TL;DR
This paper investigates the aqueous-phase hydrogenation of phenol and benzaldehyde over platinum group metals (Pd, Pt, Rh) using both thermal (TCH) and electrocatalytic (ECH) methods. The authors demonstrate that a unified Langmuir-Hinshelwood mechanism can explain the kinetic behavior of these reactions across different metals and conditions, revealing key differences in how Pd interacts with phenol versus benzaldehyde, particularly regarding hydride formation.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
While gas-phase catalytic hydrogenation is well-understood, the mechanisms governing aqueous-phase hydrogenation, especially electrocatalytic hydrogenation (ECH), remain less clear. This is a critical gap because aqueous-phase reactions are crucial for sustainable chemistry, particularly in converting biomass-derived molecules into fuels and chemicals. Specifically, understanding the role of the catalyst's electronic state and hydrogen coverage in these liquid-phase reactions is essential for optimizing efficiency and selectivity. The authors aim to elucidate these mechanisms for phenol and benzaldehyde on common platinum group metal catalysts.
Methods
The study employs a combination of experimental techniques:
- Thermal Catalytic Hydrogenation (TCH): Phenol hydrogenation was studied on Pd/C and Pt/C catalysts under varying phenol concentrations and hydrogen pressure.
- Electrocatalytic Hydrogenation (ECH): Benzaldehyde hydrogenation was studied on Pd/C, Pt/C, and Rh/C catalysts under varying applied potentials and organic concentrations.
- Kinetic Modeling: A Langmuir-Hinshelwood mechanism with competitive adsorption was used to fit the experimental rate data. This model considers the adsorption of both the organic molecule and hydrogen on the catalyst surface.
- In Situ X-ray Absorption Spectroscopy (XAS): X-ray Absorption Near Edge Spectroscopy (XANES) and Extended X-ray Absorption Fine Structure (EXAFS) were used to probe the electronic state and structural changes of Pd/C catalysts under reaction conditions, specifically to identify the formation of palladium hydride (PdHx) phases.
- Cyclic Voltammetry (CV): Used to investigate the electrochemical behavior of Pd foil in the presence of phenol and benzaldehyde, providing insights into hydride formation and organic adsorption.
- Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy (EIS): Employed to study the effect of organic adsorption on capacitance and charge transfer resistance.
Datasets
Not explicitly discussed as "datasets" in the context of machine learning. The study relies on experimental data generated from the described catalytic and electrochemical experiments. Literature data for TCH and ECH rates and reaction orders were also used for comparison.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Unified Mechanism: A single Langmuir-Hinshelwood mechanism, involving the addition of a surface hydrogen adatom to a molecularly adsorbed organic, successfully describes the kinetics of both TCH and ECH for phenol and benzaldehyde on Pd, Pt, and Rh. This highlights a common fundamental pathway across these systems.
- Pd-Phenol vs. Pd-Benzaldehyde Distinction: A significant difference was observed in how Pd interacts with phenol versus benzaldehyde.
- Phenol Hydrogenation: Pd readily forms a $\beta$-PdHx phase, indicating high hydrogen coverage. This leads to significantly lower activity for phenol hydrogenation compared to Pt and Rh.
- Benzaldehyde Hydrogenation: Pd remains in a metallic or $\alpha$-PdHx state, with low hydrogen coverage. This is attributed to strong benzaldehyde adsorption, which blocks hydrogen adsorption sites and/or rapidly consumes surface hydrogen. This results in high selectivity for benzaldehyde hydrogenation and higher activity on Pd compared to Pt and Rh.
- Role of Hydrogen Coverage: The study strongly links surface hydrogen coverage to reaction rates and selectivity. Higher hydrogen coverage (as seen with phenol on Pd) can lead to $\beta$-PdHx formation and lower organic hydrogenation rates. Conversely, low hydrogen coverage (as seen with benzaldehyde on Pd) leads to high selectivity for organic hydrogenation.
- Electrochemical Potential and Hydrogen Coverage: Increasing cathodic potential in ECH leads to increased surface hydrogen coverage, which in turn increases the hydrogenation rate. This explains the lower apparent activation energies observed in ECH compared to TCH.
- Site Specificity: For Pt/C, adsorption equilibrium constants derived from kinetic modeling align with independently measured values for Pt(111) surfaces, suggesting that these facets are the most active sites for hydrogenation.
Key Results
- Activity Trends: Phenol hydrogenation is significantly slower on Pd compared to Pt and Rh, and also slower than benzaldehyde hydrogenation on all metals. Benzaldehyde hydrogenation is faster on Pd than on Pt and Rh.
- Reaction Orders: Benzaldehyde ECH shows a zero-order dependence on benzaldehyde concentration for Pd, but first-order for Pt and Rh. Phenol TCH shows a transition from positive to negative order with increasing concentration on Pd and Pt.
- Faradaic Efficiency: Pd exhibits very high Faradaic efficiency (>99%) for benzaldehyde ECH, indicating minimal hydrogen evolution. In contrast, phenol ECH on Pd has very low Faradaic efficiency (<1%). Pt and Rh show intermediate efficiencies (40-70%) for both organics.
- Activation Energies: ECH generally has lower apparent activation energies than TCH, particularly for benzaldehyde (a 7 kJ/mol difference).
- XAS Findings: XANES and EXAFS confirmed the formation of $\beta$-PdHx during phenol hydrogenation on Pd but not during benzaldehyde hydrogenation, even at potentials where $\beta$-PdHx would typically form. This directly supports the hypothesis of strong benzaldehyde adsorption inhibiting hydride formation.
Limitations and Future Work
- Benzaldehyde ECH Mechanism on Pd: While the Langmuir-Hinshelwood model fits the kinetic data for benzaldehyde ECH on Pd, the authors suggest that future work is still needed to definitively prove this mechanism, especially given the absence of a negative reaction order at the tested concentrations.
- Complex Kinetic Model: The simple kinetic model assumes that organic coverage is solely determined by adsorption/desorption equilibria. A more complex model that accounts for how reaction rates affect organic coverage might be necessary for a more complete understanding.
- Site Heterogeneity: The current model assumes homogeneous surface sites. While Pt/C data suggests (111) facets are dominant, further investigation into the role of other sites (steps, defects) could be beneficial.
- Electrochemical Potential Effects: While the model incorporates the effect of applied potential on hydrogen chemical potential, additional effects related to how potential influences organic adsorption strength are not explicitly included.
Summary updated