Application of Intelligent Recommendation Techniques for Consumers' Food Choices in Restaurants

Xinke Li, Wenyan Jia, Zhaofang Yang, Yuecheng Li, Ding Yuan, Hong Zhang, Mingui SunFrontiers in Psychiatry 2018 · DOI

Abstract

As robotic servers begin to replace human waitstaff, there is a clear need for intelligent systems to help consumers navigate complex menus. This paper presents a Multi-Attribute Relation Matrix Tri-Factorization (MARMTF) technique for a relation-driven food recommendation system. By integrating user ordering history with dish attributes like ingredients, spiciness, and price, the system predicts individual dietary preferences. Experimental results demonstrate that MARMTF effectively simplifies food choice tasks and outperforms traditional collaborative filtering methods, offering a robust solution for future automated restaurant services.

Introduction

The "paradox of choice" is particularly acute in restaurants with extensive menus. While human waiters often use intuition to guide customers, the trend toward robotic servers creates a "recommendation gap." Existing systems often focus narrowly on healthy dieting or simple collaborative filtering (e.g., "people who liked this also liked that"). However, eating behavior is driven by a complex interplay of taste, budget, and ingredient preferences. The challenge lies in mathematically fusing these heterogeneous data sources into a cohesive model that accurately predicts customer enjoyment.

Methodology: Multi-Attribute Relation Matrix Tri-Factorization

The core innovation is the Multi-Attribute Relation Matrix Tri-Factorization (MARMTF) technique. Unlike standard models that rely solely on user ratings, MARMTF constructs a large "block matrix" integrating multiple relationship types.

Relation Fusion

The system models five key entities: Users, Dishes, Price, Ingredients, and Spice Level. As illustrated in the relation fusion graph, these entities are interconnected through various matrices:

Relation fusion graph of the system
  • User-Dish: Historical ratings (1–5 scale).
  • Dish-Ingredient: Categorical data (meat, poultry, vegetables, etc.).
  • Dish-Spiciness: Four levels from "not spicy" to "very spicy."
  • Dish-Price: Three tiers (low, medium, high).

Optimization and Prediction

MARMTF uses tri-factorization to decompose the block matrix into three factors ($V$ and $B$), capturing hidden associations across diverse data types. This allows for simultaneous co-clustering of users and dishes based on multiple attributes. Multiplicative update rules are employed to minimize the difference between original sparse data and the reconstructed matrix, effectively filling in predicted ratings for untried dishes.

Experimental Results

The study utilized a dataset of 289 dishes from Chongqing, China, with 37 participants. The MARMTF model consistently outperformed industry-standard algorithms in terms of accuracy.

Error values (RMSE and MAE) across iteration times

As shown in the convergence plot, the model achieves stable performance quickly. MARMTF reached a Root Mean Squared Error (RMSE) of 0.1693 and a Mean Absolute Error (MAE) of 0.1342. In comparison, popular models like SVD++ and Classical Matrix Factorization yielded significantly higher error rates (RMSE of 0.1805 and 0.2443, respectively).

Conclusion and Future Work

MARMTF demonstrates that incorporating background information like ingredients and price significantly stabilizes recommendations, especially when user rating data is sparse. While the current study focused on Sichuan cuisine, future iterations could incorporate seasonal contexts and health data (e.g., BMI) to provide even more personalized and nutritionally balanced recommendations. This system has great potential for deployment in future restaurants using non-human waitstaff.

Summary updated

Abstract

Currently, there has been a new trend in applying modern robotics, information technology, and artificial intelligence to restaurants for improvements of food service, cost-effectiveness, and customer satisfaction. As robots replace humans to serve food, there is a clear need for robotic servers to help consumers select foods from a menu that satisfies their preferences such as taste and nutrition. However, currently, little is known about how eating behaviors drive food choices, and it is often difficult for consumers to make choices from a variety of foods offered by the typical restaurant, even with the assistance from a human server. In this paper, we conduct an exploratory study on an intelligent food choice method that recommends dishes by predicting individual's dietary preference, including ingredients, types of spices, price, etc. A multi-attribute relation matrix tri-factorization (MARMTF) technique is developed for a relation-driven food recommendation system. First, the user's ordering history and their rating scores of the foods in the menu are gathered and represented by a user-dish rating matrix. Next, the attribute relations of the ingredients, spicy level, and price of each food choice are extracted to construct a group of the relation matrices. Then, these matrices are integrated into a large block matrix. In the next step, a matrix tri-factorization algorithm is employed to decompose the block matrix and fuse the complex relationships into matrix factors. Further, a set of approximation block matrices are constructed and the predicted food rating matrix is generated. Finally, the foods (dishes) with sufficiently high preference scores are recommended to the consumers. Our experiments demonstrate that the MARMTF technique can provide effective dish recommendation for customers. Our system significantly simplifies the daunting task of making food choices and has a great potential in providing intelligent and professionally trained non-human waiters and waitresses for employment by future restaurants.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2018application,
  author = {Xinke Li and Wenyan Jia and Zhaofang Yang and Yuecheng Li and Ding Yuan and Hong Zhang and Mingui Sun},
  title = {{Application of Intelligent Recommendation Techniques for Consumers' Food Choices in Restaurants}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychiatry},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyt.2018.00415},
}
Figure