Approximate Envy-Freeness in Graphical Cake Cutting

Sheung Man Yuen, Warut SuksompongIJCAI 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of fairly dividing complex resources, represented as graphs, among multiple agents. It introduces algorithms that guarantee allocations where agents experience minimal envy, even when the resource structure prevents perfectly fair divisions. This work extends classic cake-cutting theory to more realistic network-like resource distributions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The classic "cake-cutting" problem deals with dividing a divisible resource (like land or time) among agents who might value different parts differently. Traditionally, the resource is modeled as a simple interval, and algorithms exist to ensure proportional and even envy-free divisions, where no agent prefers another's share. However, many real-world resources are more complex, like road networks, power grids, or communication networks, which are better represented by graphs.

The challenge with graphical cake cutting is that simple, connected envy-free allocations are not guaranteed to exist. Previous work showed that approximate proportionality (each agent gets at least a fraction of their value) is achievable, but this often comes at the cost of significant envy between agents. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing algorithms that provide strong guarantees on low envy in graphical cake cutting, both for general graphs and specific structures like star graphs, and for agents with identical or differing valuations.

Methods

The authors propose several algorithms based on iterative division and balancing of shares.

  • ITERATIVEDIVIDE: For general graphs and non-identical valuations, this algorithm iteratively divides the remaining graph. It aims to give each agent a share that is at least 1/2 of their value relative to what others might value it, resulting in a 1/2-additive-envy-free allocation.
  • Star Graph Algorithm: For star graphs, a more complex, multi-phase algorithm is presented. It involves preparing small "stubs," incrementally increasing agents' shares through trades, and finally appending remaining portions. This algorithm achieves a (3 + ε)-multiplicative-envy-free allocation.
  • Identical Valuations Algorithms:
    • A modified ITERATIVEDIVIDE is used to achieve a 4-EF allocation.
  • A more sophisticated algorithm, RECURSIVEBALANCE, is introduced. It uses a "bag-filling" approach and iteratively balances shares by identifying minimum-maximum paths to achieve a (2 + ε)-multiplicative-envy-free allocation.
  • For star graphs with identical valuations, a simpler 2-EF allocation algorithm is provided.
  • Relaxing Connectivity: The paper also explores scenarios where agents can receive multiple connected pieces, relating graphical cake cutting to interval cake cutting via a "path similarity number."

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The problem is theoretical and relies on abstract graph structures and agent valuation functions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Envy is the Bottleneck: While proportionality can be achieved in graphical cake cutting, envy-freeness is the real challenge. The paper highlights that even simple structures like star graphs can lead to high envy if not handled carefully.
  • Trade-offs Between Additive and Multiplicative Envy: The paper distinguishes between additive envy (envy is a fixed amount) and multiplicative envy (envy is a factor of the value). Achieving multiplicative envy-freeness is generally harder but provides stronger guarantees for larger values.
  • Structure Matters: Star graphs, as a generalization of interval cakes, offer a good testbed for developing and adapting algorithms. The paper shows that specific graph structures allow for better envy guarantees.
  • Iterative Refinement is Key: Many of the algorithms rely on repeatedly dividing and reallocating portions of the resource to balance agent valuations and reduce envy.
  • Connectivity is a Constraint: The requirement for connected pieces significantly complicates graphical cake cutting compared to non-connected allocations. Relaxing this constraint can improve fairness guarantees.

Key Results

  • General Graphs (Non-identical Valuations): A 1/2-additive-envy-free allocation is guaranteed.
  • Star Graphs (Non-identical Valuations): A (3 + ε)-multiplicative-envy-free allocation is achievable.
  • General Graphs (Identical Valuations): A (2 + ε)-multiplicative-envy-free allocation is achievable.
  • Star Graphs (Identical Valuations): A 2-multiplicative-envy-free allocation is achievable.
  • All results are accompanied by efficient polynomial-time algorithms.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Connectedness for General Graphs: The paper notes that achieving a constant multiplicative envy-free allocation for general graphs with non-identical valuations remains an open question. The techniques used for star graphs don't directly extend.
  • Tightness of Bounds: While the paper provides bounds and algorithms, it suggests that some of these bounds might be tight, particularly for the proportionality guarantees.
  • Non-connected Allocations: The paper explores relaxing the connectivity constraint and suggests further work on tightening bounds for the number of connected pieces an agent might receive.
  • Alternative Approaches: The authors propose investigating different approaches beyond converting graphs to paths for non-connected allocations to potentially achieve improved envy bounds.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{yuen2023approximate,
  author = {Sheung Man Yuen and Warut Suksompong},
  title = {{Approximate Envy-Freeness in Graphical Cake Cutting}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.24963/ijcai.2023/326},
}
Figure