Application of the drilling resistance method for annual ring characteristics: evaluation of Taiwania (Taiwania cryptomerioides) trees grown with different thinning and pruning treatments

S.-y. Wang, C.-m. Chiu, Chih‐Jen LinJournal of Wood Science 2003 · DOI

Introduction

In commercial forestry, the management of Taiwania cryptomerioides—a high-value timber species in Taiwan—requires a delicate balance between growth volume and wood quality. Silvicultural practices such as thinning and pruning are standard for optimizing yield, but their specific impacts on wood density and internal ring structure are often difficult to assess without destructive sampling or costly laboratory analysis. This study evaluates the efficacy of the RESISTOGRAPH, a semi-nondestructive drilling resistance tool, as a field-ready alternative for monitoring these wood properties.

Methodology

The research was conducted in the Liukuei Experimental Forest, utilizing a 3x3 factorial design across 27 plots. The experiment tested three levels of thinning (Heavy, Medium, and None) and three levels of pruning (Heavy, Medium, and None).

The primary analytical tool was the RESISTOGRAPH 1410, which measures the mechanical resistance encountered by a 1.5mm needle driven into the tree at a constant speed. This resistance correlates strongly with wood density ($R^2 > 0.8$). Nine years after the initial treatments, 27 trees were harvested to compare these drilling resistance profiles against physical ring measurements and statistical models.

Drilling resistance profile of a Taiwania sample tree showing periodic variations corresponding to annual rings.

Impact of Silvicultural Treatments

The study highlights a fundamental trade-off in forest management: rapid growth versus wood density.

Thinning and Growth

Thinning emerged as the dominant factor affecting ring characteristics. By reducing competition for light and nutrients, heavy thinning significantly accelerated radial growth. Trees in heavily thinned plots reached an average diameter at breast height (DBH) of 28.03 cm, compared to 23.53 cm in unthinned plots. However, this growth was primarily driven by an expansion of earlywood, which is less dense than latewood. Consequently, while heavy thinning produced the widest rings (averaging 5.81 mm), it resulted in a lower average wood density (0.38 $g/cm^3$) compared to unthinned plots (0.40 $g/cm^3$).

Impact of thinning intensity on average annual ring width over a nine-year period.

Pruning and Latewood Stability

Pruning had a secondary, generally inhibitory effect on growth, leading to narrower rings. For instance, unpruned trees averaged a ring width of 5.58 mm, while medium pruning reduced this to 4.73 mm. Interestingly, the percentage of latewood remained relatively stable across all treatments, suggesting that the transition from earlywood to latewood is influenced more by environmental or genetic factors than by stand density.

Conclusion

The validation of the RESISTOGRAPH as a proxy for wood density provides foresters with a powerful tool for non-destructive assessment. The study confirms that while thinning is an effective strategy for increasing timber volume, it must be managed carefully to avoid significant reductions in wood density. The drilling resistance method successfully mirrors traditional density profiles, allowing for the identification of ring boundaries and density variations in standing timber with high reliability.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{wang2003application,
  author = {S.-Y. Wang and C.-M. Chiu and Chih‐Jen Lin},
  title = {{Application of the drilling resistance method for annual ring characteristics: evaluation of Taiwania (Taiwania cryptomerioides) trees grown with different thinning and pruning treatments}},
  journal = {Journal of Wood Science},
  year = {2003},
  doi = {10.1007/s100860300018},
}
Figure