Application of numerical calculation methods in stability analysis of pile foundation under complex foundation conditions

Huimin Wang, Kai Ma, Jing Zhang, Kai ZhangNonlinear 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a more accurate numerical method for analyzing pile foundation stability by moving beyond the traditional "Winkler" model to a more sophisticated two-parameter model. This new approach accounts for the complex shear interactions in soil and dynamic marine loads, providing a safer and more realistic framework for designing offshore structures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In civil engineering, pile foundations are the "legs" that keep massive structures like bridges and offshore wind turbines standing. However, modeling how these piles interact with the surrounding soil is notoriously difficult, especially in marine environments.

For decades, engineers have relied on the Winkler model, which treats soil like a series of independent vertical springs. While simple, this model has a major flaw: it assumes that if you push down on one part of the soil, the neighboring soil doesn't feel a thing. In reality, soil is a continuous medium with internal shear forces. Furthermore, traditional models often focus on static loads, ignoring the rhythmic, punishing forces of waves, tides, and earthquakes. This gap leads to over-optimistic stability predictions that can fail under real-world dynamic conditions.

Methods

The authors propose a numerical calculation method based on a two-parameter model. Unlike the Winkler model, this approach incorporates:

  1. Subgrade Stiffness: The traditional "spring" resistance.
  2. Shear Interaction: A second parameter that accounts for the mechanical coupling between adjacent soil "springs," capturing how forces propagate through the soil mass.

The study utilizes the Finite Element Method (FEM) to simulate pile-soil interaction. They integrated specific marine variables into their equations, such as pile water entry depth, lateral soil resistance coefficients, and pile stiffness. To ensure the math held up, they validated their numerical results against physical model testing and experimental data.

Datasets

The paper does not use a standard public dataset (like those found in computer vision). Instead, it relies on:

  • Numerical Simulation Data: Generated through FEM modeling of various pile configurations (varying diameter, length, and soil properties).
  • Experimental Validation: Results from physical model tests conducted by the authors to confirm the accuracy of the two-parameter model against observed bending damage and slip resistance.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Shear Gap": The most significant "aha moment" is that the two-parameter model consistently predicts lower instability loads than the Winkler model. This suggests that traditional methods have been underestimating the risk of failure by ignoring soil shear.
  • The Resonance Trap: The researchers identified a "parameter resonance" region. When loading frequencies (from waves or tides) hit a certain critical value, the instability load drops abruptly to near zero.
  • Diminishing Returns on Pile Length: Interestingly, increasing pile length doesn't always lead to a linear increase in stability. There is an equilibrium point where the soil's restraining impact stabilizes; beyond this, the added mass of the pile can actually start to lower the critical frequency.
  • The Double-Edged Sword of Diameter: Increasing pile diameter boosts stiffness (good for stability) but also increases the mass (potentially bad for dynamic response). The paper highlights the need for a "sweet spot" in design to balance these factors.

Key Results

  • Improved Precision: The two-parameter model proved significantly more accurate in capturing nonlinear dynamic responses compared to conventional models.
  • Critical Frequency Trends: The study found that the critical frequency of the system rises as the soil resistance coefficient ($k$) increases, but—counterintuitively for some—it decreases as the shear stiffness ($G$) of the soil increases.
  • Stability Thresholds: The instability load ($N_{tcr}$) was shown to decrease slightly as static vertical loads increase, until reaching a critical threshold where the system becomes highly volatile.
  • Scour Impact: Simulations of "wave scour" (where waves wash away soil around the pile) showed a sharp decline in stability as the effective free length of the pile increased, providing a quantitative look at how erosion threatens marine structures.

Limitations and Future Work

While the two-parameter model is a major step forward, the authors acknowledge several areas for further exploration:

  • Extreme Conditions: The current model needs further validation under "extreme" scenarios, such as hurricane-force waves or high-magnitude seismic events.
  • Complex Soil Rheology: Future iterations could incorporate even more complex soil behaviors, such as liquefaction or time-dependent creep.
  • Generality: The researchers suggest expanding the model to cover a wider variety of loading types and pile materials to enhance its applicability across different engineering sectors.

Reference: Wang, H., Ma, K., Zhang, J., & Zhang, K. (2025). Application of numerical calculation methods in stability analysis of pile foundation under complex foundation conditions. Nonlinear Engineering.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Pile foundation has been widely applied in modern civil engineering due to its excellent performance under complex foundation conditions. However, when subjected to dynamic loads such as waves, tides, and earthquakes, the long-term stability of pile foundations becomes a significant concern. Traditional stability analysis methods are predominantly based on static loading assumptions, which neglect the nonlinear behavior of soils and the time-varying characteristics of dynamic loads. This leads to reduced prediction accuracy and limited applicability under real-world, complex working conditions. To address these challenges, this study proposes an innovative numerical calculation method based on a two-parameter model, which integrates dynamic load effects – such as wave and tidal actions – into the pile-soil interaction framework. Compared with the conventional Winkler model, the two-parameter model incorporates both the stiffness of the subgrade and the shear interaction between adjacent soil springs, thereby capturing the nonlinear and spatially correlated behavior of foundation soils more accurately. The core innovations of this study lie in two aspects. First, it introduces a more refined numerical model by incorporating key parameters such as pile water entry depth, lateral soil resistance coefficient, and pile stiffness, offering a more realistic simulation of complex marine foundation conditions. Second, it performs a comprehensive stability analysis under dynamic loading environments, systematically investigating the influence of various factors including soil properties, pile length, and pile diameter on the critical frequency and overall structural stability. The research findings show that the proposed two-parameter model significantly improves the precision of stability analysis and effectively reveals the nonlinear dynamic responses of pile foundations. This contributes to both the theoretical development of pile-soil interaction modeling and practical engineering applications in marine and offshore structures.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2025application,
  author = {Huimin Wang and Kai Ma and Jing Zhang and Kai Zhang},
  title = {{Application of numerical calculation methods in stability analysis of pile foundation under complex foundation conditions}},
  booktitle = {Nonlinear},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1515/nleng-2025-0162},
}
Figure