TL;DR
This paper investigates whether firms are finding fewer opportunities to improve their performance through new IT investments. Using an event study approach that analyzes stock price reactions to macroeconomic news, the authors find that, contrary to some beliefs, firms continue to discover and leverage new IT opportunities, and these investments are not diminishing.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The central question this paper tackles is whether the "wellspring" of new IT-enabled opportunities for firms to enhance their performance is drying up. For decades, IT has been a significant driver of productivity and innovation. However, some argue that as IT becomes more standardized and integrated, the unique advantages it once offered are diminishing, leading firms to focus more on maintaining existing systems (Current Business Investments - CBIs) rather than exploring new frontiers (New Initiative Investments - NIIs). This debate has implications for the future of IT's role in economic growth and the IT industry itself. The authors aim to empirically test whether the opportunities for NIIs are indeed declining.
Methods
The authors employ an event study methodology, a standard technique in finance and economics, to analyze the impact of macroeconomic news on the stock prices of different industry groups. The core idea is that the stock market's reaction to news signals how sensitive demand for a firm's products is to economic conditions.
- Event Study: They identify macroeconomic news releases (e.g., consumer confidence, inflation, GDP) as "events."
- Volatility Analysis: They measure the volatility of stock prices for different industry groups in response to these events. Higher volatility suggests greater sensitivity to economic changes, which is interpreted as demand for more discretionary products (NIIs). Lower volatility suggests demand for necessities (CBIs).
- Industry Comparison: They compare the volatility of IT firms to that of "Widely Used Current Business Input" (WUCBI) industries (utilities and transportation/freight) as a benchmark. The hypothesis is that if IT opportunities are diminishing, IT firms' stock price volatility should become less sensitive to economic news, approaching that of WUCBI firms.
- Hypothesis Testing: They formulate specific hypotheses to test whether IT industry volatility is decreasing over time and whether specific IT sectors (e.g., those providing necessities vs. discretionary products) exhibit different sensitivities.
Datasets
The study utilizes financial market data from 1980 to 2007.
- Publicly Traded Firms: Data was collected for firms in the IT industry, as well as two benchmark WUCBI industries: utilities (UT) and transportation/freight (TF).
- Macroeconomic News Releases: Data on a comprehensive set of 16 different types of macroeconomic announcements was gathered.
- Industry Classification: The North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) at the six-digit level was used to categorize firms.
- Financial Data: Daily stock price data was obtained from the Center for Research in Security Prices (CRSP) database, and firm-specific data (like NAICS codes) from the Compustat database.
Key Insights and Ideas
- IT as a Driver of Growth: The paper reinforces the idea that IT is a crucial driver of productivity and innovation, and that firms' continued investment in new IT uses is essential for economic dynamism.
- NIIs vs. CBIs: The distinction between investments in new initiatives (NIIs) and investments to maintain current operations (CBIs) is central. NIIs are seen as discretionary and more sensitive to economic downturns, while CBIs are necessities.
- Dynamic Product Life Cycles: The study highlights that IT products and services can transition from being NIIs (opportunities for growth) to CBIs (necessities for operation) over time. This transition is crucial for understanding the evolving value of IT.
- Industry Benchmarking: Using WUCBI industries as a benchmark is a clever way to assess whether IT's sensitivity to economic conditions is changing relative to sectors that provide essential inputs.
Key Results
- Hypothesis 1 (IT Volatility is Decreasing): Not Supported. The study found that the volatility of IT firms' stock prices in response to macroeconomic news has not become less sensitive over time. This suggests that opportunities for new IT investments are not diminishing.
- Hypothesis 2 (CBI-focused IT Firms are Less Sensitive): Supported. Firms providing primarily CBI products (e.g., IT firms managing computing facilities) showed significantly lower stock price volatility, similar to WUCBI industries, supporting the idea that these are necessities.
- Hypothesis 3 (NII-focused IT Firms are More Sensitive): Supported. Firms providing products for new IT applications (e.g., RFID product producers) exhibited much higher stock price volatility, indicating these are more discretionary and sensitive to economic conditions.
- Hypothesis 4 (NIIs Transition to CBIs): Supported. The analysis of firms providing ERP, SCM, and CRM systems indicated that while these were once NIIs, they are increasingly becoming CBIs for many firms, especially ERP systems. This supports the idea of a transition over time.
Limitations and Future Work
- Firm Categorization: The authors acknowledge that categorizing firms into IT, WUCBI, or specific IT sub-sectors can be challenging and might influence results. They note that using SIC codes for some hypotheses did not change the qualitative results, but a more selective categorization could yield stronger evidence.
- Event Study Limitations: The study's reliance on macroeconomic news events means it captures broad economic shifts. It doesn't directly observe individual firm investment decisions.
- Future Research Directions:
- Investigating the "supply side" of IT investment decisions by surveying IT managers.
- Examining the impact of specific technologies (like cloud computing) over time, as they may transition rapidly from NII to CBI.
- Exploring how IT investment risks have changed over time.
- Applying the theoretical model to other business disciplines, such as marketing, to study product diffusion patterns.
- Investigating whether expert forecasts are less accurate for discretionary products than necessities.
- Analyzing firm-level IT investment data to understand how changing economic conditions affect these decisions.
Summary updated