TL;DR
This paper introduces a novel approach to multi-criteria group decision-making (MCGDM) by combining the Best-Worst Method (BWM) with the ELECTRE III method. This hybrid approach aims to reduce the number of comparisons needed while leveraging the strengths of both methods to handle complex decision scenarios with intuitionistic multiplicative preference relations.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
In real-world scenarios, group decision-making often involves multiple criteria and multiple decision-makers (DMs). Traditional methods for multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) can be computationally intensive, requiring a large number of pairwise comparisons. This can be burdensome for DMs, especially when dealing with complex preference structures like intuitionistic multiplicative preference relations, which capture both preferred and non-preferred intensities. The paper addresses the challenge of efficiently and effectively ranking alternatives in such complex group decision-making environments, aiming to reduce the cognitive load on DMs and improve the rationality of the outcomes.
Methods
The core of this paper is the integration of two established methods:
- Best-Worst Method (BWM): BWM is utilized to determine the weights of criteria and alternatives. Its key advantage is reducing the number of pairwise comparisons from $n(n-1)/2$ to $2n-3$, making the process more efficient.
- ELECTRE III Method: This method is employed for ranking alternatives based on outranking relations. The paper extends ELECTRE III to work with "intuitionistic multiplicative preference relations" (IMPRs).
The novel aspects include:
- Intuitionistic Multiplicative Preference Relations (IMPRs): The paper defines and utilizes IMPRs, which are an extension of traditional preference relations, to represent decision-makers' preferences more comprehensively by including both preferred and non-preferred intensities.
- Hybrid Approach: The BWM is used to generate initial comparison matrices, which are then processed using the ELECTRE III framework adapted for IMPRs. This allows for a more robust and efficient decision-making process.
- Double-Automatic System: The proposed method includes a mechanism to automatically adjust certain "improper elements" in the decision matrices under specific limitations, reducing the need for DMs to re-evaluate alternatives.
- Distance Formula: A new distance formula is introduced to measure the distance between two IMPNs, which is also applicable to interval-valued fuzzy preference relations.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The paper presents a numerical example to demonstrate the proposed method.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Efficiency through BWM: The integration of BWM significantly reduces the number of comparisons required from DMs, making the decision-making process more manageable and less time-consuming.
- Richer Preference Representation: Using intuitionistic multiplicative preference relations allows for a more nuanced capture of preferences, including both positive and negative aspects, which can lead to more realistic and accurate rankings.
- Automated Adjustment: The "double-automatic system" offers a practical advantage by allowing for self-correction of decision matrices within defined limits, enhancing the robustness of the method without constant DM intervention.
- Generalizability: The developed distance formula for IMPNs has potential applications beyond the immediate scope of this paper, particularly for interval-valued fuzzy preference relations.
Key Results
The paper demonstrates the proposed method through a numerical example involving the selection of a cultural facility site. The results show that the proposed hybrid method can effectively rank alternatives. While the paper notes that ranking results may differ slightly from other methods (like those by Xia et al. and Z.S. Xu), it highlights that the best alternative identified is consistent across methods, suggesting the proposed approach is reasonable. The satisfaction index degrees calculated indicate the method's ability to achieve acceptable results, with adjustments made when initial satisfaction levels are below a threshold.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest future research directions:
- Consistency Issue: While BWM matrices are individually consistent, the paper notes a potential consistency issue between the "best-to-others" and "others-to-worst" comparisons, which was not addressed in this study.
- Complexity of IMPRs: The current method is based on intuitionistic preference relations. For more complex scenarios, further research is needed to extend the methodology to handle more intricate preference structures, such as interval-valued intuitionistic preference relations.
- Further Extension: The authors suggest extending the method to solve more complex MCGDM problems and exploring the consistency degree of comparisons between best-to-others and others-to-worst.
Summary updated