Application of Blockchain Technology in Environmental Health: Literature Review and Prospect of Visualization Based on CiteSpace

Meiwen Guo, Zhenheng Huang, Liang Wu, Cheng Ling Tan, Jianping Peng, Xingcheng Guo, Hong ChenTechnologies 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper provides a comprehensive literature review of blockchain technology's application in environmental health from 2014-2021, using bibliometric analysis to map research trends, collaborations, and key themes. It highlights a growing but fragmented research landscape, emphasizing the need for more integrated, cross-disciplinary studies to address complex environmental and health challenges.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The authors address the growing interest in blockchain technology and its potential applications beyond its initial financial domain. Specifically, they identify a gap in understanding how blockchain is being applied to environmental health issues. While blockchain offers promising features like transparency, traceability, and decentralization, its integration into environmental health research is still nascent and lacks a clear, unified direction. The paper aims to map the current research landscape, identify key players and themes, and suggest future research avenues to foster more effective and impactful applications in this critical interdisciplinary field.

Methods

The study employs a bibliometric analysis using CiteSpace software to systematically review and visualize research trends. The core methods include:

  • Data Retrieval: A search of the Web of Science database using specific keywords related to blockchain, environment, and health.
  • Visual Analysis: CiteSpace was used to analyze various indicators, including:
  • Article Publication Trends: Tracking the number of publications over time to identify growth periods.
  • Author Collaboration Networks: Mapping relationships between researchers to identify key contributors and collaborative clusters.
  • Research Institution Networks: Visualizing the spatial distribution and collaboration patterns of academic institutions.
  • Keyword Co-occurrence Analysis: Identifying frequently appearing keywords and their relationships to pinpoint research hotspots.
  • Keyword Clustering: Grouping related keywords to reveal thematic areas within the research.
  • Keyword Burst Detection: Identifying keywords that experienced a surge in popularity over specific periods, indicating emerging trends.
  • Co-citation Analysis: Mapping the relationships between highly cited papers to identify foundational research.
  • Country/Region Collaboration Networks: Analyzing the geographical distribution of research and international collaborations.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the Web of Science database, covering publications from 2014 to 2021. The specific search query was: TS = ((blockchain AND environment) OR (blockchain AND health) OR (blockchain AND environment AND health)). No new datasets were introduced; the paper relies entirely on existing published literature.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Nascent but Growing Field: Research on blockchain in environmental health is relatively new, with a significant surge in publications starting around 2017, indicating a growing interest and development phase.
  • Fragmented Research Landscape: While there's increasing activity, the research tends to focus on either environmental or health aspects individually, rather than a holistic integration. This "siloed" approach might hinder comprehensive solutions.
  • Key Themes Emerge: Core themes include "blockchain," "internet of things," "security," and "privacy," highlighting the foundational technologies and critical concerns in this domain.
  • Collaborative Efforts are Weak: The author and institution collaboration networks show a "weak collaboration network," suggesting a need for more robust interdisciplinary and international partnerships.
  • China and the US Lead in Volume, but Not Necessarily Influence: While China and the US publish the most articles, their betweenness centrality is relatively low, suggesting their research might be more internally focused or less connected to global research networks.
  • Emerging Hotspots: Burst keyword analysis reveals "consortium," "trust management," and "data security" as recent emerging hotspots, indicating a shift towards practical implementation and trust-building aspects.

Key Results

  • Publication Trend: A slow growth from 2014-2016, followed by rapid acceleration, peaking at 874 articles in 2020.
  • Author Collaboration: A network of 324 authors with 305 edges, indicating a weak collaboration density. Neeraj Kumar is the most prolific author with 26 articles.
  • Institution Collaboration: A network of 310 institutions with 521 edges, showing a moderate density. Chinese Academy of Sciences leads with 47 articles.
  • Keyword Co-occurrence: "Blockchain" is the most frequent keyword, followed by "internet of things" and "security."
  • Top Clusters: The largest keyword clusters include "blockchain," "artificial intelligence," and "security," with average years around 2017-2019.
  • Country Contributions: China leads in publications (713 articles), followed by the USA (509) and India (304).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study acknowledges that the research is primarily focused on the application of blockchain in environmental health, with less emphasis on the theoretical development of the technology itself within this context.
  • The literature results have a "limited impact on surrounding fields," especially where correlations are weak, suggesting a need for more impactful and integrated research.
  • Collaborations are largely confined to geographically proximate institutions and those within the same research field, limiting cross-border and cross-discipline engagement.
  • Future Work:
    • Encourage cross-disciplinary studies to integrate environmental and health aspects more effectively, avoiding information silos.
  • Promote collaborations across multiple fields and borders to address the global nature of environmental and health issues.
  • Strengthen the technical performance of blockchain in environmental applications, focusing on data transfer and computational power.
  • Explore diverse application scenarios and foster theoretical and applied research opportunities.
  • Develop innovative solutions by combining blockchain with environmental industry segmentation and addressing specific environmental problems.
  • Promote openness, diversity, and collaboration to avoid stereotypical thinking and foster a broader range of innovative ideas.

Summary updated

Abstract

Blockchain technology and its applications have recently become a research hotspot. Its three core technologies, distributed ledger, smart contract, and consensus mechanism, provide trust-enhancing features such as tamper-proof records, full traceability, and data decentralization for a wide range of applications. This paper investigates the use of blockchain technology in environmental health. It investigates indicators such as the number of articles published, author collaboration network, research institution network, and keyword co-occurrence in this field between 2014 and 2021. It describes and analyzes the development and connotations of these indicators. Many scholars have conducted in-depth studies on blockchain in various areas. Still, there are few cross-over studies on environmental health and a lack of cross-over studies on technology application in multiple fields. The current study investigates the evolution of research on the application of blockchain technology in environmental health, as well as potential development patterns and research trends, to provide a theoretical foundation for the application and sustainability of blockchain technology in this field.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{guo2022application,
  author = {Meiwen Guo and Zhenheng Huang and Liang Wu and Cheng Ling Tan and Jianping Peng and Xingcheng Guo and Hong Chen},
  title = {{Application of Blockchain Technology in Environmental Health: Literature Review and Prospect of Visualization Based on CiteSpace}},
  booktitle = {Technologies},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/technologies10050100},
}
Figure