Approach to the Quantitative Diagnosis of Rolling Bearings Based on Optimized VMD and Lempel–Ziv Complexity under Varying Conditions

Haobo Wang, Tongguang Yang, Qingkai Han, Zhong LuoSensors 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces an improved method for diagnosing faults in rolling bearings, particularly in challenging micro-turbine environments. By combining an optimized Variational Modal Decomposition (VMD) with Lempel-Ziv Complexity (LZC), the approach effectively extracts subtle fault signatures from noisy vibration data, offering more accurate and quantitative fault assessment than existing methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Rolling bearings are critical components in systems like micro-turbines, and their failure can have severe consequences. Accurate and timely fault diagnosis is essential for predictive maintenance and operational safety. While Lempel-Ziv Complexity (LZC) has shown promise in quantifying mechanical failures by analyzing signal complexity, it has limitations. LZC's reliance on binary conversion can lead to loss of information, and it's susceptible to noise, making it difficult to reliably detect faults in environments with strong background interference. Furthermore, existing methods often struggle with the complex, nonlinear, and non-stationary nature of vibration signals from systems operating under varying conditions (like speed and load). This paper aims to overcome these limitations by developing a more robust and quantitative fault diagnosis method.

Methods

The core of the proposed method is the Optimized Variational Modal Decomposition (VMD) - Lempel-Ziv Complexity (LZC) approach.

  • Optimized VMD: Traditional VMD requires manual selection of key parameters (number of modes 'k' and penalty factor 'α'). To address this, the authors employ a Genetic Algorithm (GA) to automatically optimize these parameters. This adaptive approach ensures that VMD effectively decomposes the vibration signal into its intrinsic mode functions (IMFs) while minimizing modal mixing and endpoint effects, which are common issues in other decomposition methods like EEMD.
  • Kurtosis-based IMF Selection: After VMD decomposition, the authors use the Kurtosis value to identify the IMFs that contain the most significant fault information. Kurtosis is a statistical measure that indicates the "spikiness" of a signal, and higher Kurtosis values in IMFs are indicative of fault-related vibration components. This step helps to filter out noise and focus on relevant fault signatures.
  • LZC for Quantitative Diagnosis: The selected IMFs are then used to reconstruct a signal, and the Lempel-Ziv Complexity (LZC) is calculated for this reconstructed signal. LZC quantifies the complexity of a time series by measuring the rate at which new patterns emerge. By calculating a weighted sum of LZC values from the selected IMFs, a composite LZC index is obtained, providing a quantitative measure of the bearing's health status.

The paper also compares this method against traditional LZC, EMD-LZC, and EEMD-LZC to demonstrate its superiority.

Datasets

The study utilizes experimental vibration data collected from a turbine rolling bearing-rotor system experimental bench. This bench was designed to simulate the operating conditions of micro-turbines. The data includes vibration signals from:

  • Healthy bearings
  • Bearings with cage faults
  • Bearings with inner race faults (slight and severe)
  • Bearings with outer race faults (slight and severe)

The experiments were conducted under specific conditions: a motor speed of 2400 r/min (40 Hz operating frequency) and a sampling frequency of 4000 Hz. A total of 30 types of sample data were collected, with 8 sets of 100-second data for each of the 4 working conditions (health, cage fault, inner race fault, outer race fault).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • GA for VMD Parameter Optimization is Crucial: Manually setting VMD parameters is suboptimal. Using a Genetic Algorithm to adaptively determine 'k' and 'α' significantly improves the decomposition quality and the subsequent fault diagnosis.
  • Kurtosis as an Effective Fault Feature Selector: Not all IMFs from VMD are equally informative. Kurtosis provides a reliable statistical basis for selecting IMFs that are most sensitive to bearing faults, effectively reducing noise and enhancing the signal-to-noise ratio for fault detection.
  • LZC's Power in Complex, Noisy Environments: While LZC alone can be limited, when applied to VMD-decomposed and Kurtosis-filtered signals, it becomes a powerful tool for quantitative fault diagnosis, even in the presence of strong background noise and complex nonlinear dynamics.
  • Improved Differentiation Across Fault Types and Severities: The optimized VMD-LZC method demonstrates superior ability to distinguish between healthy states and various fault types (cage, inner race, outer race), as well as different fault severities (slight vs. severe), under varying operating conditions.

Key Results

The proposed optimized VMD-LZC method consistently outperformed traditional LZC, EMD-LZC, and EEMD-LZC across various fault scenarios (severe, slight, and under loading conditions).

  • Quantitative Differentiation: The method achieved clear differentiation between healthy and faulty states, with complexity index values showing distinct patterns for each fault type. For instance, under loading conditions, the differences in average LZC values between healthy and fault states were 0.22 (cage), 0.33 (inner race), and 0.42 (outer race), indicating strong discriminative power.
  • Robustness to Noise: The optimized VMD effectively removes noise, allowing LZC to better capture the underlying fault characteristics, leading to more stable and reliable index curves compared to methods susceptible to noise.
  • Accurate Classification: The paper demonstrates the method's ability to accurately assess and classify bearing faults under variable loads and different crack severities, highlighting its practical application value.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost: While the GA optimizes VMD parameters, the optimization process itself can be computationally intensive.
  • Generalizability: The study focuses on micro-turbine rolling bearings. Further validation on other types of bearings or machinery would be beneficial.
  • Real-world Complexity: While the experimental setup simulates varying conditions, real-world industrial environments can present even more complex and unpredictable fault combinations and noise sources.

The authors suggest that this study provides a new direction for quantitative diagnosis and a new research idea for automatic diagnosis by establishing quantitative criteria. The method's broad potential and application value for fault monitoring and diagnosis of electrical equipment are highlighted.

Summary updated

Abstract

The quantitative diagnosis of rolling bearings is essential to automating maintenance decisions. Over recent years, Lempel-Ziv complexity (LZC) has been widely used for the quantitative assessment of mechanical failures as one of the most valuable indicators for detecting dynamic changes in nonlinear signals. However, LZC focuses on the binary conversion of 0-1 code, which can easily lose some effective information about the time series and cannot fully mine the fault characteristics. Additionally, the immunity of LZC to noise cannot be insured, and it is difficult to quantitatively characterize the fault signal under strong background noise. To overcome these limitations, a quantitative bearing fault diagnosis method based on the optimized Variational Modal Decomposition Lempel-Ziv complexity (VMD-LZC) was developed to fully extract the vibration characteristics and to quantitatively characterize the bearing faults under variable operating conditions. First, to compensate for the deficiency that the main parameters of the variational modal decomposition (VMD) have to be selected by human experience, a genetic algorithm (GA) is used to optimize the parameters of the VMD and adaptively determine the optimal parameters [<i>k</i>, <i>α</i>] of the bearing fault signal. Furthermore, the IMF components that contain the maximum fault information are selected for signal reconstruction based on the Kurtosis theory. The Lempel-Ziv index of the reconstructed signal is calculated and then weighted and summed to obtain the Lempel-Ziv composite index. The experimental results show that the proposed method is of high application value for the quantitative assessment and classification of bearing faults in turbine rolling bearings under various operating conditions such as mild and severe crack faults and variable loads.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2023approach,
  author = {Haobo Wang and Tongguang Yang and Qingkai Han and Zhong Luo},
  title = {{Approach to the Quantitative Diagnosis of Rolling Bearings Based on Optimized VMD and Lempel–Ziv Complexity under Varying Conditions}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/s23084044},
}
Figure