Approximate Analytical Gradients and Nonadiabatic Couplings for the State-Average Density Matrix Renormalization Group Self-Consistent-Field Method

Leon Freitag, Yingjin Ma, Alberto Baiardi, Stefan Knecht, Markus ReiherJournal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2019 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

In computational photochemistry, the ability to model electronic transitions and non-radiative decay processes is paramount. This requires the calculation of energy gradients and nonadiabatic couplings (NACs), which describe how molecular energy and electronic states change with nuclear coordinates. The State-Average Complete Active Space Self-Consistent Field (SA-CASSCF) method has long been the gold standard for these calculations. However, SA-CASSCF is limited by an exponential scaling bottleneck, typically restricting its application to active spaces of approximately 18 orbitals.

To overcome this "18-orbital wall," researchers have turned to the Density Matrix Renormalization Group (DMRG) method. By representing the wavefunction as a Matrix Product State (MPS), DMRG allows for the treatment of much larger active spaces. While energy calculations for SA-DMRG-SCF are well-established, the derivation and implementation of efficient analytical gradients and NACs have remained a significant challenge. This paper presents an approximate scheme that bridges this gap, enabling photochemical simulations on previously inaccessible molecular systems.

Methodology: The Lagrangian Formalism

The authors adopt a Lagrangian formalism similar to that used in standard SA-CASSCF. The goal is to determine the response of the wavefunction parameters to nuclear displacements. This involves solving the coupled-perturbed (CP) equations to find Lagrange multipliers that account for the variation of the molecular orbitals and the Configuration Interaction (CI)-like coefficients—represented here by the MPS tensors.

Single-Site Parametrization

The primary innovation of this work is the introduction of a single-site parametrization for the MPS. In traditional DMRG, optimizing the wavefunction requires a "sweep" procedure, where tensors are updated sequentially across the orbital chain. Applying this sweep logic to the CP equations would be computationally prohibitive for every gradient step.

Instead, the authors utilize a mixed-canonical form of the MPS. By selecting a specific "linear response site" within the chain, they can express the variation of the entire MPS in terms of the variation of a single-site tensor. This approach maps the complex MPS response onto a simpler problem, effectively avoiding the need for iterative sweeps during the solution of the CP-DMRG-SCF equations. This implementation was integrated into the QCMaquis DMRG program and interfaced with the OpenMOLCAS suite.

Validation and Results

The method was validated using two primary molecular benchmarks: cyclobutadiene and 1,2-dioxetanone.

1,2-Dioxetanone and Conical Intersections

1,2-dioxetanone is a classic benchmark for chemiluminescence. The study focused on optimizing the conical intersection (CI) between the ground state and the first excited state. Conical intersections are "funnels" where electronic states become degenerate, allowing for rapid non-radiative transitions.

The SA-DMRG-SCF method successfully located the $^1\sigma\sigma^*$-TS conical intersection, reproducing SA-CASSCF results with high precision. Errors in energy and gradient norms were reduced to as low as $10^{-6}$ Hartree/bohr, demonstrating that the single-site approximation does not sacrifice the accuracy required for identifying critical points on potential energy surfaces.

The Importance of Site Selection

Tests on cyclobutadiene (12 electrons in 12 orbitals) revealed that the accuracy of the gradient is sensitive to the position of the linear response site. The authors found that choosing a site in the middle of the MPS chain yields the most accurate results. This is attributed to the higher variational flexibility of central sites compared to those at the boundaries of the chain.

Discussion: Understanding the BVOE

The authors identify a specific source of error termed the Basis-Variation Omission Error (BVOE). Because the single-site approach does not capture the full variational space of the MPS (which a full sweep would), a small discrepancy is introduced. However, the study demonstrates that the BVOE is manageable for practical chemical applications. Interestingly, for calculations with smaller bond dimensions ($m$), the error in the gradient can sometimes be smaller than the error in the total energy, suggesting a robust performance even when the wavefunction is not perfectly converged.

Conclusion

The development of approximate analytical gradients and NACs for SA-DMRG-SCF represents a significant step forward for large-scale photochemical simulations. By utilizing a single-site parametrization and avoiding expensive sweep procedures, the authors have provided a computationally efficient path to studying complex molecular dynamics in systems that exceed the 18-orbital limit of traditional CASSCF. Future developments will likely focus on applying the method to "surface hopping" molecular dynamics to simulate real-time electronic processes in large molecular systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present an approximate scheme for analytical gradients and nonadiabatic couplings for calculating state-average density matrix renormalization group self-consistent-field wave function. Our formalism follows closely the state-average complete active space self-consistent-field (SA-CASSCF) <i>ansatz</i>, which employs a Lagrangian, and the corresponding Lagrange multipliers are obtained from a solution of the coupled-perturbed CASSCF (CP-CASSCF) equations. We introduce a definition of the matrix product state (MPS) Lagrange multipliers based on a single-site tensor in a mixed-canonical form of the MPS, such that a sweep procedure is avoided in the solution of the CP-CASSCF equations. We apply our implementation to the optimization of a conical intersection in 1,2-dioxetanone, where we are able to fully reproduce the SA-CASSCF result up to arbitrary accuracy.
BibTeX
@article{freitag2019approximate,
  author = {Leon Freitag and Yingjin Ma and Alberto Baiardi and Stefan Knecht and Markus Reiher},
  title = {{Approximate Analytical Gradients and Nonadiabatic Couplings for the State-Average Density Matrix Renormalization Group Self-Consistent-Field Method}},
  journal = {Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.jctc.9b00969},
}

Loading related content...

Figure