physical gold. In a $1 million portfolio during the pandemic, a "naked" Bitcoin position had an Expected Shortfall of $126,363. Adding a 10% position in Tether reduced this loss to $113,278.
According to the data in Figure 5, Tether provided the highest net economic value (EVIES) at $769.13, outperforming physical gold ($632.00). This suggests that for cryptocurrency investors, fiat-backed stablecoins may offer more efficient risk reduction than traditional commodities.
Conclusion
The COVID-19 pandemic served as a high-stakes stress test for stablecoins. The findings suggest that Tether is a reliable safe haven, while the failure of Digix highlights that collateral type is secondary to market liquidity and size. Future research should further investigate the heterogeneity of stablecoins to determine why certain assets remain "stabler" than others during global crises.
Reference: Kang, S. B., Xie, Y., & Zhao, J. (2021). Are Stablecoins Safe Havens for Traditional Cryptocurrencies? An Empirical Study during the COVID-19 Pandemic. Applied Finance Letters, 10, 2-9.
Summary updated