Applicability of Difference in Oxygen-18 and Deuterium of Water Sources and Isotopic Hydrograph Separation in a Bamboo Catchment during Different Rainfall Types

Yang You, Simin Qu, Yifan Wang, Qingyi Yang, Peng Shi, Yuxun Jiang, Xiaoqiang YangWater 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses stable water isotopes (oxygen-18 and deuterium) to track water sources in a bamboo catchment during two distinct rainfall types: typhoon and plum rain. The findings highlight that accounting for temporal variations in rainfall and throughfall isotopes is crucial for accurate hydrograph separation, and that soil water plays a significant role in runoff generation, especially during plum rain events.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The lower Yangtze River Basin is prone to flood disasters, often triggered by heavy rainfall events during the typhoon and plum rain seasons. To effectively manage water resources and predict floods, a deeper understanding of how catchments respond to these different rainfall types is essential. Specifically, researchers need to better understand where the runoff water comes from (water source dynamics) and how it moves through the landscape (runoff mechanisms). Traditional methods of hydrograph separation, which aim to quantify the contributions of different water sources to streamflow, often rely on simplifying assumptions about isotope behavior. This paper addresses the gap in understanding how the unique characteristics of typhoon and plum rain events, and the isotopic differences between rainfall and throughfall, impact these hydrograph separation results, particularly in a forested watershed.

Methods

The researchers employed stable isotope analysis (δ¹⁸O and δD) as their primary hydrological tracer. They intensively monitored two representative rainfall events: one typhoon and one plum rain event in 2016, within a 1.35 km² bamboo catchment.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Multi-compartment Sampling: Water samples were collected hourly (or every two hours for groundwater) from various hydrological compartments: rainfall, throughfall (rain that has passed through the canopy), surface water, soil water (at 50 cm depth), groundwater, and river water.
  • Isotopic Analysis: Samples were analyzed for δ¹⁸O and δD using mass spectrometry.
  • Hydrograph Separation:
    • Two-Component Model: This model separates streamflow into "old water" (pre-event water from groundwater and soil) and "new water" (event water from rainfall). They specifically investigated the impact of using constant vs. temporally varying isotopic values for rainfall and throughfall.
  • Three-Component Model: This more complex model further differentiates pre-event water into soil water and groundwater, using both isotopic signatures and electrical conductivity (EC) as tracers.
  • Temporal Variation Analysis: A significant focus was placed on analyzing how the isotopic composition of different water sources changed over time during the rainfall events.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from a field monitoring campaign in the Hemuqiao catchment in the lower Yangtze River Basin during two specific rainfall events in 2016:

  • Typhoon Event: September 14, 2016
  • Plum Rain Event: June 24, 2016

The dataset comprises hourly (or bi-hourly) measurements of:

  • Precipitation (rainfall) amount and isotopic composition (δ¹⁸O, δD)
  • Throughfall isotopic composition (δ¹⁸O, δD)
  • Surface water isotopic composition (δ¹⁸O, δD)
  • Soil water isotopic composition (δ¹⁸O, δD)
  • Groundwater isotopic composition (δ¹⁸O, δD)
  • River water (streamflow) isotopic composition (δ¹⁸O, δD)
  • Streamflow discharge (measured via a weir)
  • Electrical Conductivity (EC) of various water sources.

No pre-existing benchmark datasets were used for evaluation; the study generated its own field data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Rainfall vs. Throughfall Isotopes Matter: The isotopic composition of throughfall is not simply a diluted version of rainfall. Differences in their temporal variations significantly impact hydrograph separation results, leading to substantial overestimations of pre-event water if not accounted for.
  • Plum Rain vs. Typhoon Isotopes Differ: Plum rain events tend to have more depleted (lighter) isotopic values in rainfall compared to typhoon events. This is attributed to factors like longer duration and greater precipitation amounts.
  • Soil Water is a Major Player: The three-component model revealed that soil water is a crucial source of runoff, contributing a substantial portion (10.9% to 28.3%) of the total discharge, particularly during plum rain events. This challenges the notion that only direct rainfall or groundwater are the primary contributors.
  • Temporal Dynamics are Key: Assuming constant isotopic values for water sources can lead to misleading hydrograph separation results. Capturing the dynamic, event-scale variations in isotopes is essential for accurate source apportionment.
  • Catchment Specificity: The findings underscore that hydrograph separation models and their assumptions need to be carefully considered and validated for specific catchment types and rainfall regimes.

Key Results

  • Isotopic Variation: Rainfall isotopic variations were generally larger than those in other compartments and were larger for plum rain (δ¹⁸O range of 5.2‰) than for typhoon events (3.7‰). Throughfall also showed variations, but generally less pronounced than direct rainfall.
  • Hydrograph Separation (Two-Component):
    • When temporal variations of rainfall and throughfall isotopes were not considered, pre-event water fractions were overestimated by 26.6% for typhoon events and 15.3% for plum rain events.
  • Average pre-event water fractions were higher for plum rain (84.0% using rainfall, 68.7% using throughfall) than for typhoon events (45.4% using rainfall, 18.8% using throughfall).
  • Hydrograph Separation (Three-Component):
    • Soil water accounted for 10.9% of total discharge during the typhoon event.
  • Soil water accounted for 28.3% of total discharge during the plum rain event.
  • Groundwater contributions were higher during typhoon events (45.4%) compared to plum rain events (24.0%).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Events: The study focused on only two specific rainfall events (one typhoon, one plum rain). While these were representative, a broader range of events would strengthen the conclusions.
  • Single Catchment: The findings are specific to the Hemuqiao bamboo catchment. Further research is needed to assess the applicability of these findings to other catchment types and land covers.
  • Model Assumptions: While the study explored temporal variations, other assumptions inherent in isotopic hydrograph separation models (e.g., complete mixing, conservative tracer behavior) may still influence results.

The authors suggest that future research should focus on:

  • Investigating the influence of both temporal and spatial variations of different water sources on isotopic hydrograph separation.
  • Coupling isotope and hydrological models to improve the understanding of basin runoff generation and concentration.
  • Providing advice for basin water resource planning and flood management based on these improved understandings.

Summary updated

Abstract

Typhoon storm and plum rain are two typical rainfall types in the lower regions of the Yangtze River Basin, which frequently cause flood disasters in China. New information in stable water isotopes offers the opportunity to advance understanding of runoff mechanisms and water source dynamics in response to these two typical rainfall types. We intensively monitored two representative rainfall events in a small bamboo forestry watershed in 2016. Results showed that precipitation isotopic variations during the event were generally larger than those of other monitored compartments (including throughfall, surface overland water, groundwater and river water) and also larger for the plum rain than for the typhoon event (δ18O varied in 5.2‰ and 3.7‰, respectively). Importantly, the differences of isotopic temporal variation between rainfall and throughfall showed significant impacts on the two-component hydrograph separation for both rainfall types (e.g., if not considered, the pre-event water fractions were 26.6% and 15.3% higher for the typhoon and plum rain events, respectively). Furthermore, we evaluated the role of soil water on the three-component isotopic hydrograph separation model; results revealed that soil water accounted for 10.9% and 28.3% of the total discharge in typhoon and plum rain events, respectively. This underpins the important role of soil water dynamics during the rainy season in this humid region.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{you2021applicability,
  author = {Yang You and Simin Qu and Yifan Wang and Qingyi Yang and Peng Shi and Yuxun Jiang and Xiaoqiang Yang},
  title = {{Applicability of Difference in Oxygen-18 and Deuterium of Water Sources and Isotopic Hydrograph Separation in a Bamboo Catchment during Different Rainfall Types}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/w13243531},
}
Figure