Application of Robust Control for CSR Formalization and Stakeholders Interest

Sana Ben Abdallah, Dhafer Saïdane, Mihály PetreczkyComputational 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) has long been a cornerstone of modern business ethics, yet it frequently suffers from a lack of rigorous, quantitative definition. Often relegated to qualitative mission statements, CSR goals are difficult to measure and balance against the competing interests of diverse stakeholders. This paper proposes a paradigm shift, moving CSR from the realm of corporate communication into the domain of control engineering. By applying robust control theory and state-space modeling, the authors provide a mathematical framework to ensure long-term organizational sustainability and stakeholder equity.

The Problem: Balancing Conflicting Interests in Volatile Environments

The fundamental challenge of CSR lies in the inherent conflict between stakeholder groups—shareholders, employees, regulators, and customers—each with distinct and often opposing objectives. Furthermore, these interests are not static; they evolve within a dynamical economic environment subject to constant shocks and uncertainties.

Traditional management approaches often lack a theoretical framework that accounts for these temporal dynamics and the necessity of fairness. The authors address a critical gap: how can a corporation identify a management strategy that achieves a fair equilibrium while guaranteeing that no stakeholder’s vital interests are compromised, even in the face of market volatility or model inaccuracies?

Methodology: A Systems Engineering Approach to Ethics

The researchers adopt a "systems engineering" perspective, modeling the corporation as a discrete-time dynamical system.

State-Space Modeling and Utility Theory

The company’s status is represented through "attributes" (e.g., profitability, wages, loan ratios), which serve as system states. Management decisions act as control inputs. To quantify stakeholder satisfaction, the authors employ Multi-Attribute Utility Theory (MAUT). Utility functions map the company's state to a value between 0 and 1, representing the degree of satisfaction for each stakeholder group.

Robust Control and Linear Matrix Inequalities (LMIs)

The core technical contribution involves the use of Linear Matrix Inequalities (LMIs) to derive a feedback control law. This law guides management in adjusting inputs based on the current state to drive the system toward a Pareto-optimal equilibrium—a state where no stakeholder's utility can be improved without diminishing another's.

The Concept of the "Safe Invariant Set"

A pivotal concept in this framework is the "safe invariant set," defined as an ellipsoid within the state space. If the system remains within this set, the utility of every stakeholder is mathematically guaranteed to stay above a predefined "catastrophic" threshold. In this context, sustainability is redefined as the property of maintaining the system within this safe invariant region.

Case Study: The Banking Sector

To validate the framework, the authors developed a phenomenological model based on expert assessments within the banking industry. The simulation involved three primary stakeholders:

  • The Manager: Focused on remuneration and performance.
  • The Regulator: Focused on stability and compliance (e.g., non-performing loans).
  • The Customer: Focused on service quality and costs.

The model utilized six specific metrics, including Return on Assets (ROA) and annual remuneration evolution. Interaction matrices ($A$ and $B$) were constructed using qualitative expert input to define how these variables influence one another over time.

Key Results and Insights

The simulations yielded several critical insights into the dynamics of socially responsible management:

  1. Convergence to Equilibrium: The proposed feedback strategy successfully steered the bank’s attributes toward a fair, Rawlsian equilibrium—maximizing collective utility rather than shareholder profit alone.
  2. Robustness to Disturbances: When subjected to periodic market shocks, the system demonstrated resilience. As long as disturbances did not force the system out of the "safe set," the feedback mechanism successfully corrected the trajectory back toward sustainability.
  3. The Instability of Greed: A "greedy" scenario was simulated, where inputs were optimized solely for manager utility (e.g., through excessive fees). While this led to a short-term spike in manager satisfaction, it caused a total collapse in customer utility, proving that profit-maximization at the expense of other stakeholders is inherently unsustainable within this dynamical framework.

Discussion and Future Directions

The paper also explores the role of external regulation, suggesting that control strategies could be implemented via "reputational taxes" or policy nudges. These mechanisms would effectively "tax" a corporation as it deviates from the socially optimal path, providing a market-based signal to return to the safe invariant set.

However, the authors acknowledge certain limitations. The current model relies on expert opinion for interaction matrices; future work should focus on estimating these parameters using empirical econometric data. Additionally, while the linear assumptions used here are computationally efficient, real-world economic systems may require non-linear techniques such as Model Predictive Control (MPC) to capture more complex behaviors.

Conclusion

By formalizing CSR as a robust control problem, this research provides a rigorous roadmap for ethical management. It transforms sustainability from a marketing slogan into a quantifiable objective for the "C-suite," offering a mathematical basis for balancing the complex, competing demands of modern corporate governance.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{abdallah2022application,
  author = {Sana Ben Abdallah and Dhafer Saïdane and Mihály Petreczky},
  title = {{Application of Robust Control for CSR Formalization and Stakeholders Interest}},
  booktitle = {Computational},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1007/s10614-022-10286-y},
}
Figure