Application of Measurement Uncertainty for Electric Motor Efficiency Evaluation

Fei Li, Yuanxing Zhang, Jie Li, Xiaobin Yang, Taoyong Li, Weili Shang2015 · DOI

Abstract

Faced with the challenge that resource depletion and environment deterioration, an important energy-saving measure by enhancing electric motor efficiency has been adopted around the world. With the development of measurement uncertainty of electric motor, for conventional motor efficiency evaluation, the methods or requirements used for measurement uncertainty are not uniform, and only motor tolerance is considered, how to select evaluation method to improve accuracy of electric motor efficiency has become a problem. In this paper, the theory and methods concerning measurement uncertainty of electric motor has been explored, which offer important reference for evaluation of electric motor.

Introduction

As global efforts intensify to combat resource depletion through higher energy efficiency, the precision of efficiency measurements for electric motors—the primary drivers of industrial activity—has become paramount. Efficiency is not a static value but a derived calculation from multiple sensor inputs, including power, torque, speed, and temperature. Historically, engineers have relied on "tolerance," which represents the allowable deviation between nominal and measured values. However, tolerance fails to account for measurement uncertainty—the statistical dispersion or "noise" inherent in the measurement process. This paper addresses the lack of a standardized method for evaluating this uncertainty, which is critical for certifying high-efficiency motors.

Methodology

The researchers established a framework based on Chinese metrology standards (JJF 1001-2011 and JJF 1059.1-2012), utilizing a dual-pronged approach:

  1. A-Type Evaluation: This involves the statistical analysis of repeated measurements. For instance, ten efficiency tests were performed on the same motor under identical conditions. The standard deviation ($u_A$) was calculated using the Bessel equation to quantify random errors.
  2. B-Type Evaluation: This accounts for uncertainties from testing equipment, such as power analyzers, torque sensors, and temperature loggers, derived from calibration certificates and manufacturer specifications ($u_B$).
Table of repeated efficiency measurements used for A-type statistical evaluation.

The mathematical model decomposes motor efficiency into six components: input power, stator copper loss, iron loss, windage/friction loss, rotor copper loss, and stray losses. These are combined into a Composite Standard Uncertainty ($u_c$) and then multiplied by a coverage factor ($k=2$) to determine the Expanded Uncertainty ($U$), representing a 95% confidence interval.

Results and Discussion

A key finding of this research is the practical application of the "One-Third Rule." The study demonstrates that if the expanded uncertainty is less than one-third of the allowable efficiency tolerance (defined by standards like GB755-2008), the measurement uncertainty can be considered negligible for qualification purposes.

Comparison of expanded uncertainty against efficiency tolerance for various motor capacities and poles.

The results show that as motor capacity increases, expanded uncertainty generally decreases. For a 315kW motor, the expanded uncertainty was only 0.13%, well within the 1/3 tolerance threshold. Conversely, for a 7.5kW 8-pole motor, the expanded uncertainty was 0.30%, which also satisfied the rule against its 1.92% tolerance. This confirms that the measurement systems used were sufficiently precise for qualification. The paper identifies stray loss uncertainty as the most complex factor, requiring specific modeling of torque and residual losses.

Conclusion

This framework provides a rigorous method for motor efficiency evaluation, moving beyond simple tolerance allowances. By establishing that measurement uncertainty is often significantly lower than standard tolerances, it offers a clear path for labs to qualify motors based on measured values plus tolerance. While currently aligned with specific national standards, the methodology provides a blueprint for international standardization. Future work may refine the model by integrating complex variables like curve-fitting for windage and iron losses to achieve even higher precision.

Summary updated

Abstract

Faced with the challenge that resource depletion and environment deterioration, an important energy-saving measure by enhancing electric motor efficiency has been adopted around the world. With the development of measurement uncertainty of electric motor, for conventional motor efficiency evaluation, the methods or requirements used for measurement uncertainty are not uniform, and only motor tolerance is considered, how to select evaluation method to improve accuracy of electric motor efficiency has become a problem. In this paper, the theory and methods concerning measurement uncertainty of electric motor has been explored, which offer important reference for evaluation of electric motor.
BibTeX
@misc{li2015application,
  author = {Fei Li and Yuanxing Zhang and Jie Li and Xiaobin Yang and Taoyong Li and Weili Shang},
  title = {{Application of Measurement Uncertainty for Electric Motor Efficiency Evaluation}},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.2991/ifeesm-15.2015.179},
}
Figure