Application of Positive Mathematical Programming (PMP) in Sustainable Water Resource Management: A Case Study of Hetao Irrigation District, China

Jingwei Yao, Julio Berbel, Zhiyuan Yang, Huiyong Wang, Javier Martínez-DalmauWater 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study applies a novel multi-stress factor Positive Mathematical Programming (PMP) model to the Hetao Irrigation District in China, revealing critical water usage thresholds and the limited effectiveness of water pricing alone. It highlights the resilience of crop rotation systems, particularly wheat-sunflower, under extreme salinity, offering a data-driven approach for sustainable water management and agricultural adaptation in arid regions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Arid and semi-arid regions worldwide face a growing crisis of water scarcity and soil salinization, threatening sustainable agricultural development and food security. The Hetao Irrigation District (HID) in China, a major agricultural hub, exemplifies this challenge. Existing agricultural economic models often struggle to capture the complex interplay of multiple environmental and economic stressors on farmer decision-making. Specifically, many studies focus on individual factors like water scarcity or pricing, neglecting the combined impact of water constraints, pricing policies, and soil salinity. Furthermore, the unique climatic and agricultural conditions of China's arid regions are often underrepresented in global PMP research. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing and applying a comprehensive, multi-stress factor PMP model to the HID to better understand and manage its agricultural water resources.

Methods

The core of this research is the application of Positive Mathematical Programming (PMP), a three-stage modeling approach designed to calibrate agricultural production models to observed data and simulate farmer behavior.

  • Stage 1: Linear Programming (LP): A standard LP model is used to maximize the total gross margin of the agricultural system, subject to land and water constraints. This stage also incorporates a "calibration constraint" to ensure the model reflects current planting structures.
  • Stage 2: Cost Function Calibration: The dual values (shadow prices) from the LP stage are used to calibrate a non-linear quadratic cost function. This step links the economic costs of production to observed farmer behavior.
  • Stage 3: Non-Linear Programming (NLP): A final NLP model is solved, incorporating the calibrated cost function, to maximize the total gross margin. This model is then used for scenario analysis to evaluate the impacts of different policy and environmental changes.

What's novel here is the integration of multiple stress factors into a single PMP framework. The model explicitly incorporates:

  • Water resource constraints: Including a water resource reduction ratio.
  • Water pricing policies: Simulating changes in water prices.
  • Soil salinity stress: Incorporating crop-specific salinity tolerance thresholds and a salinity stress function that reduces yield based on soil salinity levels.

This multi-stress factor approach allows for a more realistic assessment of the compound impacts on agricultural production systems.

Datasets

The study utilizes comprehensive data from the Hetao Irrigation District, including:

  • Agricultural production data: Crop yield, water requirements, prices, planting areas, production costs, and gross margins.
  • Water resource data: Yellow River diversion volumes, water quality data, and water supply availability.
  • Environmental data: Soil salinity levels and crop-specific salinity tolerance thresholds (referenced from FAO data).
  • Socio-economic data: Information from the "Bayannur Statistical Yearbook" and interviews with local farmers.

The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets but rather compiles and integrates existing data specific to the HID to calibrate and validate its PMP model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Critical Water Thresholds: The agricultural system in HID exhibits significant vulnerability, with a critical transition zone for water resource utilization occurring between 60-70%. Beyond this point, crop yields and economic returns decline sharply. This suggests that early warning systems based on these thresholds are crucial.
  • Limited Impact of Water Pricing Alone: Water pricing policies show minimal effectiveness in the low-to-medium price ranges. Significant adjustments in farmer behavior and crop planting only occur at higher price points. This implies that water pricing needs to be complemented by other policy instruments.
  • Resilience of Crop Rotations: Crop rotation systems, particularly wheat-sunflower, demonstrate superior resilience to soil salinity compared to individual crops. They maintain a significantly higher planting proportion even under extreme salinity conditions.
  • Salinity Management is Key: Soil salinization is a major limiting factor. Stratified management based on salinity thresholds (safe, warning, restricted, prohibited zones) is essential for sustainable land use.
  • Wheat's Vulnerability: Wheat, a traditional staple crop, shows the highest sensitivity to water price changes and is moderately sensitive to salinity. This highlights the need for strategies to support its cultivation while promoting more resilient options.

Key Results

  • Water Scarcity Impact: A 10% reduction in water resources leads to a 5.5% decline in total gross margins. Extreme water scarcity (less than 20% availability) can cause economic losses as high as 96.3%.
  • Water Pricing Elasticity: Wheat exhibits the highest price sensitivity with a water price elasticity of -23.8%. Corn shows moderate sensitivity (-9.7%), while other crops and rotations are largely insensitive.
  • Salinity Tolerance: Under extreme salinity (10 dS/m), wheat-sunflower rotation maintains 85% of its planting proportion, significantly outperforming individual crops like corn (0%) and tomato-watermelon (20%). Rotation systems, on average, maintain a 52.3% planting proportion compared to 44.3% for individual crops at 10 dS/m.
  • Economic Efficiency: Tomato-watermelon combinations offer the highest water productivity (6.4 CNY/m³), while wheat has the lowest (1.9 CNY/m³).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Short-term Focus: The PMP model primarily captures short-term responses and may not fully account for long-term changes in agricultural systems.
  • Climate Change Dynamics: The current model does not fully incorporate the dynamic effects of changing temperature and precipitation patterns on crop water requirements and salinity stress. The static nature of the PMP framework limits its ability to capture temporal evolution of climate-agriculture interactions.

Future research directions suggested include:

  • Integrating Climate Change: Incorporating climate change scenarios, including stochastic weather patterns and long-term projections, to enhance predictive capabilities and policy relevance.
  • Technological Progress: Including the impact of agricultural technology advancements.
  • Institutional Factors: Exploring institutional factors that influence farmer decision-making.
  • Advanced Modeling: Developing integrated models that link agricultural, hydrological, and economic systems, and exploring machine learning techniques to enhance PMP model accuracy.

Summary updated

Abstract

Water scarcity and soil salinization pose significant challenges to sustainable agricultural development in arid and semi-arid regions globally. This study applies Positive Mathematical Programming (PMP) to analyze agricultural water resource management in the Hetao Irrigation District (HID), China. The research constructs a comprehensive multi-stress-factor integrated PMP model to evaluate the compound impacts of water resource constraints, pricing policies, and environmental stress on agricultural production systems. The model incorporates crop-specific salinity tolerance thresholds and simulates farmer decision-making behaviors under various scenarios including water supply reduction (0–100%), water pricing increases (0.2–1.0 CNY/m3), and soil salinity stress (0–10 dS/m). The results reveal that the agricultural system exhibits significant vulnerability characteristics with critical thresholds concentrated in the 60–70% water resource utilization interval. Water pricing policies show limited effectiveness in low-price ranges, with wheat demonstrating the highest price sensitivity (−23.8% elasticity). Crop salinity tolerance analysis indicates that wheat–sunflower rotation systems maintain an 85% planting proportion even under extreme salinity conditions (10 dS/m), significantly outperforming individual crops. The study proposes a hierarchical water resource quota allocation system based on vulnerability thresholds and recommends promoting salt-tolerant rotation systems to enhance agricultural resilience. These findings provide scientific evidence for sustainable water resource management and agricultural adaptation strategies in water-stressed regions, contributing to both theoretical advancement of the PMP methodology and practical policy formulation for irrigation districts facing similar challenges.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yao2025application,
  author = {Jingwei Yao and Julio Berbel and Zhiyuan Yang and Huiyong Wang and Javier Martínez-Dalmau},
  title = {{Application of Positive Mathematical Programming (PMP) in Sustainable Water Resource Management: A Case Study of Hetao Irrigation District, China}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/w17172598},
}
Figure