Are ambiguity aversion and ambiguity intolerance identical? A neuroeconomics investigation

Yusuke Tanaka, Junya Fujino, Takashi Ideno, Shigetaka Okubo, Kazuhisa Takemura, Jun Miyata, Ryosaku Kawada, Shinsuke Fujimoto, Manabu Kubota, Akihiko Sasamoto, Kimito Hirose, Hideaki Takeuchi, Hidenao Fukuyama, Toshiya Murai, Hidehiko TakahashiFrontiers in Psychology 2015 · DOI

Abstract

In recent years, there has been growing interest in understanding a person's reaction to ambiguous situations, and two similar constructs related to ambiguity, "ambiguity aversion" and "ambiguity intolerance," are defined in different disciplines. In the field of economic decision-making research, "ambiguity aversion" represents a preference for known risks relative to unknown risks. On the other hand, in clinical psychology, "ambiguity intolerance" describes the tendency to perceive ambiguous situations as undesirable. However, it remains unclear whether these two notions derived from different disciplines are identical or not. To clarify this issue, we combined an economic task, psychological questionnaires, and voxel-based morphometry (VBM) of structural brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in a sample of healthy volunteers. Our results suggest that ambiguity aversion, described in decision theory, may not necessarily be identical to ambiguity intolerance, referred to in clinical psychology. Cautious applications of decision theory to clinical neuropsychiatry are recommended.

Introduction: Two Disciplines, One Term?

In a world of uncertainty, how do we react when we don't know the odds? Researchers in economics and clinical psychology have developed distinct ways to describe this reaction, often using terms that sound synonymous but may represent different underlying traits.

  1. Ambiguity Aversion (Economics): This is the preference for "known risks" over "unknown risks." For example, an individual might prefer a 50% chance of winning a prize over a mystery chance that could range anywhere from 0% to 100%.
  2. Ambiguity Intolerance (Clinical Psychology): This is a broader psychological tendency to perceive ambiguous or "gray area" situations as threatening or uncomfortable, often linked to clinical conditions like anxiety and depression.

Researchers frequently use these terms interchangeably. This study investigates whether an economist's measure of "ambiguity aversion" using gambling tasks actually reflects a patient's psychological "ambiguity intolerance."

Methods and Data

The researchers recruited a primary sample of 31 healthy Japanese volunteers (undergraduate and graduate students). After excluding 5 participants for failing to follow logical choice patterns, a final sample of $N=26$ was analyzed using a three-pronged assessment:

The Economic Task

Participants played a lottery game involving two bowls of colored chips. One bowl had known ratios (e.g., 12 blue, 12 red), representing a "risky" trial. The other bowl had hidden ratios covered by a "black occluder," representing an "ambiguous" trial. By observing choices across 60 trials, the team calculated a mathematical parameter ($\beta$) for each person's specific level of ambiguity aversion.

The experimental setup for the economic task, comparing a risky trial with known probabilities (A) to an ambiguous trial where probabilities are hidden by a black occluder (B).

Psychological and Neuroimaging Assessment

  • Questionnaires: Participants completed the Revised NEO Personality Inventory (NEO-PI-R) to measure the "Big Five" traits and the Need for Closure Scale (NFC), specifically the "discomfort with ambiguity" subscale.
  • Voxel-Based Morphometry (VBM): The team used structural MRI scans to measure the volume of gray matter (GM) in specific brain regions, seeking physical correlates for these personality traits.

Key Findings

Personality and Construct Mismatch

The study found a significant personality mismatch between the two constructs. Economic ambiguity aversion was negatively correlated with Agreeableness ($r = -0.56, p < 0.01$), suggesting that agreeable people might be more optimistic about hidden odds. In contrast, psychological ambiguity intolerance was linked to Neuroticism ($r = 0.44, p = 0.03$) and low Extraversion.

Crucially, there was no significant correlation between a person’s economic ambiguity aversion and their psychological discomfort with ambiguity ($r = -0.13$). Being a cautious gambler does not necessarily mean an individual finds life's general uncertainties distressing.

Structural Brain Footprints

Neuroimaging revealed that individuals with high economic ambiguity aversion had lower gray matter volume in the right lateral prefrontal cortex (specifically the right middle frontal gyrus) and the parietal cortex (right postcentral gyrus). These areas are associated with higher cognition and resolving uncertainty. Conversely, psychological ambiguity intolerance showed no significant correlation with gray matter volume in any brain region.

Discussion and Conclusion

The authors argue that economic ambiguity focuses on missing information regarding probability, whereas psychological ambiguity often involves "polysemy"—situations with multiple possible meanings. These represent cognitively different challenges.

While the study is limited by a small sample size and a focus solely on monetary gains (rather than losses), the results strongly suggest that ambiguity aversion and ambiguity intolerance are distinct constructs. Researchers and clinicians should exercise caution when applying economic decision theory models to clinical neuropsychiatric conditions, as the underlying neural and psychological mechanisms appear to differ.

Summary updated

Abstract

In recent years, there has been growing interest in understanding a person's reaction to ambiguous situations, and two similar constructs related to ambiguity, "ambiguity aversion" and "ambiguity intolerance," are defined in different disciplines. In the field of economic decision-making research, "ambiguity aversion" represents a preference for known risks relative to unknown risks. On the other hand, in clinical psychology, "ambiguity intolerance" describes the tendency to perceive ambiguous situations as undesirable. However, it remains unclear whether these two notions derived from different disciplines are identical or not. To clarify this issue, we combined an economic task, psychological questionnaires, and voxel-based morphometry (VBM) of structural brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in a sample of healthy volunteers. The individual ambiguity aversion tendency parameter, as measured by our economic task, was negatively correlated with agreeableness scores on the self-reported version of the Revised NEO Personality Inventory. However, it was not correlated with scores of discomfort with ambiguity, one of the subscales of the Need for Closure Scale. Furthermore, the ambiguity aversion tendency parameter was negatively correlated with gray matter (GM) volume of areas in the lateral prefrontal cortex and parietal cortex, whereas ambiguity intolerance was not correlated with GM volume in any region. Our results suggest that ambiguity aversion, described in decision theory, may not necessarily be identical to ambiguity intolerance, referred to in clinical psychology. Cautious applications of decision theory to clinical neuropsychiatry are recommended.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tanaka2015are,
  author = {Yusuke Tanaka and Junya Fujino and Takashi Ideno and Shigetaka Okubo and Kazuhisa Takemura and Jun Miyata and Ryosaku Kawada and Shinsuke Fujimoto and Manabu Kubota and Akihiko Sasamoto and Kimito Hirose and Hideaki Takeuchi and Hidenao Fukuyama and Toshiya Murai and Hidehiko Takahashi},
  title = {{Are ambiguity aversion and ambiguity intolerance identical? A neuroeconomics investigation}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2014.01550},
}
Figure