TL;DR
This study uses cold-water coral records to reconstruct ocean interior temperatures during the last deglaciation, revealing coeval warming in the tropical Pacific and Atlantic. This warming, particularly its depth and magnitude, suggests that a slowdown of the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC) played a significant role in heating the ocean's interior, with some contribution from southern-sourced waters.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The last deglaciation (roughly 18,000 to 10,000 years ago) was a period of significant global climate change, marked by warming and shifts in ocean circulation. While high-latitude temperature changes are well-documented, the timing and drivers of warming in the ocean's interior at lower latitudes have remained uncertain. This uncertainty hinders our understanding of how heat is redistributed globally and how ocean circulation influences climate. Specifically, it's unclear whether low-latitude ocean warming was primarily driven by heat accumulating from surface waters during periods of reduced overturning circulation (like AMOC slowdown) or by the advection of heat from warming southern ocean regions.
Methods
The researchers utilized cold-water scleractinian corals as paleoceanographic archives. These corals precipitate their skeletons from seawater, incorporating elements like Lithium (Li) and Magnesium (Mg) into their aragonite structure. The Li/Mg ratio in coral skeletons is a well-established proxy for seawater temperature, with minimal influence from species or calcification processes.
Key methodological aspects include:
- Precise U-series dating: This allowed for accurate age control of the coral samples, crucial for correlating temperature records with other climate archives.
- Li/Mg proxy: This is a standard technique for reconstructing past temperatures, but its application to a broad range of intermediate water depths across different ocean basins is a significant contribution.
- Radiocarbon measurements: Previously conducted on the same corals, these provided complementary information on water mass circulation and ventilation.
- Hovmöller diagrams: These were used to visualize temperature changes across depth and time, offering insights into the vertical structure of ocean warming.
Datasets
The study presents new paleoceanographic data derived from:
- Cold-water coral samples: Collected from the East Equatorial Pacific (EEP), Equatorial Atlantic, and Southern Ocean (Drake Passage). These samples provide new, precisely dated temperature reconstructions for intermediate water masses.
- Comparison with existing records: The new coral data are compared with established records, including:
- Greenland and Antarctic ice core stable isotope records (for high-latitude temperature changes).
- Antarctic ice core atmospheric CO2 records.
- Previous intermediate water temperature records from the East Equatorial Pacific and Equatorial Atlantic (often from benthic foraminifera).
- Previous intermediate water temperature records from the Southern Ocean (e.g., Burdwood Bank).
Key Insights and Ideas
- Synchronous Tropical Warming: The most striking finding is the coeval warming observed in both the East Equatorial Pacific and Equatorial Atlantic during Heinrich Stadial 1 (HS1). This suggests a widespread tropical ocean response to deglacial climate shifts.
- Depth and Magnitude of Warming: The significant magnitude (+6 °C) and deep penetration (down to ~1700 m) of warming in the Equatorial Atlantic are particularly noteworthy. This suggests that heat was accumulating in the ocean interior, rather than just being a surface phenomenon.
- AMOC Slowdown as a Primary Driver: The observed warming pattern, especially its depth and magnitude in the Atlantic, strongly supports the hypothesis that a slowdown of the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC) played a dominant role. During AMOC slowdown, the usual cooling influence of North Atlantic Deep Water (NADW) is reduced, allowing heat to accumulate in the ocean interior.
- Southern Ocean Contribution is Secondary (for tropical warming): While warming was observed in the Southern Ocean, it was more modest (+3 °C) and occurred later during HS1 compared to the tropical sites. This suggests that while southern-sourced intermediate waters may have contributed some heat ("ocean tunnelling"), their role in driving the intense tropical warming was likely secondary to AMOC-related heat accumulation.
- Bipolar Seesaw Connection: The coeval warming in the tropics and Antarctica aligns with the "bipolar seesaw" concept, where warming in one hemisphere is associated with cooling in the other, mediated by ocean circulation.
Key Results
- Equatorial Atlantic and EEP Warming: Both regions experienced a significant warming of approximately +6 °C during Heinrich Stadial 1 (HS1, ~17-14.5 ka).
- Southern Ocean Warming: The Southern Ocean showed more modest warming of around +3 °C, primarily occurring in the latter part of HS1.
- Depth of Warming: In the Equatorial Atlantic, warming extended to depths of ~1700 m, deeper than typically associated with Antarctic Intermediate Water (AAIW).
- Timing: Warming in the tropical EEP and Atlantic commenced around 17 ka, closely matching the onset of HS1 and Antarctic warming. Southern Ocean warming was slightly delayed.
- Hovmöller Diagrams: These visualizations confirmed intense deepening of upper ocean warmth in the Equatorial Atlantic during late HS1 and late Younger Dryas (YD).
Limitations and Future Work
- Temporal Coverage: While the study provides new high-resolution data, temporal coverage for some sites, particularly after HS1, is more limited.
- Reconciling Discrepancies: The paper acknowledges existing discrepancies in deglacial intermediate water records from the Atlantic and Pacific, highlighting the need for more precise and widespread data.
- Model-Data Comparison: While the study's findings align with some climate models suggesting AMOC slowdown as a key driver, further model-data comparisons are needed to fully disentangle the contributions of different warming mechanisms.
- Future Work: The authors suggest that more precise and widespread intermediate water records are needed to fully understand the timing, patterns, and likely causes of deglacial sub-surface warming. They also point to the importance of understanding the ocean's role in communicating high-latitude climate anomalies and redistributing global heat, especially in the context of current anthropogenic warming.
Summary updated