Approximate Strang-Fix: sampling infinite streams of Diracs with any kernel

Pier Luigi Dragotti, Jon Oñativia, Antonio Urigüen, Thierry BluProceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a flexible framework for sampling and reconstructing "signals with finite rate of innovation" (FRI) using arbitrary sampling kernels, not just specialized ones. They achieve this by approximating exponential reproduction and present a novel, robust algorithm for reconstructing infinite streams of Dirac impulses even in noisy conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional signal sampling theory often relies on signals being "bandlimited," meaning they are confined to a specific range of frequencies. However, many real-world signals, like those with sharp transitions or discrete events, don't fit this mold. The concept of "signals with finite rate of innovation" (FRI) was developed to handle these signals, which are characterized by a finite number of "innovations" (like Dirac impulses or abrupt changes) per unit of time.

A key challenge in FRI signal reconstruction is the design of the "sampling kernel" – the filter used in the acquisition device. Ideally, these kernels should be able to "reproduce exponentials," a property that simplifies the reconstruction process. However, this requirement is very strict and limits the choice of usable kernels. This paper addresses the problem of sampling FRI signals with any kernel, not just those that perfectly reproduce exponentials, and doing so in a way that is robust to noise.

Methods

The paper presents two main contributions:

  1. Approximate Strang-Fix Framework: Instead of requiring perfect exponential reproduction by the sampling kernel, the authors propose an "approximate" approach. They allow for a controlled error in the reproduction formula, enabling the use of a wider range of kernels. This is achieved by finding coefficients that provide the "best approximation" to exponential reproduction. This "approximate Strang-Fix" approach makes the sampling process more universal and robust to noise.
  2. Sequential Local FRI Sampling Algorithm: For reconstructing infinite streams of Dirac impulses (a common type of FRI signal), the authors introduce a novel sequential algorithm. This algorithm processes sets of samples in overlapping "windows." Within each window, it retrieves potential Dirac locations and amplitudes. By comparing results across overlapping windows, the algorithm can identify consistent Diracs and filter out noise-induced artifacts. This method is designed to be fast and resilient to high noise levels.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical development and simulation results, not on training or evaluating on specific real-world datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Flexibility is Key: The core idea is that perfect exponential reproduction by the sampling kernel is overly restrictive. Allowing for a small, controlled approximation error opens up a much broader class of practical sampling kernels.
  • Approximation as Robustness: By embracing approximation, the method becomes inherently more robust to noise. The "model mismatch" introduced by the approximation can be treated similarly to noise, allowing established techniques like matrix pencil to be used for reconstruction.
  • Local Processing for Global Signals: Reconstructing an infinite stream of Diracs is tackled by breaking it down into local, overlapping windows. This sequential, local approach simplifies the problem and allows for efficient, real-time processing.
  • Noise Resilience: The proposed algorithm demonstrates remarkable resilience to noise, successfully reconstructing signals with a significant amount of interference.

Key Results

  • The approximate Strang-Fix framework allows for the reconstruction of FRI signals using arbitrary kernels, overcoming the limitations of exact exponential reproduction.
  • The sequential local FRI sampling algorithm can reconstruct infinite streams of Diracs with high accuracy, even at signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs) as low as 5dB.
  • The paper shows the ability to reconstruct up to 1000 Diracs with high accuracy under these challenging noisy conditions.
  • The approximate framework allows for reconstructing more Diracs than the exact framework when the kernel order is limited (e.g., reconstructing 4 Diracs with a P=5 B-spline kernel using the approximate method, whereas the exact method would only allow for 3).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Approximation Error: While the paper addresses the approximation error, its precise impact and how to optimally bound it for different kernels and signal types could be further explored.
  • Kernel Choice: The paper suggests that certain kernels (like e-MOMS) are more noise-resilient. Further investigation into the optimal choice of kernels for the approximate framework, considering their specific properties and the signal characteristics, would be beneficial.
  • Real-time Performance: While the algorithm is presented as "fast and very resilient to noise," detailed performance metrics and analysis for real-time applications on specific hardware could be a future direction.
  • General FRI Signals: The paper focuses heavily on Dirac streams. Extending the approximate framework and local reconstruction to other classes of FRI signals (e.g., piecewise sinusoidal) would be a natural next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the last few years, several new methods have been developed for the sampling and the exact reconstruction of specific classes of non-bandlimited signals known as signals with finite rate of innovation (FRI). This is achieved by using adequate sampling kernels and reconstruction schemes. An important class of such kernels is the one made of functions able to reproduce exponentials. In this paper we review a new strategy for sampling these signals which is universal in that it works with any kernel. We do so by noting that meeting the exact exponential reproduction condition is too stringent a constraint, we thus allow for a controlled error in the reproduction formula in order to use the exponential reproduction idea with any kernel and develop a reconstruction method which is more robust to noise. We also present a novel method that is able to reconstruct infinite streams of Diracs, even in high noise scenarios. We sequentially process the discrete samples and output locations and amplitudes of the Diracs in real-time. In this context we also show that we can achieve a high reconstruction accuracy of 1000 Diracs for SNRs as low as 5dB.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dragotti2013approximate,
  author = {Pier Luigi Dragotti and Jon Oñativia and Antonio Urigüen and Thierry Blu},
  title = {{Approximate Strang-Fix: sampling infinite streams of Diracs with any kernel}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1117/12.2023249},
}
Figure