Application of Biphase Complete Complementary Code for Ionospheric Sounding

Guobin Yang, Peng Duan, Chun-Hua Jiang, Tongxin Liu, Ting Lan, Zhengyu Zhao, Shuzhu Shi, Xu ChenSensors 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel application of biphase Complete Complementary Codes (CCC) for multi-station ionospheric sounding. By leveraging the unique correlation properties of CCC, the authors demonstrate an effective method to eliminate coherent interference, a significant challenge in synchronized ionospheric measurements, thereby enabling more reliable and automatable ionogram analysis.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Ionospheric sounding, a technique used to study the Earth's upper atmosphere, often involves networks of synchronized ionosondes. A major challenge in these multi-station setups is "coherent interference," where signals from different stations overlap and interfere, making it difficult to accurately interpret the resulting ionograms. Traditional methods for suppressing this interference are not well-suited for ionospheric sounding. This paper aims to solve this problem by proposing and validating the use of biphase Complete Complementary Codes (CCC) as a more effective solution for eliminating this interference in synchronized ionospheric sounding networks.

Methods

The core of this paper lies in the application of Complete Complementary Codes (CCC). The authors first describe an algorithm for generating biphase CCC, which are sequences where the sum of autocorrelations is zero except at zero shift, and the sum of cross-correlations between different sequences is also zero. This property is crucial for distinguishing signals from multiple sources. They detail the process of constructing the specific biphase waveform used for ionospheric sounding, where +1 and -1 represent phase shifts. Signal processing techniques, including matched filtering, are then applied to extract the desired information from the received echoes. The paper also includes simulations to analyze the autocorrelation and cross-correlation characteristics of the proposed CCC and compares them to conventional complementary codes. Finally, experimental results from multi-station ionospheric sounding are presented to validate the effectiveness of the CCC approach.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments utilize real-time ionospheric sounding data collected from ionosondes installed at Ningqiang and Wuhan.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • CCC's Superior Interference Suppression: The key insight is that CCC's ideal autocorrelation and cross-correlation properties are significantly better than conventional complementary codes for eliminating coherent interference in multi-station ionospheric sounding. This is demonstrated through simulations and experimental results.
  • Enabling Automated Ionogram Scaling: By effectively separating vertical and oblique echoes on a single ionogram, CCC makes it feasible to automatically scale ionograms using software, a significant improvement over manual or semi-automated methods currently required.
  • Trade-offs in CCC Design: The paper acknowledges that the number of subsets (M) and the length of sequences (L) in CCC are limiting factors. Increasing these can lead to larger detection dead zones and reduced applicability, suggesting a need for careful design choices.
  • Doppler Shift Resilience: The analysis shows that CCC maintains low sidelobe peak levels even with significant Doppler shifts, which are common in ionospheric sounding, indicating robustness for this application.

Key Results

  • Effective Interference Elimination: Experimental results confirm that the biphase CCC effectively eliminates coherent interference in multi-station ionospheric sounding.
  • Separation of Echoes: The use of CCC allows for clear separation of vertical and oblique echoes on the same ionogram, which is crucial for accurate parameter extraction.
  • Improved Autocorrelation Gain: Simulations show that the {4, 4, 16} CCC provides double the autocorrelation gain compared to a 16-bit complementary code, leading to better signal detection.
  • Reduced Sidelobe Peaks: The CCC exhibits significantly lower sidelobe peaks in its ambiguity function compared to m-sequences and Barker codes, especially at higher Doppler shifts, though the effect of Doppler shift is minimal for typical ionospheric sounding frequencies.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limiting Factors: The number of subsets (M) and the length of sequences (L) in CCC are identified as primary limiting factors. Increasing these can lead to an exponential growth in the probe cycle length, potentially enlarging the detection dead zone and degrading applicability.
  • Future Directions: While not explicitly detailed as future work, the paper implies that further research could focus on optimizing the CCC parameters (M and L) to balance interference suppression capabilities with detection dead zone limitations. The successful demonstration of CCC for ionospheric sounding also opens avenues for its application in other areas requiring synchronized multi-source signal processing.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper illustrates the processes carried out for the application of biphase complete complementary code (CCC) for ionospheric sounding to address the coherent interference problem in multi-station ionospheric sounding. An algorithm to generate the biphase CCC is described, and the detailed process of waveform construction and signal processing is presented. Characteristics of the autocorrelation and cross-correlation are analyzed through simulations, and the technical feasibility of the application of CCC is explored. Experiments of ionospheric sounding with the CCC are also implemented to verify performance. Results demonstrate that the CCC performs well in multi-station ionospheric sounding, and is capable of eliminating the coherent interference in the network of ionosondes, compared to the conventional complementary code.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2018application,
  author = {Guobin Yang and Peng Duan and Chun-Hua Jiang and Tongxin Liu and Ting Lan and Zhengyu Zhao and Shuzhu Shi and Xu Chen},
  title = {{Application of Biphase Complete Complementary Code for Ionospheric Sounding}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/s18092811},
}
Figure