Application of the 2021 AAPOS Guidelines in Clinics with Revision and Validation of SPOT Referral Criteria

Rui Li, Qi Yan, Xiao Lin, Ziwei Wu, Hui Zhu, Wei Guo, Peibin Zhang, F. Zuo, Ziyan Wu, Hu Liu, Dan HuangClinical 2025 · DOI

Abstract

The study proposes the "Nanjing Referral Criteria" and its modified version with enhanced specificity for the Spot Vision Screener to optimize vision screening in children. Vision screening programs can utilize this validated data to select referral criteria best suited to their local context.

Introduction

Amblyopia, commonly known as "lazy eye," affects approximately 2% of the global population. If not identified and treated during early childhood, it can lead to permanent vision loss. To combat this, pediatricians and vision specialists increasingly rely on instrument-based screening. Devices like the Spot Vision Screener (SVS) allow for rapid, non-invasive estimation of a child's refractive error without the need for cycloplegic eye drops.

However, the effectiveness of these screeners depends heavily on the referral thresholds used. In 2021, the American Association for Pediatric Ophthalmology and Strabismus (AAPOS) updated its diagnostic guidelines, shifting the focus toward "meridional power" rather than simple "spherical equivalent." This change necessitates a re-evaluation of how automated screeners are calibrated to ensure they catch at-risk children without overwhelming healthcare systems with false positives.

Addressing Systematic Device Bias

A critical finding of this research is that automated screeners like the SVS do not perfectly mirror clinical "gold standard" measurements. There is a consistent "machine signature" or systematic bias inherent in the device's measurements when compared to cycloplegic retinoscopy (CR).

Specifically, the SVS tends to underestimate hyperopia (farsightedness) and overestimate astigmatism. In this study, the mean difference for spherical power was 0.74 D, and for cylinder power, it was 0.49 D. Understanding these biases is essential for developing accurate referral criteria that align with the 2021 AAPOS standards.

Bland-Altman plots showing the systematic bias of the Spot Vision Screener (SVS) compared to cycloplegic retinoscopy (CR) for spherical power (A) and cylinder power (B).

Methodology

The researchers conducted a validation study involving 1,103 children aged 12 months to 7 years at a clinic in Nanjing, China. The cohort was divided into two age-based subgroups: children under four years (n=347) and those four years or older (n=756).

Each participant underwent a two-step evaluation:

  1. Initial Screening: Non-cycloplegic screening using the Spot Vision Screener.
  2. Clinical Reference: Cycloplegic Retinoscopy (CR), performed after administering eye drops to paralyze the eye's focusing muscles, providing the "ground truth" measurement.

The team utilized Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) curves to identify optimal cut-off points for various refractive errors, including hyperopia, myopia, astigmatism, and anisometropia.

The Nanjing Referral Criteria

Based on the ROC analysis, the researchers developed the "Nanjing Referral Criteria." These thresholds were specifically tuned for the Chinese pediatric population to better align with the 2021 AAPOS guidelines.

For children under four, the optimal thresholds were set at +2.13 D for hyperopia and -2.88 D for myopia and astigmatism. To further optimize the balance between sensitivity and specificity, the team proposed a "Modified Nanjing Criteria," which slightly tightened the requirements for referral to reduce the rate of false alarms.

Results and Clinical Impact

The study compared the performance of the Nanjing criteria against established sets like the Arnold and Peterseim criteria.

  • Sensitivity vs. Specificity: The original Nanjing criteria achieved a high sensitivity of 86.04%, ensuring most at-risk children were identified. However, the specificity was 62.26%.
  • The Modified Advantage: The Modified Nanjing Criteria successfully increased specificity to 71.45% while maintaining a sensitivity of 80.52%.
  • Comparative Performance: The Peterseim criteria were found to be overly liberal, with 98% sensitivity but only 9% specificity, leading to a massive number of unnecessary referrals. Conversely, the Arnold criteria remained the most conservative.

In a high-volume healthcare environment, the 9% improvement in specificity offered by the Modified Nanjing Criteria represents a significant reduction in unnecessary specialist visits, allowing clinics to focus resources on children who truly need intervention.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The "Nanjing Referral Criteria" provide a validated framework for using the Spot Vision Screener in accordance with the latest AAPOS guidelines. While the study demonstrates that local optimization can significantly improve screening efficiency, limitations remain. The specificity ceiling of approximately 71% suggests that nearly 30% of referrals may still be "false alarms."

Future research should explore the integration of artificial intelligence to further refine "pass/fail" decisions and investigate how these criteria perform in broader, school-based mass screening environments compared to the clinical setting used in this study.

Summary updated

Abstract

The study proposes the "Nanjing Referral Criteria" and its modified version with enhanced specificity for the Spot Vision Screener to optimize vision screening in children. Vision screening programs can utilize this validated data to select referral criteria best suited to their local context.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2025application,
  author = {Rui Li and Qi Yan and Xiao Lin and Ziwei Wu and Hui Zhu and Wei Guo and Peibin Zhang and F. Zuo and Ziyan Wu and Hu Liu and Dan Huang},
  title = {{Application of the 2021 AAPOS Guidelines in Clinics with Revision and Validation of SPOT Referral Criteria}},
  booktitle = {Clinical},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.2147/opth.s488084},
}
Figure