Application of the time-dependent surface flux method to the time-dependent multiconfiguration self-consistent-field method

Yuki Orimo, Takeshi Sato, Kenichi L. IshikawaPhysical Review. A/Physical Review, A 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a computationally efficient method, the time-dependent surface flux (tSURFF) method, for calculating photoelectron energy spectra from complex multielectron systems interacting with intense laser fields. By combining tSURFF with advanced quantum chemistry techniques like TD-MCSCF, researchers can now perform accurate ab initio simulations of these phenomena with significantly reduced computational cost.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how electrons behave in atoms and molecules when exposed to intense laser fields is crucial for fields like attosecond science and high-field physics. The theoretical framework for this, the time-dependent Schrödinger equation (TDSE), becomes computationally intractable for systems with multiple electrons. Existing methods for calculating photoelectron energy spectra, which are key experimental probes of these dynamics, often require retaining the entire wave function, leading to prohibitive computational demands. This paper addresses the need for a more efficient and accurate method to extract these crucial spectral information from complex multielectron systems.

Methods

The core contribution is the extension of the time-dependent surface flux (tSURFF) method, originally developed for single-electron systems, to the time-dependent multiconfiguration self-consistent-field (TD-MCSCF) framework. This involves:

  • Formulating equations of motion for spectral amplitudes: Instead of tracking the entire complex wave function, the method focuses on the amplitudes of individual orbitals, significantly reducing the computational burden.
  • Combining with TD-MCSCF variants: The tSURFF method is integrated with TD-CASSCF (complete-active-space self-consistent-field) and TD-ORMAS (occupation-restricted multiple-active-space) methods. These TD-MCSCF approaches offer flexible descriptions of multielectron wave functions by classifying orbitals and restricting excitations, making them suitable for systems with many electrons.
  • Utilizing an efficient absorbing boundary: The infinite-range exterior complex scaling (irECS) technique is employed as an absorbing boundary. This is crucial for tSURFF as it allows for the simulation of outgoing electrons without needing an infinitely large computational grid, further reducing costs.
  • Photoelectron Reduced Density Matrix (PRDM): For multielectron systems, the concept of a PRDM is introduced to extract the photoelectron spectra.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical development and numerical simulations of atomic systems (Neon and Argon) under specific laser pulse conditions, rather than using pre-existing experimental datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • tSURFF's efficiency for multielectron systems: The paper demonstrates that tSURFF, when combined with TD-MCSCF, can accurately capture photoelectron spectra from complex multielectron systems, a feat that was previously computationally prohibitive.
  • The role of electronic correlation: For Argon, the study highlights that electronic correlation plays a significant role in detailed descriptions of above-threshold ionization (ATI) spectra, particularly at higher energies. TDHF (time-dependent Hartree-Fock) methods, which neglect correlation, show broadened peaks and underestimate yields in certain directions compared to more sophisticated TD-MCSCF approaches.
  • Accuracy of the approximation: The assumption that interelectronic Coulomb interactions are negligible for photoelectrons in the region beyond a certain radius ($R_s$) is validated through numerical comparisons, showing excellent agreement between tSURFF and direct projection methods.
  • Flexibility of TD-MCSCF variants: The study showcases how different TD-MCSCF configurations (e.g., varying the number of active orbitals and excitation restrictions) can be used to achieve converged results, with TD-CASSCF and TD-ORMAS offering a balance between accuracy and computational cost.

Key Results

  • Accurate PES and ARPES: The implemented tSURFF-TD-MCSCF method successfully reproduces photoelectron energy spectra (PES) and angle-resolved photoelectron energy spectra (ARPES) for Neon and Argon atoms under intense laser fields.
  • Excellent agreement with direct projection: For Neon, the tSURFF results show excellent agreement with direct projection methods, validating the approach.
  • Computational cost reduction: The paper emphasizes that the tSURFF method significantly reduces the computational cost compared to traditional projection methods, making ab initio simulations of complex phenomena feasible.
  • Convergence studies: For Argon, convergence studies demonstrate that using a sufficient number of active orbitals and appropriate excitation restrictions (like SDT) leads to results that are nearly identical to full configuration interaction (full-CI) calculations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Neglect of nuclear dynamics: The current implementation assumes fixed nuclei. The authors suggest extending the method to include nuclear dynamics for more comprehensive simulations.
  • Applicability to other methods: The authors propose that the tSURFF method can be straightforwardly extended to other ab initio multielectron methods that utilize time-dependent orbitals, such as time-dependent optimized coupled-cluster methods and TD-MCSCF methods incorporating nuclear dynamics. This opens avenues for studying even more complex systems and phenomena.
  • Approximation of Coulomb interaction: While validated numerically, the assumption of negligible interelectronic Coulomb interaction beyond $R_s$ might have limitations for specific systems or laser parameters, which could be a point for further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present a numerical implementation of the time-dependent surface flux (tSURFF) method [L. Tao and A. Scrinzi, New J. Phys. 14, 013021 (2012).], an efficient computational scheme to extract photoelectron energy spectra, to the time-dependent multiconfiguration self-consistent-field (TD-MCSCF) method. Extending the original tSURFF method developed for single-particle systems, we formulate the equations of motion for the spectral amplitude of orbital functions constituting the TD-MCSCF wave function, from which the angle-resolved photoelectron energy spectrum, and more generally, photoelectron reduced density matrices (RDMs) are readily obtained. The tSURFF method applied to the TD-MCSCF wave function, in combination with an efficient absorbing boundary offered by the infinite-range exterior complex scaling, enables accurate ab initio computations of photoelectron energy spectra from multielectron systems subject to an intense and ultrashort laser pulse with a computational cost significantly reduced compared to that required in projecting the total wave function onto scattering states. We apply the present implementation to the photoionization of Ne exposed to an attosecond extreme-ultraviolet (XUV) pulse and above-threshold ionization of Ar irradiated by an intense mid-infrared laser field, demonstrating both accuracy and efficiency of the present method.
BibTeX
@article{orimo2019application,
  author = {Yuki Orimo and Takeshi Sato and Kenichi L. Ishikawa},
  title = {{Application of the time-dependent surface flux method to the time-dependent multiconfiguration self-consistent-field method}},
  journal = {Physical Review. A/Physical Review, A},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1103/physreva.100.013419},
}
Figure