Abstract
Secondary organic carbon (SOC) is often a significant portion of organic carbon (OC) in ambient particulate matter (PM). The levels and seasonal patterns of SOC in Hong Kong were examined using more than 2000 PM10 measurements made over a 4.5-year period (1998–2002) in a network of ten air quality monitoring stations. The positive matrix factorization (PMF) model was used to analyze this large data set for source identification and apportioning. SOC was subsequently estimated to be the sum of OC present in the secondary sources, i.e., secondary sulfate, secondary nitrate, and secondary organic aerosol. The annual average SOC as estimated by the PMF method was 4.25 μg C/m3 while the summer average was 1.66 μg C/m3 and the winter average was 7.05 μg C/m3. In comparison, the method that uses EC as a tracer for primary carbonaceous aerosol sources to derive SOC overestimated SOC by 70–212% for the summer samples and by 4–43% for the winter samples. The overestimation by the EC tracer method resulted from the inability of obtaining a single OC/EC ratio that represented a mixture of primary sources varying in time and space. We found that SOC and secondary sulfate had synchronous seasonal variation and were correlated in individual seasons, suggesting common factors that control their formation. Additionally, the presence of SOC was found to be enhanced more than that of secondary sulfate in the winter. We postulate this to be a combined result of favorable partitioning of semivolatile SOC species in the particle phase and more abundant SOC precursors in the winter.
Introduction
Atmospheric particulate matter (PM) contains Organic Carbon (OC), which is broadly categorized into primary organic carbon (POC), emitted directly from sources like vehicle exhaust, and secondary organic carbon (SOC), formed through complex chemical reactions in the atmosphere. While SOC constitutes a major fraction of total organic carbon, its quantification remains a significant challenge in atmospheric science because it cannot be measured directly. Traditionally, researchers have relied on the Elemental Carbon (EC) tracer method, which uses EC as a proxy for primary emissions. However, this method assumes a constant OC/EC ratio for primary sources—an assumption that often fails in complex urban environments like Hong Kong where emission sources vary significantly by location and season.
Methodology: PMF vs. the EC Tracer Method
To address the limitations of traditional methods, this study employed Positive Matrix Factorization (PMF), an advanced multivariate factor analysis tool. Unlike traditional models that require predefined source profiles (chemical fingerprints), PMF utilizes the internal variability of a large dataset to identify source categories. In this study, SOC was defined as the sum of OC associated with three secondary source factors identified by PMF: secondary sulfate, secondary nitrate, and secondary organic aerosol (SOA).
The researchers compared PMF-derived results against the traditional EC tracer method. As shown in the seasonal scatter plots of OC versus EC, the relationship between these two carbonaceous components shifts throughout the year, with slopes ranging from 0.41 in summer to 0.88 in winter. The EC tracer method's reliance on these varying slopes leads to systematic biases. Specifically, the tracer method was found to overestimate SOC by 70–212% in the summer and by 4–43% in the winter. This overestimation stems from the method's inability to account for non-EC associated OC (such as biogenic emissions) and the extreme diversity of primary OC/EC ratios in a dense urban setting.
Seasonal Dynamics and the 'Winter Spike'
The study analyzed over 2,000 PM10 samples collected over a 4.5-year period (1998–2002) across ten monitoring stations in Hong Kong. A key finding was the dramatic seasonal variation in SOC levels. The annual average SOC was 4.25 μg C/m³, but concentrations spiked to 7.05 μg C/m³ in the winter—more than four times the summer average of 1.66 μg C/m³.
This "winter spike" is attributed to two primary factors:
- Temperature-Driven Partitioning: Many secondary organic compounds are semi-volatile. In the high temperatures of summer, they remain in the gas phase; however, in the cooler winter months, they condense into the solid or liquid particles measured as PM.
- Precursor Availability: There is likely an increase in the abundance of reactive organic gases (precursors) during the winter months, leading to higher yields of secondary aerosols.
Relationship with Secondary Sulfate
A significant insight from the PMF analysis is the synchronous seasonality of SOC and secondary sulfate. The two pollutants show nearly identical seasonal patterns and are correlated within individual seasons. This suggests that common atmospheric factors—such as oxidant concentrations and stagnant air masses—govern the formation of both secondary species. Interestingly, the presence of SOC was found to be enhanced more than that of secondary sulfate in the winter, further supporting the hypothesis of favorable gas-to-particle partitioning for organic species in colder weather.
Conclusion
By utilizing PMF on an extensive multi-year dataset, this research provides a more accurate quantification of SOC in Hong Kong than previously possible with tracer methods. SOC was found to account for approximately 46% of total organic carbon and 13% of total PM10 mass. The findings highlight the critical role of seasonal meteorological conditions and precursor availability in driving secondary aerosol formation. Future work should focus on identifying specific organic precursors to better inform regional air quality management and emission control strategies.
Summary updated